4 ms·
>in reality that's a weird argument, women or lgbt or people of color don't need to be better in order to be accepted, they should be accepted by default. In r
by krapp 5y ago
>in reality that's a weird argument, women or lgbt or people of color don't need to be better in order to be accepted, they should be accepted by default.
In reality every non-majority demographic has to be better in order to be accepted. They often have to work harder just to reach the default that the majority takes for granted, because that system works with the majority, and against everyone else.
- car_analogy 5y agoDo they? Here is the composition of Ivy League non-international students, courtesy of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30338742 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30338742: Ivy League US Ratio Jewish 17.2% 2.4% 7.16 Asian 19.6% 5.3% 3.71 White (incl. Jewish) 50.3% 61.5% 0.82 Hispanic 11.4% 17.6% 0.65 Black 7.8% 12.7% 0.61 White (non-Jewish) 33.1% 59.1% 0.56
- giraffe_lady 5y agowhat'd those numbers look like in 1980 no reason just curious.
- stormbrew 5y agoWhich column identifies how hard people in any of these demographics worked to achieve this outcome?
- car_analogy 5y agoYou want to attribute different outcomes to differences in behavior by race? In this case, you're saying that Jewish students are 11x more hard-working than Hispanic ones, and Asian students are 6x more hard-working than Black ones? Which other racial disparities do you attribute to differences in behavior?
- magicalist 5y agoYou're the one who responded with the start of a refutation ("Do they?"). It's reasonable to expect you to actually make the argument.
- car_analogy 5y agoI'm the only one that presented any data at all - the original comment simply asserted something was true, without backing it up in any way. It's reasonable to expect a refutation to contain at least some data, instead of dismissing what data we do have as not complete enough, and reverting back to the original fact-free assertion.
- stormbrew 5y agoYou can't just throw up a data table and go "ok I refuted it!" That's not an argument, it's just some contextless numbers. It is legitimately not clear to me in any way what you're trying to say or what it has to do with the thing you're replying to.
- AussieWog93 5y ago>In this case, you're saying that Jewish students are 11x more hard-working than Hispanic ones, and Asian students are 6x more hard-working than Black ones? Does Michael Phelps (23 Olympic gold medals) swim 23x faster than Mack Horton (1 Olympic gold medal)?
- car_analogy 5y agoFine. N-times more likely to be hard-working enough for the Ivy League.
- AussieWog93 5y agoInternet arguments aside, the fact that certain cultural groups push their children to study hard (and also provide them with as many resources as possible to make sure their studies are fruitful) probably is a big contributor to the disparity illustrated in your table.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoMeritocracy is bigoted or rational depending on which groups appear in a particular order. Pick one and be consistent with it. Swapping depending on what pecking order shows up is just more moral relativism to benefit one group while demonizing any others who ever try to do the same. Don't think it's not noticed and remembered for future reference.
- throwawaydem45 5y agoWhy does the concept of "working hard" have to be a categorized by race when it is largely based on individual circumstances such as family income, parental upbringing, and immigration history? Someone who individually works hard that is a member of a group that is not considered to be hard working (or vice versa) would still be treated unfairly by this proposed system, making it no better than the status quo.
- heavyset_go 5y agoUS immigration policy selects for high earners, the already wealthy and the highly skilled and educated. I think that can explain the demographics pretty well.