8 ms·
Overtone
- sbochins 15y agoThis is very cool. I remember there was another clojure music library that came out several months ago. It was very cool, but nowhere near as cool and extensible as this. EDIT: this was the library I was thinking of http://mad.emotionull.com/ http://mad.emotionull.com/
- dplakon 15y agoMax/MSP is this times a million. check it out if you haven't heard of it. cycling74.com it does the exact same things but with more options, complexity, and a more usable interface. It also has visual fx.
- erikschoster 15y agoSignal flow approaches like Max/MSP and PureData are awesome and have their own strengths and weaknesses - but certainly they have no more or less 'options' or capacity for complexity than any similarly mature text-based DSP system like SuperCollider or ChucK.
- msutherl 15y agoHey Erik ;) Strictly Max/MSP/Jitter is a much more encompassing environment than SuperCollider and ChucK, which focus on audio. The advantage of Max is that it combines a great control language with audio programming, a great video matrix library and a dataflow OpenGL API. Generally there are many more 3rd party contributions to Max/MSP than any of the other media programming frameworks with the exception of perhaps vvvv (which is video centric). That said, the nice thing about all of these environments is that they heavily integrate OSC messaging, which allows you to mix and match anything together. People often combine openFrameworks/Cinder and SuperCollider for instance.
- erikschoster 15y agoI suppose Jitter is a big honking extra option, yeah. :-) I read the original comment as suggesting that SuperCollider was somehow lacking in flexibility compared to Max/MSP, which isn't true. They're all excellent tools with different approaches.
- swannodette 15y agoMax/MSP and Clojure are not either/or http://www.cassiel.com/2011/08/01/clojure-in-maxmsp/ http://www.cassiel.com/2011/08/01/clojure-in-maxmsp/
- samaaron 15y agoMax is very cool - however the biggest issue for me is its lack of support for abstractions. This typically results in an insanely complicated visual program for everything except for the most trivial examples. One of the core goals for Overtone is to provide the means for musicians to share their ideas through a programming-language-like notation. This means readability and understandability are at least, if not more important, to expressiveness with the language. Overtone should be easy to grok, not appear to be some cryptic puzzle.
- mikefox 15y agoI’m seeing educational value in this, musical output as a way of teaching programming to beginners, especially to auditory learners (or to the blind, for that matter). Is there anything out there like this that’s specifically intended as an educational tool?
- jcfrei 15y agohere's the project website: http://overtone.github.com/ http://overtone.github.com/
- agumonkey 15y agoThey also publish their dotemacs which is lovely to use (theme, autocomplete, some lambda beautification) https://github.com/overtone/live-coding-emacs https://github.com/overtone/live-coding-emacs
- mcav 15y agoOvertone looks fantastic, and I've been meaning to really look into it for a while now. It seems to be an active project with a lot of momentum. I was writing something similar in Clojure, but more directly musically focused rather than on sound synths, before I found overtone. I tried installing it once a while ago, but had trouble getting SuperCollider to install and work with overtone. Are there any overtone-related gatherings in the bay area?
- samaaron 15y agoHey mcav, you should definitely head over to the Overtone mailing list on google groups: http://groups.google.com/group/overtone http://groups.google.com/group/overtone. We should be able to sort out your SC install <-> Overtone troubles easily :-)
- jianshen 15y agoThis is what Hollywood thinks most coding is like in the world. One shot, no bugs and pure creation. All in a highly customized and beautifully responsive editing environment. Seriously though, thanks for posting this. I think music coders deserve special attention because they mix creativity and logic together so well.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- samaaron 15y agoI'd be happy to get some code review feedback for the Overtone codebase: http://github.com/overtone/overtone http://github.com/overtone/overtone Pull requests would be even nicer...
- angrycoder 15y agohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7bdECd3pQ0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P7bdECd3pQ0 Coded by hand over the course of 6 months using Csound.
- moondowner 15y agoBT is truly an artist.
- moomin 15y agoIt's also what Hollywood thinks music is like: pure improvisation. In the real world, both require an amazing amount of rehearsal and frustrating lack of progress on your own time before the 'performance'. I always thought the best moment of 8-mile was when Bunny stops talking and sits down with a pen and a paper in his bedroom. It's fairly explicit that that's the point he starts on the road to being a successful musician.
- wylie 15y agoI'm so glad that somebody built a better front-end for SuperCollider. It's badly in need of a better guide and tutorial for new users, and this seems like an excellent way to go about it.
- marquis 15y agoIs SuperCollider really that complicated? I've seen some incredible things built with it by musicians who have learnt to code specifically for it.
