4 ms·
Residential water use in the west is typically around 7% of the water available in a state. Residential and municipal water use in most large cities of the dese
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Residential water use in the west is typically around 7% of the water available in a state. Residential and municipal water use in most large cities of the desert west has been falling over the last 2-3 decades despite rising population.
Agriculture - the ridiculous dream of the US Bureau of Reclamation from the 1930s - is what uses 70-80% of all the water.
- vegetablepotpie 5y agoRight, and that’s what feeds the nation as a whole. Most of the USs winter time vegetables come from the southwest. If you’ve eaten a salad in winter, the lettuce came from Yuma, AZ, which grew it with Colorado river water. Moving to another part of the US will not make the food you eat more sustainable or less prone to drought. One way moving to a region with more water will help is if there is a collapse of society, where you need to grow your own food.
- codingdave 5y agoYep, that is part of it for sure. We have always grown at least some of our own food, raised chickens and livestock, and been at least closer to self-sustainable than not. It makes far more sense to do that in a place where an ample water supply falls from the sky on a regular basis, with our own wells and a few dozen acres of lands to work with. The other part is just the experience. Living in brown, dry, dusty lands with dried out lake beds, or algae blooms if there is water... it just got old. Growing population meant more traffic, more ticky-tacky housing developments. It just wasn't a fun place to live anymore, even if you can prove with statistics that it is survivable. Your life experience needs to be enjoyable.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> Growing population meant more traffic, more ticky-tacky housing developments. It just wasn't a fun place to live anymore, even if you can prove with statistics that it is survivable. My wife grew up in Wisconsin. That pretty much matches the way she would describe it at this point :)
- bilbo0s 5y agoI live in Wisconsin. Your wife is 100% right. I don't think I'd necessarily recommend it to people who are not from here.
- codingdave 5y agoDepends on where. Milwaukee is vastly different than the north woods, both of which are different than Madison. There are definitely parts of Wisconsin I would not move to, despite finding a lovely home for ourselves away from the cities.
- jessaustin 5y agoAgriculture... In a society governed by law, the straightforward way to confiscate a regular benefit received by a particular group is to pay that group to forego their statutory right to that benefit. Until we pony up the cash to pay farmers to use less of the water they own, one concludes that the problem of low flows on the Colorado doesn't really concern TPTB.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoStatutory right? Owning water? Anyone east of the Mississippi wouldn't have any idea what these terms mean. They exist in the west due to accidents of history, combined with the US love for "private property". For example, before NM became a US state, water was managed here at the community level (acqueias), and there was absolutely no notion that anyone owned the water. NM only became a state in 1912, so you're talking about a system that has only existed for a little more than 100 years.
- jessaustin 5y agoPhilosophically, you might be right, although even philosophers are aware of the tragedy of the commons. Practically, however, these are not serious questions. As long as time and effort is wasted on demonizing farmers rather than cooperating in pursuit of our mutual goals, water levels will continue to drop.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoActually, there is and never has been a tragedy of the commons. Historically, commons have been managed by highly evolved communal practice. The so-called tragedies occured after powerful interests first dismantled those practices, and then sought to exploit the commons. Even Hardin (originator of the ToC concept) has acknowledged this. The idea that human societies had commons that were just open to anyone to do anything, and thus they got screwed up is completely ahistorical. It's also a widely used tool in the rhetorical arguments deployed against a return to true (historical) commons. I am not aware of anyone demonizing farmers. It's not demonizing farmers to note the evaporative loss caused by flood and spray irrigation - that's simply a fact. It's not demonizing farmers to note that the whole idea of turning the highly insolated SW into a garden for the nation was originated at a specific time and place, by a specific group of people who refused to be curious about water. It's not demonizing farmers to note that the practice of growing crops for export is effectively the same as exporting water. But yes, cooperation in pursuit of mutal goals is a great idea. One approach that I think has a lot of promise is a system that affects the purchase of water rights for municipal use, from farmers. The purchasing city pays some amount for the water rights, but then throws in a substantial additional payment to cover the capital cost of the farmer converting to drip irrigation. Everybody wins!