5 ms·
Can Amazon now just shut down that warehouse and fire all the workers? It would seem like a sensible business move, even if it involves a little bit of service
by londons_explore 5y ago
Can Amazon now just shut down that warehouse and fire all the workers?
It would seem like a sensible business move, even if it involves a little bit of service disruption for users in New York.
- lalaland1125 5y agoYes, Amazon is allowed to do that. The main caveat is that they have to argue in court that the warehouse would be unprofitable given the union's demands.
- daenz 5y ago>they have to argue in court that the warehouse would be unprofitable given the union's demands. They would? Why? How does the existence of a union prevent a company from firing everyone if it wants to? My understanding is that the only power of a union is that all of its members use collective leverage to get better deals. There is no collective leverage action if everyone is fired.
- relaxing 5y agoFederal law.
- colinmhayes 5y agoYes, but I believe this warehouse employs 8,000 of people. It would probably cost hundreds of millions to rebuild it which is what they'd have to do in this situation. Might be worth it for them, but they'd take a huge pr hit which could tip the scales to not shutting down the warehouse. I think it's likely they build smaller warehouses in the future to make a shut down in response to unionization more palatable.
- zjaffee 5y ago8300 is just the size of the bargaining unit, there are almost certainly far more people working there than just that.
- jefurii 5y agoAre you advocating this course of action?
- dymk 5y agoIt seems like somebody like you has to pop in and imply (accuse) a commenter of being anti-labor or whatever, whenever it's pointed out that unions can have downsides. Unions have upsides, and downsides. Discussing them helps people make good decisions. Pretending it's all flowers and rainbows does not.
- xibo9 5y agoI don't believe he did what you're claiming. Please keep the strawmen at home and undamaged.
- lampshades 5y agoIs he not allowed to?
- softfalcon 5y agoI don’t think they are, they’re just worried about what might happen if Amazon brings down the ban hammer. Please don’t ask leading questions like this, they’re not helpful to the discussion.
- zjaffee 5y agoNYC is one of amazon's largest markets, and this is the biggest warehouse in the city. There are 8300 employees in the bargaining group which doesn't include management, engineers who do repair work for the robotics and so on. They cannot afford to close this shop, and it's obviously playing a big role as to why this location has successfully unionized while the location in Alabama has not.
- morelish 5y agoMay the opposite be the case? If Amazon really wants to prevent unions appearing in their employment relations, doesn't Amazon need to close this down now? I'm not saying that's good. But I'm saying Amazon might think it can't afford to let the employees unionise.
- zjaffee 5y agoIt's a matter of near totally shutting down their operations in NYC or not, a place where Amazon is currently the largest retailer. They might be able to stop gap it by sending all their packages in NYC through UPS/USPS, but it would be a major disruption to their operations.
- morelish 5y agoAmazon has historically had the capacity to be ruthless. For example in it's fight against collecting state taxes, it shutdown third-party sellers in states that introduced laws requiring Amazon to collect state taxes. Eventually Amazon lost that battle, which paved the way for Amazon opening more fulfilment centres in more states. I wouldn't be surprised if Amazon announced the closure of this fulfilment centre. It would seem dramatic but if it kept other centres from unionizing I could see Amazon taking the short-term discomfort. I don't know what Amazon's calculation will be in these circumstances. If Jeff was still in charge I reckon the fulfilment centre would be closed down.
- munk-a 5y ago> I wouldn't be surprised if Amazon announced the closure of this fulfilment centre. It would seem dramatic but if it kept other centres from unionizing I could see Amazon taking the short-term discomfort. I think you're underestimating the long term pain Amazon is opening themselves up to by closing a recently unionized site. With a labour shortage and extremely high churn Amazon is already having hiring issues - scabs aren't really on the menu if you're already scraping the barrel and a large employer in the local market.
- munk-a 5y ago> It would seem like a sensible business move, even if it involves a little bit of service disruption for users in New York. It only seems like a sensible business move if you ignore the incredibly negative PR that'd come from it. You're laying off a lot of local workers and publicly making a target of yourself after the vote passes. Usually businesses will shut down sites before the union vote while they can still sort of BS their way into saying "Well, it looked like the vote would've failed anyways - look at this internal polling" - doing it after unionization is going to add a lot of vitriol to the situation, much more so than the underhanded techniques they use to sway the vote.
- londons_explore 5y agoAmazon could sell the fulfilment center building to a third party to run. Then make all the workers redundant, but let the third party offer them employment. Then if the union makes undue demands, the third party can go bust and Amazon buy back the centre for pennies on the dollar, but without most of the staff.