4 ms·
After seeing what happened to Libya when they gave up their nuclear ambitions, and what happened to Ukraine when they gave up their nuclear ambitions, how can a
by dotancohen 5y ago
After seeing what happened to Libya when they gave up their nuclear ambitions, and what happened to Ukraine when they gave up their nuclear ambitions, how can anything think that the Iranians would give up their nuclear ambitions?
I live in the state most threatened by a nuclear Iran. But Iran has watched its neighbour to the west be invaded by NATO forces, Iran has watched its neighbour to the east be invaded by NATO forces, and has seen how NATO cowers in front of Russia at the hint of nuclear confrontation. If I were in their shoes, I would not give up the nation's only proven viable deterrent.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agothe crazy part is, just like the proverbial "iraq WMDs" the whole "iran threat" is mostly propaganda. sure they are "enriching uranium" but you have thousands of ALREADY READY nuclear weapons so why would they try to use their currently non-existing weapons against someone who does? i have read on HN that "many countries opposed the US when it invaded iraq, afghanistan, yada yada" but the fact is, they way russia is being sidelined and singled out, no one has had the balls to do that with USA even when they managed to destroy sovereign nations in the interests of "free democracy" and other shenanigans.
- dotancohen 5y ago> the crazy part is, just like the proverbial "iraq WMDs" the whole "iran threat" is mostly propaganda. Here we disagree. Iran is a real threat, they are major backering force behind both Hamas and Hezbollah. The Islamic Republic (distinct from the Persian people) is ideologically driven and regularly chants Death to America and Death to Israel. I could definitely see the friction with Iran going hot.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agogo on and disagree. "regularly chants Death to America" does this really affect you to a point that you and your government are scared of threats and want to preemptively want to remove the threat? " Death to Israel." why do you care about israel as an american? are you a citizen of that country also that you feel a sense of insecurity towards that? " Iran is a real threat, they are major backering force behind both Hamas and Hezbollah". cool so america can destroy IRAQ, afghanistan, libya, syria, vietnam among others but irans threat are a concern for you. good.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dotancohen 5y agoI'm glad that you live in a country where you feel that threats to exterminate you are empty and can be dismissed. Might I guess from your comment that you live in a country with two oceans between it and any aggressors? My own country is in fact surrounded by people who have tried multiple times to wipe us off the map with bombs, and failing that, now try to wipe us off the map with lie campaigns to influence social opinion. There is no reason to think that they won't continue to use bombs in the future. Perhaps if someone had a literal (not proverbial) warhead pointed at your children, then you would be less cavalier and naive.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agofunny you mention that. from your comments now it appears that you might live in israel and not the US as i initially made it to be so my question remains. Why, as an israeli you care if iran threatens america? i kinda live in the middle of a clusterfuck also called "kashmir". go and look up the atrocities and war crimes being committed by india and pakistan against my fellow citizens on an ongoing basis and consider my words then. i know how it looks like when you have men barging in your homes and they take you away, never to be seen again or your homes being targeted and razed to the ground. to not knowing if you will return home at the end of the day so yeah, i am in the middle of this and can say that. >Perhaps if someone had a literal (not proverbial) warhead pointed at your children, then you would be less cavalier and naive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gawkadal_massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gawkadal_massacre
- mcv 5y agoIt's entirely understandable that Iran fears a US or NATO attack, but I also think it's incredibly stupid for so many people in the US to consider such an attack. For one thing, the current situation of Iran is largely the result of the US/UK overthrow of their democratic government in 1953. This has only caused grief and problems. The attacks on Iraq and Afghanistan didn't really accomplish much either. The US should stop trying to solve problems through war, because it's pretty clear that doesn't work. Use soft power instead; much more effective.
- Physkal 5y agoSoft power failed to stop Putin from invading Ukraine, twice.
- mcv 5y agoRussia is not the same as Iran, though. One big difference is that Russia is the aggressor. Against Iran, the US would be the aggressor. Force may be unavoidable to stop aggression, but if you want a safer world, invading random countries for questionable reasons is a really bad idea.
- kingcharles 5y agoIsrael might also be the aggressor. And Israel has nukes, in violation of the NPT.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoHard power and threats also failed to stop North Korea from developing thermonuclear weapons and ICBMs they can deliver to North America. Can’t see how it’s going to work out differently for Iran.
- eynsham 5y agoSoft power in Russia would have been something along the lines of a Marshall Plan starting from the dissolution of the USSR, and could well have worked.