6 ms·
Police seized $10k from him. a court ruled he had no right to an attorney
- cryptodan 5y agoWow do the state couldn't provide him with representation?
- standardUser 5y ago"Central to the American criminal justice system is that every defendant is innocent until proven guilty. But civil forfeiture isn't a criminal action; it's a civil one, occurring in civil court, where defendants are not necessarily entitled to a lawyer."
- voakbasda 5y agoCivil forfeiture is a crime against the people. The practice needs to stop.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoPart of the problem is that it happens to people who have stuff to lose (because people with little to lose don't wind up sitting on 10k in cash or similiar). If this happened to people with nothing to lose there's be a big enough body count that we'd have solved it by now.
- juanani 5y ago
- tehwebguy 5y agoThere is literally no legal way to stop this from happening. Even if it is made illegal everywhere there are effectively zero DAs willing to prosecute police for anything they do on the job.
- chrismcb 5y agoOk. But you can make civil asset forfeiture illegal. Now they may so seize your property, but it would be a more straightforward fourth amendment battle
- tehwebguy 5y agoThey are literally stealing from the people they are charged with serving in broad daylight with zero actual justification, if it’s made illegal they will simply not give you a receipt. The individuals that use “civil forfeiture” are not like normal people, they are movie mafia goons and they cannot be reformed.
- jmyeet 5y agoAnother day, another disgusting display of what should be unconstitutional government overreach. Let's review: 1. Civil forfeiture is an action against the property, not the owner. And property has no rights. How convenient. This justification gets even more ridiculous when you consider the property is alleged to be the proceeds of crime but this isn't a criminal action; 2. The action to recover such money is a civil action not a criminal one so no right for the government to provide you with legal representation (as noted in this article); and 3. Police departments have a direct profit motive to seize asets without due process as they get to keep most or all of the proceeds. The direct profit motive leads to "forfeiture corridors". This is where typically drugs will go in one direction and the resulting cash will go in the other. The police will set up to seize only the cash going in one direction and not care one iota about the drugs going the other way. This is disgusting and has no place in the rule of law.
- fraa-orolo 5y ago> The direct profit motive leads to "forfeiture corridors". This is where typically drugs will go in one direction and the resulting cash will go in the other. The police will set up to seize only the cash going in one direction and not care one iota about the drugs going the other way. That just sounds like drug dealing with extra steps.
- site-packages1 5y agoNot that I agree with civil forfeiture, in fact I'm highly against it, but I don't think of it as drug dealing even if the money comes from drugs. They police did not manufacture or sell the drugs, so it's a pretty big leap to call seizing cash drug dealing in any form. Maybe "theft with extra steps" because they do in fact essentially steal the money and add the extra steps to legally inoculate themselves against the consequences if they were to go and just steal the money.
- standardUser 5y agoIf the focus is on skimming off the top instead of actually stopping the flow of drugs, then the cops become a component in the illegal drug market. They are essentially running protection for that market... from themselves.
- daenz 5y agoCan someone explain to me how civil forfeiture doesn't create a perverse incentive by making police departments dependent on the existence and availability of (potentially illicit) funds?
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoIt is clear from the many stories of civil asset forfeiture that this is exactly what it does.
- neuralspark 5y agoNo one can, because it does.
- woodruffw 5y agoThat is what it does, and we've seen a number of concrete examples of that over the years. ProPublica has done some excellent reporting[1] on it. [1]: https://www.propublica.org/article/police-say-seizing-property-without-trial-helps-keep-crime-down-a-new-study-shows-theyre-wrong https://www.propublica.org/article/police-say-seizing-proper...
- daenz 5y ago>For some law enforcement agencies, forfeiture funds have accounted for as much as 20% of their budgets, and are sometimes used for seemingly nonessential purchases. Jesus, this is depressing.
- chrismcb 5y agoNo. No one can explain how it doesn't. I was recently watching one video where the state basically outlawed civil forfeiture. But the fed hasn't. And the feds will share the profit with all agencies involved. So police in that state will still sieze money and turn it over to the feds and get a cut back.
- Quillbert182 5y agoThis sort of stuff is why cryptocurrency was created. Despite its flaws, it does impede the governments ability to take your assets without criminal charges.
- Zhenya 5y agoSo that anyone can steal your money on hole-ridden exchanges and not just the police?
- Quillbert182 5y agoThat's how it's ended up, which is a shame. The idea behind cryptocurrency had the potential to be used for good, but the execution has been so poorly pulled off that it ended up being scams, speculation, and air pollution.
