4 ms·
It's not much an edge case in the sense of those, which mostly concern software authors making incorrect assumptions about the data in fields, but rather a "not
by tzs 5y ago
It's not much an edge case in the sense of those, which mostly concern software authors making incorrect assumptions about the data in fields, but rather a "not even realizing we need a field" case, but music library managers are often quite annoying when dealing with classical music.
They really want to fit everything into the artist/album/song scheme, and that doesn't really work well for much classical music. In classical music most of us would want something like composer/piece/orchestra/conductor/performers (the "performers" field would be for performers in addition to the normal orchestra, such as soloists or choruses), and it should be possible to change the sort key order among those fields.
- jay-anderson 5y agoDefinitely. Pieces end up being listed something like "Symphony No.3, Mvt. II", but they only show the performer which is the orchestra playing rather than the composer so I have no idea which symphony it is. I haven't seen any service get classical music right. I think your list is pretty good (composer/piece/orchestra/conductor/performers). It'd be nice to also have a field for the movement. Also I totally agree with custom sort order being a must. E.g. for choir pieces swap out 'orchestra' for 'choir', for piano pieces only include 'performer' field, concertos should have the 'soloist' before the orchestra, etc.
- CharlesW 5y ago> …music library managers are often quite annoying when dealing with classical music. Apple will apparently be solving this problem this year with a dedicated "Apple Classical" app, the origin of which is their Primephonic (https://www.primephonic.com/ https://www.primephonic.com/) acquihire. "Why are you shutting down Primephonic?" "To focus on creating an even better experience for customers around the world. Apple Music plans to launch a dedicated classical music app next year combining Primephonic’s classical user interface that fans have grown to love with more added features."
- nerdponx 5y agoA lot of music library managers (including good old iTunes) let you add a lot of various and esoteric song tag data as columns in the track list. The problem was always that the column arrangement that makes sense for one style of music doesn't make sense for another. One missing feature that I've never seen in a music library application is the ability to have "presets" for these column headers that you can easily switch between. So you can turn on the "classical" preset which shows Composer, Performer, etc., and you can turn on the "contemporary" preset which shows Artist and Album.
- Semaphor 5y agoThat’s actually something MediaMonkey [0] (Windows-only) had for a long time (I assume the current electron version as well, I use the last native version). Classical is one of the defaults, but you can add whatever. It’s one of my favorite pieces of software, a true music library manager and not a music player with some management features tacked on. [0]: https://www.mediamonkey.com/ https://www.mediamonkey.com/
- Aidevah 5y agoAgreed, I've tested many self-hosted music streaming servers and decided to settle with navidrome in the end but not without major reservations. I personally don't mind sorting music via album/song, but the lack of composer field is really painful. Unfortunately the omission of composer information occurs in the subsonic api, which have a large number of compatible players, so adding the field is not as straightforward if one wishes to do it in an interoperable way. I used to be quite happy with a local music library and playing it with mpd, but at some point I got sick of maintaining over 100 GB of music library across multiple devices. The streaming solutions for mpd are quite awkward to use, otherwise I would have stuck with it just to get the composer field.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThere's an analogous problem going on on musescore.com, where you're supposed to list the work your score is based on. Viewing a score on the site will then include links to other scores based on the same work. I uploaded several pieces from Swan Lake, and listed each of them as the particular piece that they were. For example, https://musescore.com/user/36584999/scores/6642212 https://musescore.com/user/36584999/scores/6642212 is Swan Lake, No. 4 (Pas de trois), part IV. But every time I list a piece like this, it gets "corrected" to the canonical reference, which is "Swan Lake". And the "other scores based on the same work" are totally useless, because they can be any piece from anywhere in the ballet. It's more than 600 pages long! Where's the value add from removing my indication of exactly which piece of Swan Lake I just scored?
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoIt's a sleeve notes problem. Ideally you'd want a complete copy of all the info in the sleeve/inlay. This includes some combination of headline writer/composer, producer, conductor, headline performer, co-writers, arrangers, session players, engineer, studio, lyrics, and random sleeve notes/essay, possibly in multiple languages. Per track. Plus artwork. With credits. Plus random thank-yous and special thank-yous to sponsors and other contributors. The importance of each field varies with each project. For classical conductor showcase projects the conductor is the headliner. For classical composers, obviously it's the composer. For compilations it can be a concept like "Classical Chill" or "Early Music from the 15th Century." For pop projects it's usually the band/artist name. For movie tie-ins, it's the movie, or perhaps the franchise. And so on. You get all of this for free on CD/vinyl labels, and the fact that it's freeform doesn't matter because the sleeve artwork and visual placing of the elements make it clear who/what matters. Trying to fit this into a single fixed metadata schema is madness. It can't be done. This is one of those situations where trying to data-fy the information leads to huge loss of detail. You get some nominal (poor) searchability, but you give up a huge amount of interesting supporting information. What the industry needs is a digital sleeve note standard which can handle all of this and more. But metadata is designed for sales and stream tracking, not for user satisfaction. Which is why it's so bad at capturing what users want.