4 ms·
I'm trying to take the perspective of a founder here. Let's suppose I have a startup that's showing signs of success and growth. I'm some combination of funded
by philwelch 15y ago
I'm trying to take the perspective of a founder here. Let's suppose I have a startup that's showing signs of success and growth. I'm some combination of funded and profitable that means I can keep running for awhile. My startup have the potential to grow into the billions. I'm earning a subsistence salary and have no significant assets aside from my equity in the startup itself.
If an acquirer offered enough for the company that I personally would make at least 10 million from it, I wouldn't hesitate to sell at that point. My VC isn't hungry or broke like I am, he's just an investor who rationally wants me to go for the billions. My employees aren't hungry or broke like I am, they're earning market salaries and their only hope of a decent equity payout is for me to go for the billions. But I'm just subsisting and I don't have the stomach to avoid cashing out early from an acquisition. We have a problem.
Now let's suppose I raise another VC round and partially cash out. Now I have my millions, just like the VC's. I'm still left with a good stake in the company. Now our interests are aligned; I want to go for the billions now too. I no longer have any reason to sell it short.
Truth be told, I'm not a founder and I've never faced this myself. Maybe even taking a startup to this point requires crazy, dedicated risk-takers who will turn down significant wealth for the promise of absurd wealth, and I'm just not that kind of person. Maybe if I ever invest the time and effort into a startup necessary to get to that point I'll grow the stomach to take crazy risks. But I just don't understand the argument that paying founders a few million in a late VC round makes them less motivated to swing for the fences and build billion dollar businesses. Hungry people don't turn down a decent meal for the promise of a huge feast later on.
- sek 15y agoThen why not go for an IPO? These companies don't go public because they are not sustainable yet. This is what VCs are for, they take the risk to lose 100% of their investment. When now the founder cashes out, he is not in the same boat as the VC any more. The investors have to trust you, because they have almost zero influence in the company. When you now cash out then they are asking, why? It is a sign that the founder himself doesn't believe in the valuation. When the founder would be sure that his company will be worth billions, he is loosing money by cashing out. It is simply unfair, because there is a big information asymmetry between the two parties. There may be exceptions when there is a personal problem, but most of the time a decent salary is enough for everyone. Anyway, i think this is better than in the new economy. Back then the little guy got screwed and now professional investors. I don't feel sorry for them, they could do something against it with an endorsement. For an outsider it should just be a warning sign not to be too confident in these startups.
- 0x12 15y agoAn IPO may be much further down the line and not everybody wants to (or has to) run a public company. 'Going Public' is not just a positive thing, it comes with a large pile of headaches as well and it isn't unusual at all to see a big chunk of money go towards all the duties that come with being a public company. On top of that you have to weigh every word you say in public.
- 0x12 15y agoYou've nailed it perfectly. It's all about risk and trade-offs between security and risk.
- rscale 15y agoI agree with you completely. It's rational for a "hungry" founder to prefer a 50% chance of a $250MM exit to a 20% chance of a $2B exit which is exactly wrong for the VC. I like that some investors are wising up to the reality that you can get better outcomes if you make sure the entrepreneur's utility curve is aligned with the investors'. That said, I do think there's a difference between providing the entrepreneur liquidity and buying him a megayacht.
- jlarocco 15y agoI'm also not a founder, so this might be a dumb idea.. But if you're doing well enough to have several employees and funding and stuff, wouldn't you pay yourself a reasonable salary? It seems hard to believe a company could be doing that well, but the founder would be in dire straits financially.
- shabble 15y agoThe simple answer is: because every single dollar/pound/yen you're not paying yourself, you could be using to grow your business. Imagine you're semi-profitable, you've got enough to pay wages for a few months while you finish off your next iteration/product and bring in new cash. Then your project gets delayed, and all of a sudden you're running out of cash to pay the actual programmers. Do you try to make them take a cut and risk them jumping ship, or do you cut your own salary to close the cash gap? These sorts of things happen with (from what little I know) quite alarming regularity. The founders are almost certainly taking out less cash than everyone else up until the equity starts being traded. The same sorts of decisions can occur even if you're not desperately squeezed for cash. Do you bump your personal wage up, or do you use it to hire that kickass designer you just found who can really polish up your stuff and give you a better chance at success? The whole founder-as-martyr approach explains why they feel justified in taking out early cash, and why there's a general feeling that '1st employee' shouldn't get any early cash - they've already gotten their fair share through their wages up til now. It gets a lot more complicated when your employee is taking a pay-cut to work for you on the hopes you'll succeed, but then it's up to you and them to negotiate some sort of fair compensation scheme when you do get cash in.