3 ms·
There's got to be clear advantage, or at least no strong disadvantage across the morphological choices they are constrained to, in the forms. Isabella Rossolini
by ggm 5y ago
There's got to be clear advantage, or at least no strong disadvantage across the morphological choices they are constrained to, in the forms. Isabella Rossolini aside, there's no dance here which is pure beauty, its form-follows-function all the way.
Ducks are savage. York University where I studied, in the 70s had a huge shallow lake and it had a regrettable sexual population imbalance which caused fatalities. Randy drakes drowned the decreasing number of ducks. I think they had to do culling to fix it. You think nature would right itself, but in human time for small local populations sometimes it doesn't do a good job.
- throwanem 5y ago> You think nature would right itself Why think this? Populations and their environments constitute complex systems, not magical ones. They can self-correct, or not, just like how humans don't always manage to not develop cancer.
- giomasce 5y agoLetting a part of the population die, perhaps entire species or groups of species, is one of the way nature "rights itself".
- ben_w 5y agoDescribing a species wiping itself out as “nature righting itself” seems to me a bit like saying a shotgun is a cure for cancer.
- tjs8rj 5y agoWhy is that not accurate? Nature is just physical processes. Those physical processes taking their course is really all nature does. You could call it “righting itself” or “destroying itself” and I’d say you’re equally right, because the same physical process occurs without moral judgement, and your connotation is just you applying your human morality to the situation
- ben_w 5y agoIn a mechanical system, say a bicycle, “righting itself” implies returning to an upright position rather than any transition to a stable state — a bike lying horizontal on the ground is in a stable state, but falling over isn’t physics righting itself.
- eru 5y agoWell, the fatalities were exactly how nature 'righted itself'. Nature ain't squeamish.
- andrewflnr 5y agoThe fatalities were a vicious spiral. The males were killing more females, deepening the imbalance.
- 7steps2much 5y agoWhich means the next generation would be even smaller and so on and so forth until at one point the thing is reduced to a point where it is no longer sustaining the spiral. Or at least that's how I imagine it would go.
- eru 5y agoFor better or worse, that point might be a population of zero.
- andrewflnr 5y agoWell, let's just say extinction is not the first definition of "nature righting itself" that comes to mind for this scenario.