- rosejn 15y agoIt's not necessarily that SC is complicated, but it is a custom language that has to be learned to use a single application. Also, many musical ideas and projects extend beyond what sclang can do, or you want to use external libs, etc. By using Clojure you get all of the power of sclang and more, because you also get lisp macros, while also getting access to the whole java ecosystem of libs. We've got a gui library for Overtone in the works, and it will be a good example of this in action.
- rosejn 15y agoIt's not necessarily that SC is complicated, but it is a custom language that has to be learned to use a single application. Also, many musical ideas and projects extend beyond what sclang can do, or you want to use external libs, etc. By using Clojure you get all of the power of sclang and more, because you also get lisp macros, while also getting access to the whole java ecosystem of libs. We've got a gui library for Overtone in the works, and it will be a good example of this in action.
- mhax 15y agoI would say yes, SC really is that complicated. sclang borrows from a bunch of different programming philosophies, so you have declarative stuff alongside imperative stuff, plus it is flexible to the extreme, with various 'equivalent' syntax constructs to achieve the same thing, and innumerable 'shortcuts'. Meaning that it's very easy to write obscure, hard to read code. Plus, it's not just a matter of knowing sclang - the whole sever graph architecture needs to be understood to really 'know' SC. I think there are probably very few people that really understand all of it.
- rorrr 15y agoIt was amazing to watch him write the flawless LISP code. The project itself is interesting, but very niche.
- fragsworth 15y agoFor the purpose of the video, it was probably transcribed from existing code.
- samaaron 15y agoI practiced writing that code for about a day before I could write it flawlessly in one take. I guess, in a similar fashion to how a musician will practice using an instrument before going on stage.
- stygianguest 15y agoThat only holds for some kinds of playing. How is your experience with improvisation? Can you manage quick changes? Or does it always tend to be a slow buildup of rythms harmonics and melodies?
- swannodette 15y agoImprovisation requires plenty of practice - http://www.amazon.com/Improvisation-Its-Nature-Practice-Music/dp/0306805286 http://www.amazon.com/Improvisation-Its-Nature-Practice-Musi...
- stygianguest 15y agoApparently my question is not clear. I'm asking this as a musician who does a lot of improvisation. The question is wether livecode improvisation is comparable. The most enjoyable thing in improvisation, are sudden changes that can emerge in a good session. You typically have less than a second to react to such things. That is, less than a second to change rythm/feel, tempo, harmonics, volume, etc. More often than not all at the same time. Playing like that makes you feel part of the organism from which the music emerges, rather than a thinking actor in a rehearsed play. A feeling that I only find in dancing and other things I do with my wife. I would really like to get into this livecoding stuff, and have tried ChuCK and SuperCollider. Clearly I never practiced enough to improvise in the live, but I'm wondering if it is at all possible in the sense I described above.
- muyuu 15y agoIf you like this you may want to check Fluxus. http://www.pawfal.org/fluxus/ http://www.pawfal.org/fluxus/ http://www.pawfal.org/fluxus/projects-using-fluxus/ http://www.pawfal.org/fluxus/projects-using-fluxus/ And impromptu: http://impromptu.moso.com.au/ http://impromptu.moso.com.au/
- tizoc 15y agoIf you like Impromptu, take a look at Extempore by the same author. Unlike Impromptu, Extempore is open source, and runs on Linux and Windows too. https://github.com/digego/extempore https://github.com/digego/extempore
- Raphael 15y agoInteresting how his command line glows and shows CRT-like distortions. Is that actually how it looks, or is that post-processing applied to the video?
- davidu 15y agoI think it's a little of column A and a little of column B.
- sneak 15y agoIf on OSX, you may be interested in this: http://www.secretgeometry.com/apps/cathode/ http://www.secretgeometry.com/apps/cathode/
- jamesbkel 15y agoNot sure if I would really use it aside from a novelty, but I may need to buy this simply to support such a great/fun idea.
- mreid 15y agoI'm guessing he had emacs open in a "Cathode":http://www.secretgeometry.com/apps/cathode/ http://www.secretgeometry.com/apps/cathode/ session. The extra warping at the end of the video can be achieved by fiddling with the "distress" parameters in Cathode's preferences.
- rhdoenges 15y agoIs there a linux alternative to that? I want it incredibly badly.
- kragen 15y agoThe apple2 screensaver that comes with xscreensaver can be used as a terminal emulator. You can also get a chintzy version by fullscreening xterm or gnome-terminal with the vt220 TrueType font and green-on-black, but that doesn't give you CRT distortions, or for that matter even correct-looking reverse video.
- eegilbert 15y agoThis is great. Thank you. If you're interested in this stuff, also take a look at ChucK, a project out of Princeton's CS & Music departments. I've been extremely happy with its results when generating backgrounds for videos, for instance. http://chuck.cs.princeton.edu http://chuck.cs.princeton.edu
- rescripting 15y agoFrom what I can tell ChucK is no longer supported and has stopped working in OSX Lion.
