4 ms·
I duno. I think things happen sometimes. Sometimes not. There have been cases where it really sounded like there was a traditional split along the court and
by duxup 5y ago
I duno. I think things happen sometimes. Sometimes not.
There have been cases where it really sounded like there was a traditional split along the court and then some questions pop up and the answers are so bad / arguments clearly absurd / the lawyers have no good answers that suddenly the case is clearly going one way.
Usually this revolves around the sort of second order effects of a potential ruling and where ideology isn't entirely clear / has some conflicts with those second order effects.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI don't think any new or surprise questions pop up in oral argument. Everything has been mapped out in the briefing documents, and hashed out sever times in lower courts. In fact, I think it would be a bad thing if the court swung on oral arguments. These are very complex topics prepared by an army of lawyers on each side. They should not hinge on if a single presenter doesn't have a clear an concise answer within two seconds of being asked it.
- duxup 5y agoI don't doubt everyone prepares. However, there are arguments if you listen to where the attorneys don't have a prepared answer / don't have good answers and the judges genuinely sound surprised. As for the rulings there's A LOT more than ruling one way or another, the ruling itself can range in all sorts of directions.