2 ms·
Actually, there is and never has been a tragedy of the commons. Historically, commons have been managed by highly evolved communal practice. The so-called trage
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Actually, there is and never has been a tragedy of the commons. Historically, commons have been managed by highly evolved communal practice. The so-called tragedies occured after powerful interests first dismantled those practices, and then sought to exploit the commons. Even Hardin (originator of the ToC concept) has acknowledged this. The idea that human societies had commons that were just open to anyone to do anything, and thus they got screwed up is completely ahistorical. It's also a widely used tool in the rhetorical arguments deployed against a return to true (historical) commons.
I am not aware of anyone demonizing farmers. It's not demonizing farmers to note the evaporative loss caused by flood and spray irrigation - that's simply a fact. It's not demonizing farmers to note that the whole idea of turning the highly insolated SW into a garden for the nation was originated at a specific time and place, by a specific group of people who refused to be curious about water. It's not demonizing farmers to note that the practice of growing crops for export is effectively the same as exporting water.
But yes, cooperation in pursuit of mutal goals is a great idea. One approach that I think has a lot of promise is a system that affects the purchase of water rights for municipal use, from farmers. The purchasing city pays some amount for the water rights, but then throws in a substantial additional payment to cover the capital cost of the farmer converting to drip irrigation. Everybody wins!
- jessaustin 5y agoThat seems like a lot of words for "yes I agree farmers should be paid to use less water." I'm just trying to be practical here, but perhaps there are interests served by avoiding obvious practical solutions.