48 ms·
Seems to work for Netflix, who is very up front about this philosophy. Of course, a big part of this is they do pair it with an incredibly generous severance pa
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
Seems to work for Netflix, who is very up front about this philosophy. Of course, a big part of this is they do pair it with an incredibly generous severance package.
Personally, I would jump at the chance to work at a company with this philosophy, even if I ended up being the one getting canned. I don't think I've ever worked at a company that fired "too fast", if anything it was clear that some folks were clearly not going to succeed, but hard decisions were avoided, which took down the productivity of everyone involved, and when the folks were eventually let go or left on their own they usually ended up still being super bitter. A reluctance to fire, in my experience, just really translates into a company that has difficulty making hard decisions.
- majormajor 5y agoYeah, Netflix appears to do it in a reasonable way. I would be perfectly fine taking an offer to work there. But I've more frequently heard stories of others who see "fire fast" solely as a way to save money and also avoid having to ever train or mentor. That's bad for the employee, and not a place I'd work, if I knew it in advance. If you're looking to structure your employees' comp with a heavy equity component that takes a while to vest, "fire fast" becomes especially dangerous for the employee.
- WalterBright 5y agoPeople are fired who cost more than the value they provide. To not get fired: 1. provide more value than you cost the company 2. make sure the boss knows (1) for you
- majormajor 5y ago"People are fired when they underperform their peers [over some time window]" is much more common, since most organizations have a very fuzzy grasp exactly on value returned per employee. Candidates should try to be aware of companies that won't give new hires much of a time window to prove their performance level or value creation. Especially if large amounts of their compensation depend on going at least 12 months without getting fired.
- WalterBright 5y agoCompanies indeed often have a fuzzy grasp. But you can do things like point out how your work got the product to market X days sooner, and point out the profit per day of sales times X. Or point out how you fixed Major Customer Y's problem, ensuring a steady revenue stream from that happy customer. Or point out how you sped up the code in the datacenter by 1%, meaning 1% less needs to be spent on the datacenter. At Boeing, the accountants managed to pin down the cost of one pound of airplane weight. At the time, it was $250,000 per pound. This made it easy to point out to the boss how much money you'd saved the company by doing weight reductions. I.e. if you saved a pound, that was the equivalent of 6 years salary. Time to bring up that raise you deserve!
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI pretty strongly disagree this is actually possible (and not just be an exercise of made-up statistics) at any sizable company. Look at Google for example. I'm quite sure that a very large percentage, if not majority, of the employees at Google produce net negative value. The problem, of course, is that it's impossible to know which ones. I know a bunch of people (brilliant people, mind you) that worked years on products at Google that never shipped, or worked on products that shipped but were discontinued long before they were ever profitable. But Google is willing to make these investments because they believe that, one day, one or two of them will pay off spectacularly. I mean, Waymo has certainly never been profitable (heck they've barely had any revenue) - what do their employees argue?
- WalterBright 5y ago> Waymo has certainly never been profitable The employee needs to be profitable, not the aggregate of all the employees. As for speculative research projects, nothing succeeds like success (making money). Researchers who produce loser after loser projects I expect would be much more likely to be fired than researchers who had a win big enough to cover their losing projects. > possible The whole field of cost accounting is devoted to figuring this out. Back in the 70s, I attended Caltech when Feynman was on the staff. It came up in conversation that Feynman was making a salary of something like $55,000 (a lot of money in those days). I said what could anyone do to justify paying him such a salary. A grad student laughed and said "you don't understand. Feynman doesn't need to do anything to be worth that salary. He just has to be on the staff, which attracts donor money and draws top talent to Caltech." Of course, he was right. But also, Feynman being Feynman, did do an awful lot as well. In many universities and companies, you'll find such "prestige" staff.
- darth_avocado 5y agoAs someone who’s worked at Netflix, I feel the whole philosophy is a little too glorified. The first thing you have to remember is that Netflix pays a lot (a lot lot). The idea of expecting high performance only works when it’s accompanied with substantial benefits. Second, Netflix does “fire fast” but not in the sense most people interpret it. New hires are given enough scaffolding to succeed. It’s not like other companies where they expect people to come onboard as revolutionaries and create impact in a month. Third, high performance isn’t a constant like most people pretend it is. Netflix has managers who understand this fact and support their employees when things go down. They aren’t ruthless maniacs who fire you the first week you take a breather. And most managers who try to copy this elsewhere, miss that point.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI agree with everything you've written, but to be clear, I don't think a reasonable version of the "fire fast" mentality means you throw people in the deep end with no support and then can them at the earliest moment if they struggle. But I do think it means that when it becomes clear that it's not working out, and the reason for it not working out is pretty fundamental to the employee's personality or aptitude, that you make a decision to let them go quickly and fairly.
- zcw100 5y ago> even if I ended up being the one getting canned It's really easy to have this attitude when you don't really think it will ever happen to you. I'm also guessing you've never been the target of harassment. I don't think you're going to like it as much when you're really excited about the job and on your first day you find out that the superstar developer on the team Gill just doesn't like you, never did. He was the one person who said they shouldn't hire you and is now pissed that he was overruled. Turns out Gill doesn't like not getting his way. You find yourself socially isolated because everyone knows what Gill is like and that he doesn't like you. Being seen talking to you isn't worth getting on Gill's bad side. You get the shit assignments and code reviews are really rough. Especially the ones where Gill's around. Then you get hauled into the office about some problem with something you did. It isn't clear if it was something you did but it seems to be related to something Gill's working on. Gill's the super star and you're just the new guy so you can guess who caught the heat. It didn't go well when you suggested it might be Gill's fault. Turns out Gill was in the office right before you and he's telling a different story and they let you know what a superstar he is and everything he's done for the company over the years. It's clear that Gill's just going to grind you down as your quality of life decreases, you start losing sleep, acting out from the stress, you snap at your wife, children, and friends because you're still upset about something Gill did to you at work. See the problem now or are you just imagining yourself as Gill?
- BobbyJo 5y agoSounds like they should fire Gill fast. On the flip side, firing people around Gill, who he doesn't like, fast will make it apparent that Gill is the problem much more quickly than just keeping everyone around when things aren't working.
- zcw100 5y agoIt just reinforces what Gill has been saying all along, that most of the applicants out there really suck and it's impossible to find good people. That's why you better listen to him because if he ever decides to leave they're screwed. He's the most dependable employee. After four turnovers of the staff he's still there heroically keeping things going.