14 ms·
In Defense of Bitcoin Maximalism
- nadahalli 5y agoI started reading the article assuming it was an April fool's joke. After a bit into it, I thought it was not a joke. When the self-deprecation began, I was again convinced it was a joke - but at the end of the article, I think this is not a joke. It's a rather good take on why Bitcoin maximalism is what it is. Some degree of ETH-maximalism will be required in the future given the sheer number of pretender L-1 blockchains snapping at ETH's heels. Writing about BTC-maximalism sets the foundation for that culture.
- skybrian 5y agoIt seems that Vitalik decided to write the best defense he could of Bitcoin and publish it on April 1st. And that's the joke.
- bhaak 5y agoThat's a very Vitalik thing to do. For all the heat he gets from Bitcoiners I consider it a net negative that crypto split up into so many different camps. I wonder how the crypto space would have looked like if the Bitcoin space allowed people like Vitalik to work within it instead of being driven away.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoWhen you see Bitcoin and Dogecoin being staked on ETH contracts and services (now) I feel like we haven't lost!
- bhaak 5y agoYou're praising bridge contracts just a few days after a bridge contract has been drained by hundreds of millions of dollars? :) Also, who is "we"? Bitcoiners, Etherians, crypto people in general, or some other crypto group?
- aaaaaaaaata 5y ago"The crypto space"
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoNot every L2 is created equal.
- namlem 5y agoMeta-irony, I love it
- buildbuildbuild 5y agoIt's no coincidence that some of the strongest criticism against cryptocurrency happens here, in a community mostly of banked, relatively prosperous people in stable countries. May you never personally experience being unbanked or otherwise financially oppressed.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoWhere would you say that the "unbanked, relatively not prosperous people in unstable countries" stand - in the "really like and benefit from cryptocurrency" camp, or in the "never heard of and don't care about cryptocurrency" camp ? > May you never personally experience being unbanked or otherwise financially oppressed. Of course. But this is unrelated, unless you're making the "politician's fallacy": "We must do something (about that). This is something. Therefore, we must do this."
- zzzeek 5y agocorrect me if I'm wrong but people using bitcoin in oppressed countries will basically be rendered penniless by simply cutting off network access. source: https://lukeplant.me.uk/blog/posts/the-technological-case-against-bitcoin-and-blockchain/#security https://lukeplant.me.uk/blog/posts/the-technological-case-ag...
- cinntaile 5y agoPeople bypass China's firewall as well, why would this be subject to a different reality? Also even if we were to assume they can't access it, it doesn't mean the funds have disappeared from the wallet.
- game_the0ry 5y agoAs long as you know your private key and / or seed phrase, you will always have access to your wallet's funds. As soon as you get network access, you can transact. You literally have to cut off the internet to stop crypto - that is part of what makes it so compelling.
- 5y ago
- tromp 5y ago> Blockchains sacrifice privacy, requiring even crazier and more expensive technology to get that privacy back. The Mimblewimble protocol [0] bucks that trend, providing more privacy at the base layer while being less expensive in terms of the historical size of transactions [1]. > a focus on simplicity and deep mathematical purity: a 1 MB block size, a 21 million coin limit A supply of 50/(2^{height/210000}) coins every 10 minutes is not particularly simple or pure. One coin per second forever seems preferable, even if it takes a century to get inflation down to 1% [2]. > The protocol design must be easy to justify decades and centuries down the line; the technology and parameter choices must be a work of art. This is where Ethereum fails miserably. > The second ingredient is the culture of uncompromising, steadfast minimalism. Even bitcoin is not that minimal if you consider the complexities of bitcoin script. Much of that functionality can be achieved with scriptless scripts [3]. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20190312100102/https://www.circle.com/en/research/mimblewimble https://web.archive.org/web/20190312100102/https://www.circl... [1] https://forum.grin.mw/t/scalability-vs-privacy-chart https://forum.grin.mw/t/scalability-vs-privacy-chart [2] https://john-tromp.medium.com/a-case-for-using-soft-total-supply-1169a188d153 https://john-tromp.medium.com/a-case-for-using-soft-total-su... [3] https://medium.com/scalar-capital/scriptless-scripts-25e18fd52ede https://medium.com/scalar-capital/scriptless-scripts-25e18fd...
