4 ms·
You're gonna have some similar thing no matter what gets settled on, unless there's a flawless protocol out there but those are pretty rare in my experience. I
by giraffe_lady 5y ago
You're gonna have some similar thing no matter what gets settled on, unless there's a flawless protocol out there but those are pretty rare in my experience.
I think the comparison is more like "is having an ad-hoc semi-standard wire protocol built around the postgres one better than having none at all?" and I think the answer is yes.
But it's not like there's an authority making this choice for everyone. If you think something else is better then use it in your tools and push for it. Postgres is ancient, open source, widely used and adapted for many different use cases. I think those all make it hard to beat in just a practical "worse is better" type way, but I also think people saying "no. we can do better" is good too, esp when they demonstrate it.
- clhodapp 5y agoI agree with everything you said! I was reacting to "I don't see the harm" specifically. Ultimately, I think that with a few improvements to the Postgres protocol, settling on it wouldn't even be a "worse is better" outcome.