3 ms·
I wonder what is actually looked at or calculated for number of bedrooms and services offered. In my opinion, people's preferences for more stuff/room/services
by giantg2 5y ago
I wonder what is actually looked at or calculated for number of bedrooms and services offered. In my opinion, people's preferences for more stuff/room/services are what drives housing prices in general, especially location.
It seems racist to call people who are concerned about the project racists. Some of them may be, but some of those people concerned about traffic may have legitimate concerns. I've seen it for fancy developments too.
Edit: why downvote?
- anamax 5y agoIt's poor form to point out that a racism accusation is one of the most effective political attacks/responses. Said effectiveness is not that dependent on the "truth" of said accusation. (The sneer quotes are because "you're a racist" is somewhat ill-defined, vague, etc.)
- 6510 5y agoIt's twitter! He is going over the countless hurdles one has to successfully jump. Each has been designed to do something sensible but may turn out quite senseless. Twitter has room for a single example of that not an elaborate write up. He also illustrates how frustration grows and one might not have the patience to sensibly respond to the thousand cuts. There should be a single government body that deals with the hurdles in a timely, professional and affordable way.
- 6510 5y agoHe is referring to racist racists.
- chihuahua 5y agowe should always be careful to distinguish between real racists and true racists.
- giantg2 5y agoAs opposed to...?
- 6510 5y agoAs opposed to people who are concerned about the project for other perhaps more palatable reasons.
- giantg2 5y agoI didn't see any context that would support that, given that the only mention of people it these sorts of concerns were labeled as racists. Did I miss something?
- pvg 5y agoThe thread talks about hypothetical, rather than specific people who oppose development in bad faith using other reasons to hide their true, often racially- or class- tinged reasons. You decided to call the author of this thread (a real person) a racist because they mention imaginary racists.
- giantg2 5y ago"You decided to call the author of this thread (a real person) a racist because they mention imaginary racists." Did I? You might want to read back. I said calling people racist for bringing up traffic issues could itself seem racist. "The thread talks about hypothetical, rather than specific people who oppose development in bad faith using other reasons to hide their true, often racially- or class- tinged reasons." Did I miss the part about classist people? I only saw NIMBY and race mentioned. Are these hypothetical people? It seems the author is using real life experiences in this article, so in this context I assume they are talking about real, yet unnamed, examples they have witnessed. If not, it seems odd that they would offer up detailed, named, real examples for other parts, but not for this. Seems a bit hand wavy about it happening at any significant scale as well as in it's implication that people concerned about a traffic issue are all racists since there is no mention of the legitimate concern.
- whymauri 5y agoThis thread is so deep in recursively calling groups racist I'm not sure who we are talking about anymore. Recursion depth met >_<
- lr4444lr 5y agoYou have a point, but it may be a bit obtuse to call racist accusations themselves racist. Those call outs may or may not be correct, ignorant, or even a calculated dirty way to discredit someone, but how are they themselves racist?
- giantg2 5y agoPretty much why I worded it the way I did - to bring attention to they potential hypocrisy or lack of standards around calling people racist based on a concern (traffic, or claiming racism) that does not display racism. So yeah, my calling the accusation racist is only as founded as the author's, which is essentially based on stereotypes and supposition. In my case, that supposition is that the person making the accusation must be relying on the race of the person raising the traffic issues in calling them racist.
- giraffe_lady 5y agoYou don't need a view into someone's soul to call them a racist. Racism in this context isn't necessarily about individual interpersonal malice. If a development would greatly help members of a historically oppressed group and somewhat hinder members of a historically powerful group, and you knowingly argue against the development on those grounds, you're supporting a policy that has unjust racial consequences. "A racist" is a useful shorthand for a person taking those actions in that context. It's not a permanent immutable judgement about the inner workings of their mind or motivations. Just an assessment of some of their actions.
- giantg2 5y ago"If a development would greatly help members of a historically oppressed group and somewhat hinder members of a historically powerful group, and you knowingly argue against the development on those grounds, you're supporting a policy that has unjust racial consequences." Are they arguing against it on those grounds? The tweets don't go any further than calling people racists that bring up traffic or environmental issues.
- 01100011 5y agoYeah, from the Twitter feed: > You'll meet some racist neighbors I'm onboard with the notion that a significant amount of opposition to low-income housing in many areas stems both from racism and fear of racist stereotypes. That said, I think a lot of home owners are very defensive regarding their illiquid assets and generally just don't like things that affect their property values. Low-income housing is one of those things. Less wealthy folks moving in nearby is one of those things. Put simply, I don't think you have to be a racist to be a classist. Whether that is any better, well, probably not, but call it what it is.
- giantg2 5y ago"Put simply, I don't think you have to be a racist to be a classist. Whether that is any better, well, probably not, but call it what it is." That is pretty much my thought. I do feel that the bulk is classist and not racist though.
- deepakhj 5y agoIf you'd like to get a taste of what NIMBYs are like, this thread covers the Livable California meeting today. https://twitter.com/cafedujord/status/1510302326837301252?s=20&t=QFlS3D0Ctb6dU4OcwERpLg https://twitter.com/cafedujord/status/1510302326837301252?s=...