2 ms·
The peer review process as known today only took off from the second part of the 20th century, but the article also says: "...On 30 July, Tate replied that he
by belter 5y ago
The peer review process as known today only took off from the second part of the 20th century, but the article also says:
"...On 30 July, Tate replied that he regretted Einstein’s decision to withdraw the paper, but stated that he would not set aside the journal’s review procedure..."
What seems to imply the peer reviewing process was very much already in place since the early 1920-30's at least for the Physical Review.
Also according to historical record:[1]
"...We know that by the 1930s, peer review at the journal was more established. Ledger pages from the time contain the same basic information that we now store in our computer: date of receipt, date sent to a reviewer, date returned, date published or rejected. From these, we see that many papers were sent out for expert evaluation, but also that in many cases, the expert assigned to a manuscript was the Editor, John Tate. We also learn that many papers had no referee assigned to them, and that some of these were accepted and some were rejected. Thus during this period, peer review was growing and making a larger contribution, but decisions were still often made by the editors alone..."
[1] "Editorial: Peer Review per Physical Review"
https://journals.aps.org/edannounce/PhysRevLett.100.050001 https://journals.aps.org/edannounce/PhysRevLett.100.050001