- phyro 5y agoThere's also something to be said about extreme design simplicity and resilience to change. Bitcoin is already really good at this, but when the system design is so simple that any change looks invasive, it ossifies even sooner and makes changes even less likely. Removing opportunities for discussion (e.g. scripting support and opcode discussions) also removes opportunity for conflicts regarding a protocol feature. Simpler design may come at the cost of slightly less expressivity, but at the benefit of being naturally more resilient to change.
- Cobragri 5y ago''Eth fails miserably '' Ethereum failed already at beginning. A blockchain; Mutable ,premined and ICO is already there. Eth is the target for regulations and censorship sooner or later. And i agree with that scalability is very important part of decentralization. Privacy and scalability well balanced in MimbleWimble.
- NoblePublius 5y agoWhy is uncensorable money worth the risk of permanently losing your money because you forgot a password or lost a thumb drive?
- game_the0ry 5y agoTrade offs - bitcoin is not a free lunch. If you want to be fully sovereign with your wealth, you have to accept full responsibility of that wealth. If that is not a responsibility you want bc you believe it is too risky, then do not buy bitcoin. Or, you can trust centralized authority (a bank) with that responsibility; obviously, the trade off is you lose full control of your wealth. Additionally, how you approach ownership of your wealth is not binary. Nothing is stopping you from putting some proportion of each in either bank or bitcoin.
- enkid 5y agoWhat does being fully sovereign mean for something that's only used as a medium of exchange? It's value is always only meaningful when at least two people agree on it's value. At best you only control half of the equation.
- smeej 5y agoThe comparison isn't reasonably between "sovereign control of your wealth" and "in total control of what everyone else values." That doesn't even make sense. The question worth asking is about how controlling your own wealth, but having to trust the value of it to a giant swath of people over which no one entity has any significant control, compares to not having any control of your own wealth, AND having the value of any wealth you do have dependent entirely on the will of some unelected bureaucrat.
- game_the0ry 5y ago> It's value is always only meaningful when at least two people agree on it's value. Is it not totally obvious that bitcoin has market value? If not, consider these points - bitcoin was not created by MIT and Uchicago STEM and econ PhDs, it was born out of an anonymous internet "white paper." It proved itself as a type of "money" in the internet dark markets, and continues to do so. It wasn't "lab tested," it was tested in the real world. When China banned crypto, the price of bitcoin did not crash. Only authoritarian countries have banned it, while some US lawmakers hold bitcoin and Gensler (chairmen of the SEC) taught a class at MIT about crypto. These should be very compelling aspects of bitcoin.
- michael_j_ward 5y agoThe Defense of Toxicity section reads to me like a defense of Linus Torvalds or Richard Stallman.
- pygy_ 5y agoTorvalds has apologized for past toxic and the damage it incurred, behavior and has vowed to do better from then on.
- nwah1 5y agoUh oh
- michael_j_ward 5y agoVitalik proposed a theory that the toxicity is a valid and perhaps even necessary defense mechanism. I don't pretend to know whether Vitalik's theory is true, but it certainly seems plausible. And defending linux from bad actors is a herculean task. If Torvald's toxicity helped him in that endeavor, his apology would be a negative development. Interestingly, the Rust community has had incredible success being explicitly anti-toxic. It's a wonderful community that I enjoy. Rust is also now reaching a level importance that it will be a target to be coopted as described by Vitalik, as prominent members of the Rust community have expressed concern over [0]. [0] https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/1437441118745071617 https://twitter.com/steveklabnik/status/1437441118745071617
- javert 5y ago> Vitalik proposed a theory... That is not at all original to Vitalik. It pre-exists in the bitcoin community and maybe is even older than that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- phyro 5y agoIt seems to me the threat model of Rust is a magnitude safer than that of Bitcoin under assumption that Bitcoin was to become a global store of wealth. Toxicity acts as a shield to protect against social attacks from the big players which may try to, in some way, capture control of the network or influence its direction. And there are very good incentives to try and do that. It's also why it's important for the protocol to ossify over time and become even more conservative. Rust, as well as the vast majority of open source communities, doesn't really need that these levels of toxicity to survive in the long run because the attack vectors aren't on the same level (although still very important to deflect attacks because there are other incentives in play). At least it seems to me to be this way, I'll gladly listen to a counter-argument.
