4 ms·
> P.S: [..] Birds, she thought at the time, didn’t have penises. In her two years studying them at Cornell University, a world leader in avian research, she’d n
by mschuster91 5y ago
> P.S: [..] Birds, she thought at the time, didn’t have penises. In her two years studying them at Cornell University, a world leader in avian research, she’d never once heard her colleagues mention a bird penis.[..] Huh! Really? Cornell university scientists don’t know what a farm child picks up during one farming season? The article is full of red flags for clickbait lies.
Uh, here in Germany we took until February 2022 to have the first anatomically correct drawing of a human clitoris in a schoolbook [1]. I'm pretty sure the US hasn't reached even that state, given that university textbooks aren't accurate either [2].
And when we can't even manage to have anatomically correct drawings in university textbooks for our own species, how on earth can we assume that the situation is different in veterinary science?!
Farm kids obviously know the difference because they have first-hand experience. But most farm kids don't go and become veterinary scientists or scientists at all!
[1] https://kurier.at/leben/gesellschaft/keine-scham-klitoris-erstmals-korrekt-in-schulbuechern-abgebildet/401906452 https://kurier.at/leben/gesellschaft/keine-scham-klitoris-er...
[2]: https://www.vice.com/en/article/nejny8/fear-of-the-clit-a-brief-history-of-medical-books-erasing-womens-genitalia https://www.vice.com/en/article/nejny8/fear-of-the-clit-a-br...
- InCityDreams 5y ago>Uh, here in Germany we took until February 2022 to have the first anatomically correct drawing of a human clitoris in a schoolbook [1]. Oh, for shame. Back in the '70s a whole bunch of pictures of human (oh, and animal) clitorinks were hidden in a box under my friends dads bed.
- b112 5y agoBut most farm kids don't go and become veterinary scientists or scientists at all! What the?! Where is your data on this? Do you think the offspring of farmers are stupid? This seems incredibly biased.
- zardo 5y agoScientists are what 1% of the population? I doubt even children of scientists mostly become scientists.
- prasadjoglekar 5y agoAnd that 1% is further distributed along a competency curve. Substantially less than 100% of scientists are actually good at their job.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoTo give generous interpretation whenever possible, I am assuming op is talking simple statistics: I.e. "Most of anything don't become veterinary scientists".
- mschuster91 5y agoActually, I meant what I said. Rural and urban education outcomes are provably and statistically relevant different [1] - I simply assumed this to be at least somewhat common knowledge or at least intuition. [1]: https://academic.oup.com/joeg/article/21/5/683/5998980 https://academic.oup.com/joeg/article/21/5/683/5998980
- QuarterReptile 5y ago>But most farm kids don't go and become veterinary scientists or scientists at all! This statement lives or dies by your definition of 'scientist', but if we're talking about research scientists, it seems trivially obvious that a group constituting a small minority of the population would be quite unlikely to be a majority of 'farm kids'. Having gotten that out of the way,I agree that it read as deliberately derogatory. Grandparent also draws the specious connection between knowledge and something being present in elementary textbooks, which I found more misleading. Clearly the body of knowledge of a society extends infinitely beyond the contents of their elementary textbooks; even the knowledge of the grade-school user of said book does so.
- kjeksfjes 5y agoMost kids don't go and become scientists – why on earth would saying that specifically about farm kids be biased? Also, isn't farming an occupation where it's more common to inherit it from your parents than for other occupations? Also, why would not becoming scientists equal to being stupid? Kind of biased, hmm?
- mschuster91 5y agoAs described in a parallel comment: Farm kids mostly live in, well, rural areas (okay, there is a small percentage of farms in urban areas too...), which means that the chance of them obtaining higher education is provably lower than the chance that urban-area kids get.
- mschuster91 5y ago> What the?! Where is your data on this? See for example here: https://academic.oup.com/joeg/article/21/5/683/5998980 https://academic.oup.com/joeg/article/21/5/683/5998980 > Do you think the offspring of farmers are stupid? No, rather that the education opportunities in rural areas are rather scarce and underfunded (because school funding depends on the number of citizens, which is lower in rural areas), and as a result the education outcomes are worse (see above).
- saalweachter 5y ago> But most farm kids don't go and become veterinary scientists or scientists at all! I think the more accurate complaint is most farm kids don't grow up on farms with ducks. Ducks are pretty niche in the US. If it's not on the menu at McDonald's or Taco Bell, it's not on 95% of US farms.
- missedthecue 5y agoDucks are very common on US farms. Go to any 4H meet.
- saalweachter 5y agoI grew up on a farm in Indiana, went through 4H, and I've never seen a duck penis, nor heard word of them til the internet got ahold of the news, and Indiana accounts for 45% of US duck production. Which I also didn't know until googling it just now.
- chrischen 5y agoI’m not an ornithologist and I already knew about exploding corkscrew duck penises (via Wikipedia) for about half a decade. I also thought it was weird the article wrote it as if a researcher just discovered this information.
- saalweachter 5y agoWell, the article starts from the year 2000. I don't know exactly when I first learned about duck penises and labyrinthine duck vaginas, it's not precisely a 9/11 memory, but it was certainly after I left the farm in 2001 and could be entirely due to news reports about this researcher's research trickling out to the pop sci blogosphere.
- someweirdperson 5y agoWorld of warcarft, that displays every kind of topography, vegetation, animals, references to any form of pop culture, sports, ... does not contain a single duck. Either the author have never seen one. Or they are scared of Disney. Hints for the latter might be that there no mice either. For visual completeness there are rats, which is close enough to not need mice.
- refurb 5y agoNot shocked at all your sourced Vice.