3 ms·
The new battery tech is coming to market every few months, it's been improving regularly for decades in price/performance etc. I always read these articles as
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
The new battery tech is coming to market every few months, it's been improving regularly for decades in price/performance etc.
I always read these articles as having a subtext of "EVs are crap at the moment give 'em another decade" which I don't think resonates with me but is likely popular with certain segments and so gets clicks.
One key repeated talking point is "when our tech gets out the lab in a decade you can fill your EV just like your ICE". I don't want to do that. It was smelly, expensive and inconvenient then, it is even more so now I have a EV that's fully charged every morning when it doesn't even need to be. In 10 years time it'll be nostalgia like a fax machine or sending a telegram.
- tigerlily 5y ago> I always read these articles as having a subtext of "EVs are crap at the moment give 'em another decade" which I don't think resonates with me but is likely popular with certain segments and so gets clicks. You should introduce that certain segment to the Briggs & Stratton stock price :)
- zcw100 5y agoI keep saying that EVs are more like a laptop with wheels than a car with a computer.
- natmaka 5y ago> it's been improving regularly for decades in price/performance etc. Indeed: https://ourworldindata.org/battery-price-decline https://ourworldindata.org/battery-price-decline
- marcodiego 5y agoWe need graphs like these about power density and charging times/cycles.
- IMTDb 5y agoLogarithmic axis warning! We see no "breakthrough", just incremental optimisation (fine in itself). The biggest drop happened between 2000 and 2005, and for the past 15 years the progress have slowed (even after accounting for the logarithmic axis !). The conclusion is that battery technologies are incrementally harder to optimise, that progress is slowing and we shouldn't expect anything major unless an actual breakthrough is made. In other words: if your project isn't viable with the current price point, you may hope for a small discount in few years, but don't expect anything major.
- dghlsakjg 5y agoThat's a scale for the current champion, lithium-ion. All it tells us is that lithium ion is a mature technology, not that batteries in general are a mature technology. There's plenty of scenarios where a more expensive alternative could take over easily. A more energy dense alternative that cost 2x as much would be a massive win for vehicles and especially aircraft where weight is a huge penalty. Alternatively, a technology with a much lower price even with a much lower energy density could enable a lot of green energy storage projects that are currently uneconomical with current battery technology.
- rstuart4133 5y ago> That's a scale for the current champion, lithium-ion. They are all currently lithium-ion. What they are varying is the ion. The ion makes a big difference LiFePO4 is very different to LiMn and its mates (higher cycles and lifetime, lower energy density). A LiS is a different ion yet again. It's not a 3 fold improvement in energy density like the article says, more like twice the density in both volume and weight. And like LiFePO4, no rare earth minerals. It's downfall has been durability (50 cycles or so), but there are now multiple teams announcing 1000 cycles or better in the lab, all using different approaches. It seems inevitable that someone will figure out how to manufacture one of those chemistries at scale in time. Then you will see a step change by a change in chemistry. Without a change in chemistry all you see is improvements in manufacturing which is a gradual thing.
- lazyier 5y agoFor your purposes EVs are not crap. For lots of purposes EVs ARE crap. For example my neighbor's job involves driving specialized supplies to a number of retail outlets every day. It's a very niche business that involves pickup truck and 8 or more hours of driving to do the deliveries. If he was to try to use a EV it would result in unemployment. The reason EVs haven't caught on more isn't because everybody but you is stupid. Electic motor technology is fantastic. Battery technology is miserable. And the reason we don't see "breakthroughs" every month, except those that involve press releases and nothing else, is because ideas and chemistry is cheap. It's easy to get patents. What is hard is actually manufacturing. Taking an idea that works theoretically in a lab versus making it work in reality as a commercial product is similar to learning logging down the street the first time versus winning an olympic medal. In terms of technology what we have now is really just a series of incremental improvements over technology released in the 1990's. The rare earth magnets, the computer control of motor phases, the lithium batteries are all stuff designed for portable Japanese consumer electronics. It's just been supersized and refined for EVs.
- taylodl 5y agoThis is an example of "whatabout-ism." There's going to be a counter-example of someone for which EVs make little sense, but that doesn't mean that EVs make little sense for a large group of drivers or maybe even the majority of cases for which ICE vehicles are currently used. Can EVs 100% replace every single ICE vehicle in every single application? No - and they don't need to in order to be highly useful and provide aggregate benefits.
- BizarroLand 5y agoI think the most likely mid-tier outcome will be that in about 25 years or so, the grand majority of cars on the road will be EV, but that industrial companies will primarily use ICE vehicles, and for road trips and other such short term, long-distance, time essential driving events ICE vehicles will be typically available for rent.
- taylodl 5y ago