4 ms·
Asymmetric combatants, including in Vietnam and Gaza, have long used tunnels. I think they were popular in medieval siege warfare (is that right?). I wonder wh
by wolverine876 5y ago
Asymmetric combatants, including in Vietnam and Gaza, have long used tunnels. I think they were popular in medieval siege warfare (is that right?).
I wonder why advanced militaries don't appear to use them: They have access to technology far superior to asymmetric groups and I would guess that allows much faster tunneling. Maybe it's almost always better ROI to do the same thing via the air - e.g., distribute supplies via airdrop.
- ch4s3 5y agoTunneling to undermine walls probably began in the Bronze Age and it was used to breach trenches in WWI. It has apparently alway been awful work. I’ve read that some premodern walled cities sunk metal bars in pits below walls to try and find where enemies were digging.
- greggsy 5y agoThat might make moats more useful
- leereeves 5y ago> I think they were popular in medieval siege warfare (is that right?). Yeah, in fact the term "undermine" comes from their use in siege warfare. Attackers would try to dig under enemy walls to collapse them (literally under-mining the walls), and the defenders would dig their own tunnels to try to collapse the attackers' tunnels.
- jonplackett 5y agoWouldn’t want to be the one digging those tunnels. Bad enough digging tunnels when you don’t intend them to collapse.
- a9h74j 5y agoA First-Person Tunneler would probably also make for a boring video game. Wait, does the word 'boring' come from the drugdery of digging tunnels?
- psyc 5y agoAhem. There was this little indie game that sort of took over the world in 2010 and made its creator a billionaire…
- a9h74j 5y agoI was picturing looking at a screen of solid rock. The indie game I assume added a lot beyond that.
- sudosysgen 5y agoMost of the time is indeed spent looking at rock, at least back then.
- psyc 5y agohttps://youtu.be/IwMSjcVFXbQ?t=238 https://youtu.be/IwMSjcVFXbQ?t=238 It adds more things than I will ever learn how to do. But you still spend loooooots of time looking at a screen of 16x16 gray textures that are suggestive of rock.
- a9h74j 5y agoOMG. I've always seen people doing surface navigation or at most surface digging in Minecraft. I never made the connection to possibly blasting away rocks while below surface.
- psyc 5y agoLoot gets better and rarer the deeper you go. It’s a basic slot machine. You spend 5 minutes on whack whack whack whack poof, and every once in a while … Diamond Jackpot!
- krisoft 5y agoThere is a reason it is called “mine” craft. “The name was a combination of the words mine, for mining ore in shafts, and craft, as in building or creating something.” Quote from here: https://www.wired.com/2013/11/minecraft-book/ https://www.wired.com/2013/11/minecraft-book/
- willcipriano 5y agoThe alternative is you get hoisted by your own petard. I'd take tunnel duty. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petard https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petard
- simonh 5y agoYou’d use explosives to trigger the collapse.
- twic 5y ago> I think they were popular in medieval siege warfare (is that right?). And more recently: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mines_in_the_Battle_of_Messines_(1917) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mines_in_the_Battle_of_Messine...
- KineticLensman 5y ago> I wonder why advanced militaries don't appear to use them In cities they can use pre-formed tunnels - subways. Otherwise they aren’t needed because enemies don’t tend to sit in large static artillery-proof castles
- ezconnect 5y agomodern warfare is about mobility and firepower, tunneling will be to slow.
- wolverine876 5y agoGood point. The Russians have gone back to sieges and artillery, which is what made me think of it.
- loceng 5y agoDon't appear to use them because they're hidden. It's fairly common with drug smuggling I believe as well. And from what I remember there were tunnels from Palestine to Israel. It's why Elon has said roughly that if you can detect tunnels being dug you should contact the military because you'll become rich; he said this at least once in reference to concerns that people in cities would feel The Boring Company tunnels being bored underneath their city - that you can't feel/notice it; obviously when breaching the surface you will. I've honestly wondered at times if industrious nations - who are arguably in contention with the ways of freedom and democracy - may be digging towards other continents, even if at current technology it would take 40+ years to make the journey. If you can all of a sudden deploy millions to 10s of millions of operatives and/or soldiers - even if it's a long journey, perhaps each with significant Bitcoin or perhaps cash in the currency of who you're invading, you might be able to very quickly takeover a large nation; or get a foothold, and arguably why the right to bear arms is additionally important - for domestic bad actors but foreign bad actors could in this scenario now be local.
- wolverine876 5y ago> you can't feel/notice it I've read stories for years about people having problems with vibrations from tunneling. One was a music studio in Brooklyn, IIRC, which went out of business because of boring for a new water tunnel.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I wonder why advanced militaries don't appear to use them: Because modern advanced militaries don't usually have the problems that are solved by tunneling, either for pre-modern militaries (static fortifications highly resistant to direct attack by the most powerful weapons available) or modern less-advanced ones fighting asymmetrical warfare (covert movement against an enemy that controls the air.)