3 ms·
"Some have speculated ... it is abundantly clear" Russians left so much destroyed equipment behind them during the retreat from the North that OSINT servers ha
by inglor_cz 5y ago
"Some have speculated ... it is abundantly clear"
Russians left so much destroyed equipment behind them during the retreat from the North that OSINT servers have problems catalogizing it all.
Russian retreat wasn't a Suomussalmi-like rout [0], that much is abundantly clear from the fact that most of the personnel was able to get out (there are neither thousands of dead nor thousands of POWs there).
But the level of attrition they sustained was horrific and it would have gotten only worse once all the bushes and trees started to grow proper foliage (which is great for ambushers) in April and May. They simply had to retreat.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Suomussalmi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Suomussalmi
- sudosysgen 5y agoYou're taking two qualifiers that I assigned to different statements. Images are not a reliable way of getting information on ambushes. There is no way to know if those losses were during ambushes or shortly after the initial advances. Moreover, a big reason the OSINT community had such an issue with cataloguing them is because it was often difficult to tell whose it was and whether it was already accounted for earlier. They indeed sustained a high level of attrition. And yet, it was still a sustainable level of attrition. Russia is lacking soldiers that are needed to attack more than they lack equipment at this point in time.
- KptMarchewa 5y ago>Russia is lacking soldiers that are needed to attack more than they lack equipment at this point in time. I haven't seen any proof of that. There are rather reliable reports that large majority of stockpiled soviet-era weapons (tanks, BMPs...) is unusable in a short term due to large-scale corruption and lack of maintanence.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThere is only evidence for the loss of 425 Russian tanks (following Oryx). Russia has around 5000 post-soviet era T-90s. There is no need for them to tap into their stockpile of Soviet era tanks. Even if they had to and only 10% of those stockpiles were usable short term, it would be enough to replenish their confirmed loses.