8 ms·
Isn't open-shop effectively "no union" in practice? What threat does a union have when the company can just hire non-union workers?
by Spivak 5y ago
Isn't open-shop effectively "no union" in practice? What threat does a union have when the company can just hire non-union workers?
- germinalphrase 5y agoUnions often train their members and self-enforce safety standards. Both of these things provide a higher quality labor pool for the employer.
- hn_version_0023 5y agoIs that relevant in our race-to-the-bottom world where every last corner is cut? I am strongly pro-union, but I don’t actually see corps seeing your point as a positive.
- BuckRogers 5y agoInternational unions would prevent that. Can't cut corners if everyone you hire is united to ensure everyone is treated equally by the company.
- ceeplusplus 5y agoTraining members for an unskilled job doesn't really improve the value delivered by that worker. You can see why employers would not see that as a benefit of a union. Skilled jobs like the trades are already differentiated based on skill and reputation through the contract bidding process.
- kmonsen 5y agoI was a union rep when working in Norway, I guess it was open-shop since we had two different unions. In practice we cooperated a lot, and the largest benefit was the it gave us access to lawyers that could answer questions quickly so the members were more willing to push back on unreasonable requests. We were never close to going to a lawsuit against the company, it was more "hey this is breaking the law, how do we work together to fix it".
- oblio 5y ago> We were never close to going to a lawsuit against the company, it was more "hey this is breaking the law, how do we work together to fix it". Yeah, but the article is about the US, were they invented the Pinkertons instead of addressing employee grievances :-)
- ch4s3 5y agoThat’s hardly unique or even the night of 19th/20th century anti-Union violence.
- kmonsen 5y agoThere were pretty bad anti-union activity back in the day in Norway as well. The army was used to squash strikes. These days not so much. I think part of the reason Norway works is that it has gotten past the insane hostility and there is not the all or nothing mentality. For example there is free healthcare, but there is also private insurance and hospitals if you want better care from a private provider. I think for a capitalistic society (and I don't think we have a better way yet), being able to have options is a must.
- leetcrew 5y agomaybe this is a naive perspective, but it seems to me that the union should have more to offer labor than simply middlemanning access to an employer. if people genuinely want to be in the union, it should be hard to find non-union workers.
- brimble 5y agoThey also often provide legal help and various sorts of insurance. They'll also usually provide representation & assistance for workers who come into conflict with management, which can be super important when it comes to enforcing safety standards, contract terms (e.g. working conditions, rules around time-off requests), and even legal requirements. The trouble with completely optional membership is that it introduces the good ol' Free Rider Problem, bane of many an attempt to make things better without forcing anyone to do anything.
- selfhifive 5y agoThat could end badly because you don't want to have too many gatekeepers. I should be allowed to not be part of a group and work as I see fit. Unions are hit-or-miss. Bad ones have too much petty politics and corruption and that's why some people genuinely don't want to be in a union. Enforcing unions more strictly can make the good better but it can also make the bad worse.
- BuckRogers 5y agoit should be hard to find non-union workers. It is. Everyone wants to work for union shops like UPS or John Deere, and people feel it's a great victory to be hired. While non-union shops are always hiring, because they drive people into the ground.
- josephcsible 5y agoOnce you acknowledge that unions are useless and bad, yes, this is correct. If unions were actually beneficial to workers, then companies would have a very hard time hiring non-union workers.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 5y agoThis makes zero sense, you're drawing huge conclusions based on a prisoner's dilemma situation. Of course it's beneficial to be a defector, you get all the benefit but none of the cost. Once no one is unionized at all or it's so small to not have any pull the benefit disappears. It's like saying that taxes are useless because given the choice people would opt-out if they could, ignoring the consequences of if everyone did that.
- josephcsible 5y agoHow is it a prisoner's dilemma? Why would a union give its benefits to someone who didn't join?
- Spivak 5y agoBecause not all the benefits of membership are excludable. Unions that hold employers accountable to following labor laws and safety regulations benefit all employees, same with annual raises, removing abusive managers, better benefits, overtime pay [1], etc. etc. Some benefits are excludable for sure, a union isn't going to fight a non-members wrongful firing case. [1] Some unions manage to get payroll benefits for just union workers but it's vanishingly rare because it just pushes workers to the union if they don't give it to everyone.
- josephcsible 5y agoWhy is a union necessary to enforce labor laws and safety regulations? Can't individual employees report such violations to the government even in non-union shops?
- ufmace 5y agoI'd say a proper union is efficient and useful enough that employees who are free to choose whether to join or not mostly choose to join of their own free will. If you have to force people to join, then maybe it's not actually that great. Or alternatively, it has less incentive to stay efficient and useful and police itself if everyone is forced to join.