5 ms·
In what meaningful sense of the word is a third-party, anonymously-created (and apparently buggy) bot "authoritarian"? This reeks of artificial engagement. HN
by woodruffw 5y ago
In what meaningful sense of the word is a third-party, anonymously-created (and apparently buggy) bot "authoritarian"?
This reeks of artificial engagement. HN should avoid buying into it.
- sadmanycases 5y ago
- woodruffw 5y agoNobody is stopping you from thinking the word "man" or "woman." There's no point in making such a ridiculous claim. This is clearly just a badly programmed bot. However, if you look at one of the (less) buggy PRs it submitted, you'll find an actually helpful change[1]: replacing gendered pronouns with neutral ones makes sense in the context of documentation, wherever that documentation is in fact gender-neutral in disposition. [1]: https://github.com/moby/moby/pull/43441 https://github.com/moby/moby/pull/43441
- starkd 5y agoControlling language is how you control thoughts. It's the chief function of propaganda.
- mongol 5y agoIt is not badly programmed. It is badly intentioned.
- blindmute 5y ago"They" is not a gender neutral singular pronoun to begin with, so the entire concept is wrong
- woodruffw 5y agoSure it is. If it's good enough for the Bard, I think it's good enough for you and me[1]. [1]: https://phys.org/news/2020-01-chronicles-history-gender-neutral-pronouns-shakespeare.html https://phys.org/news/2020-01-chronicles-history-gender-neut...
- blindmute 5y agoMerriam-Webster chose "they" as its 2019 Word of the Year based on the number of dictionary lookups, and the singular "they" was added to its online dictionary in September. In other words, the dictionary added it 3 years ago due to political pressure. It's never been correct English, and it still isn't.
- woodruffw 5y ago“Correct” English is a very silly thing to get hung up on. I’ll repeat myself: if it’s correct enough for Dickens and Shakespeare, the two of us can probably suffer it. (I’ve also never heard any English dictionary make a claim of linguistic completeness, so “it’s not in Merriam-Webster” doesn’t strike me as an important standard.)
- at_a_remove 5y agoIt isn't an important standard for really obscure words. However, if Merriam-Webster forgot something like "him," you would look askance. We both know this. Why pretend?
- xeromal 5y agoYou don't want to wait to the last minute to stop something. If you see an accident forming from afar, you start reacting now. This bot may be a "joke" but it represents the thought police and the author should be sternly reprimanded.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This bot may be a "joke" but it represents the thought police It represents the thought police in exactly the same way that anyone having any opinion represents that.
- maxbond 5y agoSo, what appears to have happened is, someone who views political correctness as stifling made a troll bot to paint their opposition as absurd. And you are asking us to treat this as a representation of a real threat to free thought, and not only to respond, but to respond as it were an emergency or natural disaster. Do you hear how absurd that sounds to my ears?
- cato_the_elder 5y agoWell, if we pretend that it's just this single instance, it probably isn't. But this is part of a cultural phenomenon, unless you want to argue that wokism doesn't exist.
- woodruffw 5y agoThis is what I meant by artificial engagement: we're now in the "complain about vague cultural phenomena" segment of the program. Besides, there's nothing particularly wrong with cooking on a Wok.
- cato_the_elder 5y ago> vague cultural phenomena It's not vague at all. > Besides, there's nothing particularly wrong with cooking on a Wok. Lol, I had to look up what a wok is. Blessings of learning English as a second language.
- dragonwriter 5y ago[flagged]
- smegsicle 5y ago> reflects no coherent ideology it sure is incoherent, but it sure is persistent
- cato_the_elder 5y agoThat's certainly an argument you can make. I kinda agree with what you imply about the lack of logical coherence, but unfortunately that's not necessary for cultural movements. Don't you agree that there's a relationship between having pronouns in the bio, reading Ibram X. Kendi, being "intersectional", believing words are violence, and sporting purple hair?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I kinda agree with what you imply about the lack of logical coherence I didn't imply anything, I explicitly stated that the term “wokism” as currently used, doesn't refer to either an actual ideology, cultural phenomenon, or even a set of ideas or groups of people more connected than that they are things the dominant faction of the political Right disagrees with at the moment of the use of the label. > Don't you agree that there's a relationship between having pronouns in the bio, reading Ibram X. Kendi, being "intersectional", believing words are violence, and sporting purple hair? No, I don't. Believing (certain uses of) words are violence seems to be common across the political spectrum, though which uses of which words varies, purple hair is pretty orthogonal to politics (as is the more common feature used in this context, blue hair), intersectional isn't something a person can be, and while the first two things do correlate with political positions the Right opposes they (and the political positions they each correlate strongly with) don't correlate very strongly with each other. (In fact, that's a perennial complaint of the group that represents the intersection of those two communities.)