7 ms·
Fake emergency search warrants draw scrutiny from Capitol Hill
- hoppyhoppy2 5y agoFor those first encountering this topic, it's a followup to the story that was discussed 2 days ago at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30842757 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30842757
- morpheuskafka 5y agoI can't believe all they were doing was validating the email, if that's true. Virtually every town, city, borough, county, etc. across the country has a police/sheriff's department, sometimes as small as a few people. Even a few private companies have them. Sure the NYPD, FBI, etc. are going to (theoretically) have top security, but if any LEO anywhere in the country is good enough, just hack some podunk PD that exists solely to generate ticket revenue and has no IT department, no 2FA, no security training.
- judge2020 5y agoPretty much what they did. https://krebsonsecurity.com/2022/03/hackers-gaining-power-of-subpoena-via-fake-emergency-data-requests/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2022/03/hackers-gaining-power-of... ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30842757 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30842757 ) > Providers have a streamlined process where they publish the fax or contact information for police to get emergency access to data. But there’s no real mechanism defined by most Internet service providers or tech companies to test the validity of a search warrant or subpoena. And so as long as it looks right, they’ll comply
- gonehome 5y agoI can't really fault the tech companies for this, it's not a great place to be in and there isn't an obvious solution. The bad actors are explicitly exploiting an emergency provision intended for quick information return to prevent serious harm/death using verified police accounts they've compromised. You either end up with the headline we have here or "Apple's failure to comply with an emergency request led to the death of X" I don't know what the right policy is, but this is just a tradeoff without an easy answer.
- DennisP 5y agoI don't know, maybe look up the police department's number online and call them back? If we can do it when the "bank" calls us and asks for private information, maybe these guys could do the same.
- dvtrn 5y agoI can't really fault the tech companies for this, it's not a great place to be in and there isn't an obvious solution. For all of the box ticking, theatrical diligence and audit-preparedness work I’ve had assigned to me in my Devops career, and bespoke security “services” and “products” out there that merely exist to enable more box ticking in the name of “security and compliance”, I think maybe we should start.
- klyrs 5y agoSadly, the "common sense" solution would be a single email provider -- something provided by the federal government. Alas, sense isn't common in the US: it's up to every state (and, it would appear, county, city, university, etc) to decide.
- throwaway81523 5y agoOne obvious thing I'd do if Officer Bob from the Podunk PD asked me for anything, is say "let me call you back", find the published phone number of the Podunk PD, call it, and ask for Officer Bob. I'd of course tell him I was about to do that, so he could arrange to receive a call from the PD front desk, or at least have them confirm that they had just talked to him. So the crooks would have to intercept that front desk number too, if they wanted to fake it. That would at least slow them down a little more, I hope.
- manquer 5y agoSocial engineering this is trival. Lookup for a phone will likely be on their website. The threat actor could compromise the website just as they did for the email, Or create a legitimate looking fake one, not every department has one or is indexed well Tech support staff handling these requests cannot possibly know the thousands of police departments sites to know if the site is legitimate. There is simply no single national authoritative source for validation ( international is even more complex with different laws and languages)
- ashtonkem 5y agoNevermind the risk that it’s actually a cop sending these requests for their own personal reasons. It’s far from unheard of for cops to abuse these systems to harass former partners and personal rivals; the courts are supposed to provide oversight to prevent these abuses.
- CrazyMusicians 5y agoYou're absolutely right. Here's one high-profile example: https://www.thedailybeast.com/feds-say-bounty-hunter-matthew-marre-used-suicide-hoax-to-con-verizon-t-mobile-out-of-customer-data https://www.thedailybeast.com/feds-say-bounty-hunter-matthew...
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoHow can police get data without a court order? Shouldn't there be a 24/7 court number, where the police can request one, and then use that? What happens if the police abuses this system (and not the hackers)... does anyone get notified that "p.o. John Doe requested your data on 1. 1. 2022"? And why not? If it's a life or death situation, and you're still alive, you'll either be thankful they used the data to save you, or your laywer could get a lot happier, because you'd be suing them, because they faked such a situation.
- pigtailgirl 5y agoamerican legal system is already massively backed up + there is also a judge shortage https://calmatters.org/justice/2021/01/justice-courts-overwhelmed-pandemic/ https://calmatters.org/justice/2021/01/justice-courts-overwh... https://legal.thomsonreuters.com/en/insights/articles/backlog-reshape-future-courts https://legal.thomsonreuters.com/en/insights/articles/backlo... https://www.dcreport.org/2022/01/12/theres-a-critical-shortage-of-federal-judges/ https://www.dcreport.org/2022/01/12/theres-a-critical-shorta...
- dghlsakjg 5y agoAnd yet, drug task forces seem to have no problem getting warrants pretty quick to search a car that is stopped. “The system is broke” feels like a poor excuse for arbitrarily handing over all of someone’s data without notification
- judge2020 5y ago> drug task forces seem to have no problem getting warrants pretty quick to search a car that is stopped. Does this happen often? Most stops tell the story of the officer having probable cause for a search, even if that's just the smell of weed or something (not sure if it's still a valid reason).
- Larrikin 5y agoDespite what the Jay-Z song says police don't need a warrant to search your car https://baldanilaw.com/jay-zs-99-problems/ https://baldanilaw.com/jay-zs-99-problems/
- Jerrrry 5y agoEvery gaming platform will give the information upon "emergency request," and most CSR's, siding in caution, will happily give out the name, mailing address...email, and even challenge questions... It's a social engineering attack that has worked 2ezily since 2007. Similar to SWATting, but essentially in reverse. Also abusable are the new GDPR requests. Compliance is pretty much at odds with security of the account itself. Complying with the inane EU rules basically makes your system at risk at trivial account takeover, which juxtapositionally/ironically then make it easier to leverage a person. It's like 2FA over SMS....you are basically at the mercy of a Verizon/ATT employee. Stop trusting humans, make systems that humans cannot make unilateral decisions without a reasonable amount of redtape.
