3 ms·
"But why is your project here establishing a narrow definition of racism with a high burden of proof?" I don't believe my statement is looking for a narrow def
by giantg2 5y ago
"But why is your project here establishing a narrow definition of racism with a high burden of proof?"
I don't believe my statement is looking for a narrow definition,
just a valid one. I'd like some level of proof. It doesn't have to be high. The real problem here is the insinuation that people who bring up potentially valid issues related to a low income housing project are racist. Their concern could be a valid one with no racial basis.
"What matters here is the impact, not the intention."
Please, do show me a definition that shows intent is not a component. The dictionaries I looked at do not agree with you. Even then, would it be racist for you to assume a specific race is disproportionately affected by low income housing? If a race is affected disproportionately by lack of housing, are you inviting any of the affected people to share your home? Does that make you racist?
"Systems and policies that have disparate racial impacts are racist."
No, they have "disparate racial impacts".
By your definition, what system isn't racist? Every system has some disparity of racial impact, even if it is meritorious (take the recent posts on here about Harvard quotas and Asians). I firmly believe that without intent, a system is not racist, but could have racial disparities - there is a difference. The definition you're trying to push seems to be more worthy of the insults you're pushing at me.
You mention a racist policy. What policy is that? As there is not one mentioned in the context of sentence mentioning racism.