- chinathrow 5y ago> Crypto-assets like Bitcoin have real cultural and structural advantages that make them powerful assets worth holding and using. Not for me. Why would an asset, which I can lose, have no direct control over it or even better, whose storage places are hacked on a weekly basis, earn my trust? And no, I am not even starting about the energy waste most crypto-assets are.
- bluepnume 5y agoYou don't like it because it's possible to lose? Are all of your other physical possessions immune from being lost?
- ineedasername 5y agoBitcoin is not a physical possession. My money right now is (mostly) not a physical possession either. It exists as a non-blockchain ledger entry in bank's computer system, and cannot be lost as easily as crypto currency, even if I make a mistake like forgetting my password.
- ekianjo 5y agoDont worry it will be slowly lost to inflation anyway without you doing anything about it
- short_sells_poo 5y agoWhich is why people are encouraged not to keep their wealth in money. We can get bogged down in endless discussions about the theory of money, but my view is that money is not meant to be an appreciating asset. It is meant to be an easily fungible currency that discourages hoarding so that it's always put to work.
- ineedasername 5y ago"Dont" [sic] worry, it's invested, not stagnant.
- 5y ago
- motohagiography 5y agoI'm seriously considering a career pivot to being a freelance editor for cryptocurrency bloggers as not-having one appears to be one of the few things crypto millionaires can no longer afford. Given it's April Fools day, I think this may be GPT-3 trained on crypto subreddits and rationalist blogs.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rethab 5y agoReads very much like written by GPT-3
- tastyfreeze 5y agoWell, Vitalik is a robot...
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoAlien, actually.
- motohagiography 5y agoCanadian, technically.
- EGreg 5y agoWe've been hearing for years that the future is blockchain, not Bitcoin. They're wrong. The future is smart contracts, and moving off blockchains in favor of other distributed systems. Blockchains is what's holding the entire space back. These are the three things that need to be done to make crypto go mainstream: https://intercoin.org/proposal.pdf https://intercoin.org/proposal.pdf
- prohobo 5y agoPeople still don't understand cryptocurrencies, and at this point it seems more like intentional obtuseness for political reasons. At the same time, cryptocurrencies still haven't provided a killer app that shuts everyone up. So, IMO that's the only real thing that matters. Either you build something with it that's useful - or it isn't useful. I understand that it's difficult because of all the infrastructure required (much of which still doesn't exist), but that's where all efforts should be. Create a consumer service that people want. Otherwise, if the idea is that it's simply a trade-off of the speed/efficiency for otherwise mundane services in order to make them decentralized, then stop hyping it and let it become a parallel structure - or underground system that some people use.
- orblivion 5y agoI think as you start to hear about stories from people in (just as an example) Ukraine escaping and being able to take their wealth with them, you're seeing the principal "killer app". It's the same "killer app" as burying gold in a secret location. It only comes up in emergencies.
- bhaak 5y agoIf that is the only killer app crypto can produce then it's not useful to most people and will stay a niche technology forever.
- orblivion 5y agoIt's not useful to people almost all the time but it's vital and one-of-a-kind for that certain scenario. Though I could similarly throw in dissidents earning money and financing. I could just repeat what's in the article. In the mean time, sure, it would be smart to find other use cases.
- bhaak 5y agoI'm not sure if it really is one of a kind. Having a bit of money on PayPal would cover almost all scenarios equally well and even have less friction actually using your money. The combination of PayPal and Gold doesn't seem to justify to me the valuation of a market cap of 800 billion dollars or in other words, a daily budget of 40 million dollars for securing the blockchain.