- etripe 5y ago> Also abusable are the new GDPR requests. How? Seems to me that if they're storing (and handing over) data that allows trivial account takeover, they have a broken security process to begin with.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoWyden seems to be ahead of the loop on this kind of stuff - is he normally this far ahead of the game? My understanding is that he is basically the only person in congress that actually bothers to understand about these kind of threats but reading this article it seems he is even further ahead than I would have expected.
- sdenton4 5y agoIt's a fun thought experiment - How many 'really important' topics are there in the US, where it would be worthwhile to have at least one Congress Critter who understands it really well? Every MoC has some responsibility to a geographic constituency, and some topical specialization through committee assignments... Geography can create /some/ specialization through electoral incentives, but mostly in rural and resource extracting districts... (Such as Manchin and the coal industry... sigh.)
- corpMaverick 5y agoMany countries have plurinominal representatives. They are not elected for a geographic district since many groups may not be able to win a single district but they have people all across the country and they represent a fair % of the total population. (i.e. lgtb, cyclists, scientists, etc) Plurinominal representatives are also a counter balance to gerrymandering tendencies.
- Someone1234 5y agoOutside a national system/portal (wherein you can implement all the security you want) it doesn't seem solvable. You need law enforcement and the judiciary to sign on though, since actual fake warrants will be their next target. The prospect if using certificate signed email is an unrealistic tech-nerd dream, the average rural law enforcement personal can barely use Word and has poor or no on-site IT staff. If it is harder to use than Gmail, you may have well forget it. Could a centralized portal get hacked? Absolutely. But the security spend can be significantly higher, and entirely fictional police departments almost entirely eliminated.
- Spooky23 5y agoIt’s definitely doable. Most states operate portals to facilitate many types of transactions, and it would be easy enough to offer this as a service. This is exactly the way locals use things like codis.
- gpm 5y ago> the average rural law enforcement personal can barely use Word and has poor or no on-site IT staff. Maybe this should be a sign that they have no business requesting sensitive information be transferred to their poorly secured computers? If you let them use insecure computers as endpoints it seems like that there will inevitably continue to be data leaks -- regardless of what sort of security you put on the portal(s) that they use their insecure computers to access. I don't see that a national portal fixes this. Perhaps a national IT-department that controls all the computers involved would work, though I can only imagine what a nightmare setting that up would be.
- JasonFruit 5y agoThis is what you get when you don't require a court to order the release of private information. This, and out of control law enforcement, that is.
- perfecthjrjth 5y agoAll tech companies have provided an interface for the law enforcement. No need to verify warrants, no need to show warrants, as long as one is from the law enforcement.
- ganzuul 5y agoUnfettered access without oversight as was acceptable during WWII in practice means LE is behaving as if they are fighters in a war. If they are not regular militia, then according to official US narrative they are insurgents. Turns out the war on drugs was a war against the People.
- snarf21 5y agoAgreed, but it still baffles me that people want to give LE backdoors to encryption to "protect the children" and because "they have done nothing wrong".
- nyolfen 5y agoi think wyden might be the only sitting politician i have an unvarnished admiration for
- throwaway81523 5y agoWhy are EDR's from LE even a thing? If it's really such a matter of life and death, they should have a judge on call (i.e. a judge-type judge, with a robe and a gavel) to issue an emergency court order. So it's a real court order and not some simulation from a police department. Of course that can also be forged so this question is only about why judges are removed from the loop. If it's really a matter of life and death, wake up the damn judge. If that's too big a deal, you are doing too many of these "emergency" requests.
- throwawaygh 5y agoOur courts and legislative bodies have not grown in size linearly with the population, but the modus operandi of these institutions has also not changed. The distortion of too many people per representative without a change in how representation functions explains a lot of our issues.
- mescaline 5y agoA 100 more million people since I was in high school has ruined things around here, traffic mostly.
- dataflow 5y ago> If it's really a matter of life and death, wake up the damn judge. This really isn't a reasonable expectation. There are only so many judges, and being on-call 24/7 for all emergencies is not part of their job description, and it probably should not be, either. They need clarity of mind when they're making decisions, not to be in a sleepy mood. Moreover, you seem to be proposing a solution in search of a problem. There isn't widespread abuse of this by cops in the US (that I've heard of, anyway) to justify upending an otherwise effective procedure.
- chimeracoder 5y ago> There isn't widespread abuse of this by cops in the US (that I've heard of, anyway) to justify upending an otherwise effective procedure. There's massive abuse of police power to get access to data that would normally require a warrant. The only reason EDRs aren't abused more often is because it's often easier for cops to use more "straightforward" approaches like threatening the person/organization they want to get the data from, or lying (or misrepresenting) in order to get the other party to "voluntarily" give up the information.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kome 5y agoItaly and other countries implemented and open and parallel mail system for legal documents. While it is still possible to forge emails, it makes it much harder to do so. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certified_email https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certified_email In order to open one of those email accounts you need to give full details using Italian digital identity (SPID). It is also possible to forge a SPID, but that's even more complicated. So, to sum up, it's quite an antifragile system. Relatively simple, widely adopted and secure enough.
- xyst 5y agoThis is a problem that can be solved with existing solutions like MFA. Provide a one time use code with each “emergency search warrant” to sign off on it. The company can then verify this one time use code, invalidate it, and provide the necessary information. Any further requests using that same code will get denied and the LEO account will be flagged for review. Still scary that information is given to LEOs without a proper warrant. I think in these emergency cases should notify the individual(s) their information is accessed/requested via quasi-legal channels. This would allow users to take proactive measures as well.