5 ms·
Oh, thats different from what I've heard. Do you have a source? I'm wondering what the context and details were. My understanding was that downvotes without co
by giantg2 5y ago
Oh, thats different from what I've heard. Do you have a source? I'm wondering what the context and details were.
My understanding was that downvotes without comments are appropriate/encouraged for specific types of comments, like bots, spam, comments without any substance, or violations of the guidelines. Essentially, comments in reply to those do not supply any additonal content or contribute to the discussion (hence the additional clarification in the guideline about boring reading in relation to comments on voting), and responding to them can just turn into a thread of comments that lack any substance. However, a comment that seeks to discuss various points related to the article and are downvoted simply because people disagree seem to violate the principle of curiosity and discussion.
Basically, I thought questions out of curiosity, even around downvotes were ok. Also that downvoting is more or less targeted at guideline violations and not just disagreement. But Maybe I'm taking dang out of context. Like I'm not trying to argue my downvotes and change their minds. I just want to know why I was downvoted so I can learn.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30346954 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30346954
- tptacek 5y agoThe guidelines couldn't be much clearer about this: Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. This thread is fulfilling the Guideline Prophecy now, so here's where I bow out.
- giantg2 5y agoThat's odd since you were the one to resurrect this thread that I thought was finished. I'm still waiting for your source on this: "Allowing for (even encouraging) downvotes without comment or explanation is an explicit goal of the site, which was designed by someone who was irritated with the clutter of superficial negative comments."
- pvg 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16131314 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16131314 Although, again, the guidelines are super-explicit about not going on about voting, not dingleberrypicking one thing that irritates you in a post, etc. And generally, you can just type author:dang [your topic of choice] into search and get a learned opinion. You'll find most of your interpretation of the guidelines above to be inaccurate.
- giantg2 5y ago"Although, again, the guidelines are super-explicit about not going on about voting" I merely asked for additionally context for a conversation. Others have instigated this longer conversation. They don't seem super explicit if two guidelines conflict with each other, especially if it conflicts the core principles of curiosity and discussion. "not dingleberrypicking one thing that irritates you in a post" Again, if you read back you can see that it wasn't one thing in my comment, but that others decided to engage on one part of my comment and largely ignore the other. "And generally, you can just type author:dang [your topic of choice] into search and get a learned opinion." Which I did, and posted the previous link that seems to indicate that downvotes are more for comments breaking guidelines than for disagreeing without comment. However, I do see that the links posted by you have pg stating that downvoting is used for disagreement. Seems a little odd though, that it's purpose is for disagreement but we can't downvote replies that we disagree with. This logical issue seems to indicate that it's not just for disagreement, and that debate and discussion is also valued (as stated in the guidelines). "You'll find most of your interpretation of the guidelines above to be inaccurate." Or perhaps you are misapplying the guidelines because you misunderstand the facts of this scenario.
- pvg 5y agoNo, the facts are you dingleberrypicked, used a trope and complained about downvoting. You also think political discussions aren't allowed here, that the goal of 'curiosity' is more or less whatever you want, that downvoters owe you receipts, etc. You can literally find big dollops of moderator comments directly contradicting all of these - you simply happen to be wrong about these straightforward things. They aren't any less straightforward because you don't like them and you haven't even got around to acknowledging you are wrong about even the straightforwardest. Let's wrap up here.