- gruez 5y agoIf you're not a trader and just want to hide your wealth from the government, why would you need to keep your coins on "hole-ridden exchanges"?
- kurisufag 5y agoonly very rarely do intelligent people get their wallets drained -- its mostly young people hopping on the cultural movement (e.g. NFTs, games) without actually knowing what they are doing. if you abide by a few basic principles (keep your wallet cold, actually read through smart contracts before executing them, read the specification of everywhere you are putting your tokens) you'll be just fine.
- gkoberger 5y agoI think you'll find that if the government wants your money, they'll get it. Doesn't matter how it's stored.
- nullc 5y agoThe prior poster's point wasn't that the government couldn't get it, it was that they couldn't get it without due process: They'd have to use their ability to imprison the target to get his securely stored Bitcoin, and in doing to they'd implicate his constitutional rights. To the sibling comment, -- sure Bitcoin exchanges are sadly a security crapshow but that its a brief exposure (and one can obtain Bitcoin without an exchange, though the alternatives have their own costs). Once you've obtained and securely stored your Bitcoins they should be safe from both hackers and government due process violations. It's not always easy to correctly store Bitcoin, but it's possible which is something you can't say about other equivalently liquid assets when your threat model includes things like the abuses described in this article.
- willcipriano 5y agoHas there ever been a incident of civil asset forfeiture for a white collar crime? Say the coast guard seizing the yacht of someone suspected of obtaining it via insider trading?
- qohen 5y agoHas there ever been a incident of civil asset forfeiture for a white collar crime? Also from reason.com (2/18/22): "The FBI Seized Almost $1 Million From This Family—and Never Charged Them With a Crime" [0] In April 2020, agents showed up at the Nelsons' home and informed them that Carl—a former real estate transaction manager for Amazon—was under investigation for allegedly depriving the tech behemoth of his "honest services." In plainer terms, they accused him of showing favor to certain developers and securing them deals in exchange for illegal kickbacks. "That never happened and is exactly why I've fought as long and hard as I have," he says. "It's that simple." [0] https://reason.com/2022/02/18/fbi-seized-almost-1-million-from-amy-sterner-carl-nelson-never-charged-them-with-a-crime/ https://reason.com/2022/02/18/fbi-seized-almost-1-million-fr...
- ncmncm 5y agoSo, not really for crime, but for offending the powerful. Which is always treated worse.
- ropable 5y agoTo an outside observer, the US is a place of wild contradictions. On the one hand, you have a (perceived) high aversion to "government overreach". On the other hand, you have....this. I know that it's an enormous country with an extremely heterogenous political landscape, but it boggles the mind that this situation could be allowed there.
- standardUser 5y agoWhat's truly remarkable is the homogenous attitude towards these issues despite the enormity and diversity of the country. During the 1980's and 1990's, there was a near-universal agreement that civil rights could be violated in pursuit of drug crimes and that penalties for those crimes would be harsher than even violent and sexual crimes. Many of the most aggressive laws were passed by liberals in Congress and in liberal states. If people ever wonder why there is such a backlash against "Boomers", the drug war and the completely insane laws that came with it are a huge part of the reason.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- syshum 5y agoDisinformation, and a huge number of families decimated by a massive drug addiction problem in the US Law Enforcement, and the Policing for profit supporters have massive budgets to convince victims of drug addiction that law enforcement is the proper place for the "war" on drugs to be fought As such while under normal circumstances American's do have high aversion to government overreach, Americans have allowed massive amounts of overreach under the guise of protecting people from the surge of drugs However after nearly 50 years of this "war", all we have to show for it is higher and higher drug addiction rates, and a Militarized police force that is more fitting for dictatorship than a democracy
- everforward 5y ago> As such while under normal circumstances American's do have high aversion to government overreach, Americans have allowed massive amounts of overreach under the guise of protecting people from the surge of drugs I would rephrase that to "Americans have a high aversion to overreach exercised on people like them". The Patriot Act was popular when it was passed, and only became unpopular when people realized it was being used on them. Civil Forfeiture only really came to light when it started impacting "normal" people. We're largely fine with overreach when it only impacts foreign citizens, criminals (especially drunk drivers, drug dealers, terrorists and pedophiles, but excluding white collar crime), and undocumented workers. I still see very little concern for how the judicial system places enormous pressure on criminal defendants to take plea deals. CBP has enormous extra-legal authority when near the border. We've really only ever been concerned with overreach that's likely to impact us as individuals.