4 ms·
>a polygamous marriage necessarily requires that 2 people of the same sex are married to each other I never heard of that idea before, but I didn't really know
by vba616 5y ago
>a polygamous marriage necessarily requires that 2 people of the same sex are married to each other
I never heard of that idea before, but I didn't really know anything about how it is in fact defined where it is legal and customary.
I found something that describes the "Law of Marriage Act of 1971" of Tanzania:
"Under Section 10(1) of the Act, a marriage is defined as “the
voluntary union of a man and a woman, intended to last for their joint lives,” and may either be monogamous or polygamous (or potentially polygamous). Further, under Section 57, no wife in a polygamous marriage holds a superior position in matrimonial homes than any other wife."
I read that as saying that polygamy consists of a set of bilateral relationships having one person in common, and not a complete graph of all possible relationships between the individuals.
The paper I found that in seems to be about issues arising in divorce in Tanzania.
The problem is stated as:
"Because non-divorcing co-wives cannot be a party to divorce proceedings, and only parties can claim a stake in marital assets, the LMA currently offers no means for non-divorcing co-wives to claim a stake in marital property"
This sounds to me like wives are not considered to have a relationship to each other, and that has social implications which are important.
One can't overgeneralize based on this one source and one country, but it tends to make me more confident in my guess that "non-transitive" is the norm.
- dane-pgp 5y agoThanks for researching that. I agree that, in practice, societies which allow polygamy probably have non-transitive marriages, and they could theoretically allow women to have two husbands so as not to give men more rights than women. In an alternate reality where the US constitution happened to define marriage as between "a man and a woman", I could imagine activists pushing for states to allow polygamy so that two men or two women could "indirectly" marry, and pressuring the government to avoid the issues experienced in Tanzania by writing laws and policies which effectively treat the connection between the leaf nodes as equal to their connection to the root node when considering questions of divorce, taxation, inheritance, parenthood, etc.