- prions 5y agoSo the author points to a link claiming 12% of Ukrainians own crypto, yet triple-a creates a circular reference in trying to substantiate this claim: - The author refers to: https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership-ukraine/ https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership-ukraine/ - This link calls it an estimate: "It is estimated that over 5.5 million people, 12.7% of Ukraine’s total population, currently own cryptocurrency.(1)" - Link (1) points to https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership/ https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership/ - The link under "Ukraine" in that list points back to the first claim: https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership-ukraine/ https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership-ukraine/ At the bottom of their data page: "The data contained or reflected herein are proprietary of TripleA."
- djbebs 5y agoThis is literally an april fools joke...
- prions 5y agoSo all of the data for https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership/ https://triple-a.io/crypto-ownership/ is fake?
- InitialLastName 5y agoIt might or might not be fake. All we can say is that it can't be substantiated by anything on their website (they aren't referring to external sources), and that they are pretending that their data has been independently substantiated (presumably hoping nobody actually follows the citation links).
- latchkey 5y agoIt is quite a sight to watch someone explain to someone else that something that they read on the internet, might not be believable.
- mirntyfirty 5y agoTrue, and the concerning thing is that it’s indistinguishable from the normal PR and marketing pieces. The Matt Damon commercials are ridiculous.
- flaque 5y agoPerhaps before commenting today, look at the date.
- asah 5y agogeez people it's an April Fools joke!! Vitalik Buterin is the founder of Ethereum.
- thinkmassive 5y agoAnd also, probably lesser known, he’s the founder of Bitcoin Magazine
- SubiculumCode 5y agoAll the arguments here for BTC maximalism are actually better arguments for Monero, which is also MORE decentralized and is unparalleled in privacy.
- phyro 5y agoMonero has some strong points, but it's actually LESS decentralized than Bitcoin. A Monero confidential transaction is 1.5kb while a Bitcoin transaction which is only around 300 bytes. For the argument of decentralization, it doesn't matter that it doesn't blind the amounts or add decoys inputs, the 5x size of a transaction itself means that the chain is much bigger than Bitcoin under the same load which makes it less decentralized due to much higher storage requirements for a full node. It's also much slower to verify the history because of all the rangeproofs that need to be validated for all outputs that have been ever created.
- tenuousemphasis 5y agoHonest question because I don't know much about Monero: can you build layered networks like Lighting on top of Monero as you can with Bitcoin? If not, then Monero seems a non-starter for a global currency/payment system.
- orblivion 5y agoSo the creator of Ethereum makes (imo) a very impressive steelman argument against Ethereum (and most other coins). He clearly took some time with this. Pretty interesting take on the April Fools joke. I sincerely understand Bitcoin maximalism now better than I have before.
- thinkmassive 5y agoKeep in mind, before he started Ethereum, back in 2011 Vitalik started Bitcoin Magazine.
- BTCOG 5y agoAlso keeping in mind, Vitalik has always loved Bitcoin he just doesn't care for the maximalist culture so much. Vitalik created Ethereum after raking in tons of Bitcoin, loving the idea but choosing to take it in another direction with the smart contracting that had been disabled within the Bitcoin code.
- stillsut 5y agoWho would have thought Vitalik would have been the first human(?) to pass an Intellectual Turing Test of mimicking his ideological opponent? Laudably, he seeks only to remove the beam from his own eye [0], and turns criticism not only on his own public persona, but his own team's legacy and design decisions, and even steelmans the more "seedy" aspects of bitcoin culture. It's hard not to see the massive influence of Scott Alexander in the way Vitalik presents his ideas and structures his essay. One SSC meme that kept coming up in my mind as I read the essay is that "ideas are soldiers" [1] is certainly in play with the blockchain wars. It's refreshing to see we have leaders in this space that can recognize the bravery of the enemy's soldiers. At least for today! [0]: https://biblehub.com/matthew/7-5.htm https://biblehub.com/matthew/7-5.htm [1]: https://www.lesswrong.com/tag/arguments-as-soldiers https://www.lesswrong.com/tag/arguments-as-soldiers
- lawrenceyan 5y agoVitalik is such a gigachad big brain 4D chess rotator that he can still manage to write an extremely insightful commentary even when it’s as an April Fool’s joke.