- AllTom 15y agoNot quite true, I know the developers and they're working on Lion support, as well as some major updates to the vm.
- erikschoster 15y agoThat's great news!
- jamesbkel 15y agoDo you have any audio examples? The only examples I could see were actual code. (I'm on my phone so I'll double-check later in case I missed an obvious link on the ChucK site).
- przemoc 15y agoSounds (and looks) interesting. BTW After watching it I've finally submitted my first Ask HN: What are your music prototyping solutions? http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3089259 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3089259
- nicklovescode 15y agoI have a hell of an upvote waiting for the person who ports this to the Audio Data API
- DonnyV 15y agoI'm not really sure what you would use this for. I'm a musician and I can't possibly find any use for this. It would take forever to write a song in this and then you would have to mess with the timings just to make it not sound like a programmed piece of music and give it some feel.
- muraiki 15y agoGenerative / algorithmic music is its own world. I'm a musician too and I can't imagine being very expressive (and musical) with this compared to my shakuhachi or doumbek. I have a hard time imagining how this could be used in live improvisation vs something like Ableton. But this type of music is really its own thing, and I don't presume to understand it. Something that I found interesting, a video game approach to music: http://kotaku.com/5847212/compose-your-own-musical-villages-in-the-lovely-isle-of-tune-hd http://kotaku.com/5847212/compose-your-own-musical-villages-...
- muraiki 15y agoOk, I just saw the link someone posted to "This Binary Universe." I stand corrected: you can make some pretty amazing music this way. :) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ve8WaGmyhfI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ve8WaGmyhfI
- rosejn 15y agoActually, one of the initial motivations for creating Overtone was to experiment with automating "feel". I was getting into electronic music, and it seemed to me that many of the painful aspects of EQing and adjusting instruments and timing so they don't interfere with each other could be automated. We haven't really gotten to this point yet, but I tend to believe that this is yet another area in life where people will argue forever that software will never compete with humans, up until the point where many of the top tracks are being generated by software. It also opens the door to all kinds of interesting things, like live composition of multiple instruments, or meta-composing, where you modify parameters along axis like tension, emotion, drive, and vibe, rather than figuring out how to modulate to the next key. For now I agree with you though, most of what I create in Overtone still has a robotic feel. Hopefully that won't be the case for long. We'd love to have more musicians joining the discussion though, so if you have ideas join the mailing list.
- moultano 15y agoIf you like this, check out nyquist. Lisp for audio programming: http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~music/nyquist/ http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~music/nyquist/
- swannodette 15y agoBut that's not "realtime" like SuperCollider right?
- ehsanu1 15y agoThia isn't overtone, but here's some very impressive livecoding in scheme/impromptu (http://impromptu.moso.com.au/ http://impromptu.moso.com.au/), building up to a wonderful piano improvisation which has a very natural feel: http://vimeo.com/2433947 http://vimeo.com/2433947
- tizoc 15y agoThe author of Impromptu is now working on Extempore, which unlike Impromptu, is opensource, and runs on other operating systems other than OS X. https://github.com/digego/extempore https://github.com/digego/extempore
- chrisrickard 15y agoAs a musician & coder, i have always been intrigued by this idea.. it does seem like a tricky process to "play" live - but still - could be pretty fun
- moomin 15y agoI was lucky enough to see Sam Aaron rehearse his ClojureConj course at skillsmatter last week. The room was full of musicians who know Clojure. Personally, I think overtone has potential. It's already usable as an alternative synth design tool (beats the hell out of visual design). As for taking on Cubase... There are all sorts of features it doesn't have (like a usable UI), but as sam says... pull requests are welcome. :)
- FuzzyDunlop 15y agoThis really interests me, being a musician as well. The idea of coding music (and not just programming a synth or whatever) has never occurred to me before and I really fancy spending an evening or two with this to see what happens. My only dislike with increasingly virtual instruments, however, is that I don't really get the same sort of involvement out of using them. I can bang out some fairly decent beats with my PadKontrol but it makes me long for my old, battered drum kit, and the band practices where I'd lay down a beat and just let myself get lost in it all as the guitarists and bassist improvised over it. What you gain in technology (and all the amazing things you can do with it) you lose in that sense of physicality.
- yaxu 15y agoA big part of Sam Aaron's research is into integrating interfaces like the monome into live coding languages.
- malkia 15y agoSomehow this resonates with me as a game developer, and actually Naughty Dog's use of Lisp (common lisp) got me into learning it, but slowly has been moved to lua (but can see the difficulties in using lua as live coding language) pretty cool, and also started using emacs since then....