3 ms·
Umm... that's the thing, does anyone have NUMBERS to back these claims up? What we know is that military budgets SOAR (duh!), but what about washing machines?
by oblio 5y ago
Umm... that's the thing, does anyone have NUMBERS to back these claims up?
What we know is that military budgets SOAR (duh!), but what about washing machines? Transistors? Ballpoint pens? Antibiotics? The gazillion peace time inventions?
There's no part of me that can actually believe that you can ship off hundreds of thousands of folks off to war, you switch 10-20-40% of your economy to make bullets, and somehow research overall still comes ahead, it makes no sense. Let alone those cases where you country is physically under attack (which is most wars, not every country is as privileged as the US, to never have had a foreign power invade it at any serious scale in the last 200 years).
Research is more concentrated during war time, and more visible, frequently. But does war time research actually outpace peace time research? I don't believe that.
- hef19898 5y agoTechnoligal advances in WW2 that are still valuable today: Radar, ASDIC, modern massproduction, jet engines, rockets, nuclear fission, operations research, modern aviation ingeneral, pressurized aircraft compartments, synthetic fuel Just go on wikipedia and look up global production nimbers of war related stuff between 1939 and 1945 for increased industrial output.
- oblio 5y agoI'm not sure you understand what I'm saying. Yes, war related stuff goes up during wars. What about non-war related stuff? What about peaceful explosions of the global economy and trade? My point is that those most likely surpass wartime growth. Peacetime economic growth > wartime economic growth. Peacetime research > wartime research.
- hef19898 5y agoYou want reliable numbers, look up studies about economic growth during war and peace. Probably nobody will be able to answer that for you around here. As far as research is concerned, without any numbers, I'd assume the focus shifts from civilian research to defence research. As does production. If it surpasses peace time production depends on the scale of the war. That output so should be measured in production units, war has the habbit of screwing up economic metrics.
- throwaway599281 5y agoThere are lots of components of "non-war stuff" that originated from military R&D, and probably would appear much later if it wasn't for the Defense Budget.
- oblio 5y agoAnd how many "war things" originated from non-military R&D? After all every country's GDP is much higher than its military spending and for sure non-military research dwarfs military research. This whole hypothesis seems unsound. It would mean that all civilian research is somehow much, much worse per dollar than military research. I highly doubt that.
- hef19898 5y agoI never said that, did I? You said R&D cannot increase during war, history showed otherwise. Now it's about war R&D outranking peace time R&D, which was never the question.
- oblio 5y agoYou seem to be lost. Here, let me refresh your memory with the original trope: > And war has historically been the impetus for much technological investment. Yes, war also brings innovation. The only question worth answering as a follow up, is, does it bring more than peace? Because otherwise it makes no sense glorifying war, which this line of thinking is fundamentally about.
- baud147258 5y agoyes, but a lot of those advances were based on R&D that was done before the war. I think war is more a time where newer technologies are put to the test, those that don't fail see widespread usage and that's why we associate that war as the introduction of those technologies
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]