4 ms·
Although the article is about getting a PhD later in life, many of the comments here have been about the merits of getting a PhD (or a Masters then a PhD) right
by tzs 5y ago
Although the article is about getting a PhD later in life, many of the comments here have been about the merits of getting a PhD (or a Masters then a PhD) right after finishing undergraduate school.
The usual points against are the very low probability of having a successful academic career due to the difficulty of getting a tenured position and the very low chance of actually making a major research contribution to your field, and when you then give up an an academic career and get a job in programming or finance the opportunity cost of the say 6 years you spent not doing that job.
It is true that the longer you delay starting that programming or finance career, the farther the gap in income and wealth between you and your fellow undergraduates who went straight into programming or finance.
It's like a rocket race in a Newtonian universe. If we have identical rockets capable of constant 1/10 g acceleration and have lifelong race but you get a 6 year head start, the farther we get into the race the bigger the distance between us.
In that rocket race after 5 years you'd be 0.4 parsec farther along than me, and you'd be moving away at 0.52 c.
After 10 years, you'd be 1.3 parsecs ahead of me, and going 0.64 c faster than me.
After 15, the gap is 2.3 parsecs, and you are going 0.65 c faster than me.
At 30 years, you are 5.1 parsecs ahead of me, and going 0.68 c faster than me.
At 50 years, you are 8.9 parsecs ahead of me, and going 0.72 c faster than me.
But in terms of time at 10 years you are 6 years ahead of me. And at year 50 you are still 6 years ahead of me. Anyplace you reach I reach 6 years later.
Both of us are going to make so much money that unless we have unusually expensive tastes and hobbies we are both going to be quite well off when we retire even if we retire at the same age, able to continue to live our preferred lifestyles. That 6 year head start of yours largely just means you'll leave a bigger estate when you die.
I think this takes a lot of the force out of the opportunity cost argument.
On the pro-PhD side on the other hand, at least for STEM PhDs, is that it is ~6 years where are getting paid to learn and research something of great interest to you. And if you turn out to be one of the rare people who actually can have a successful academic career this is the only way you are going to find that out.
And don't forget the regret cost in not doing it. I didn't seriously consider graduate school because I was sure I would end up programming anyway. But I didn't lose my interest in math and physics. Many a PBS Space Time episode makes me wish I had a much deeper understanding of physics than I do now. It is possible to learn much of that on your own, but it is a lot harder and slower than it would have been had if I had went to grad school for it.