3 ms·
> San Francisco proposed a new bus lane on Van Ness in 2001. Its opening was delayed to 2022, yielding a project duration of around 7,600 days. “The project has
by paxys 5y ago
> San Francisco proposed a new bus lane on Van Ness in 2001. Its opening was delayed to 2022, yielding a project duration of around 7,600 days. “The project has been delayed due to an increase of wet weather since the project started,” said Paul Rose, a San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency spokesperson. The project will cost $310 million, i.e. $100,000 per meter. The Alaska Highway, mentioned above, constructed across remote tundra, cost $793 per meter in 2019 dollars.
A similar example – the Golden Gate Bridge was built in 4 years in the 1930s at a (inflation adjusted) cost of $500M, ahead of schedule and 10% under budget. A project to install suicide nets below the bridge started in 2008 and is still ongoing after multiple delays, with a total projected cost of $211M.
- planetsprite 5y agowhy does this happen? Our technology is magnitudes more advanced, we have better preexisting infrastructure, materials, measuring equipment, yet the nation with the world's most powerful economy doesn't hold a candle to it's past achievements.
- ummonk 5y agoInflation adjustment takes into account the advancements though. The comparison would look a little better if we adjusted for median hourly wages instead of adjusting for inflation.
- pixl97 5y agoBecause it's not a technology problem. In general it's a political and regulatory problem. There's a term for this, but I cant think of it at the moment.
- paxys 5y agoBecause we have spent decades retooling our entire economy to send manufacturing and heavy industry to cheaper countries. Get an entire Chinese construction crew to come build a bridge in San Francisco under their own labor/safety/environmental laws and they will show you that early-mid 1900s efficiency.
- babyshake 5y agoAnd we don't do this because of unions?
- Olreich 5y agoNo, it’s because of everything. Increased specialization of our construction crews, increased oversight and regulation, increased labor costs due to improved working conditions, improved safety requirements reducing productivity, increased shipping and manufacturing time for increasingly specialized tools and building materials, reduced working hours to cause less impact to traffic and noise, increased sync points to inspect the work and ensure it’s good before moving to the next step, mechanization reducing the number of people that can work at one time because the equipment is large and expensive, increased project complexity because complex materials and construction practices are more efficient in specific ways, etc.
- stretchwithme 5y agoBut it could be tofu-dreg construction and be more likely to fall over.
- jonobird1 5y agoThat's his entire point
- wazoox 5y agoExactly that. In France the new EPR nuclear reactor has been 15 years in the making and should (hopefully) start in 2023. The Chinese built 2 of these in 9 years. As some engineer from Framatome overseeing the project said, "they achieve in 3 days what Bouygues (the French contractor) does in 3 months".
- ihaveajob 5y agoFor starters, it's no longer politically viable to expect 11 people to die during the construction of a bridge. To avoid that, there's a lot of regulation in place. And a lot more that probably got in for other reasons.
- jljljl 5y agoUsing the actuarial value of a human life, those 11 deaths would add $83M-100M to the costs (assuming the costs aren’t already fully baked in to the cost added above), which would put the Golden Gate Bridge over its budget.
- Swizec 5y agoTo be fair, the Golden Gate Bridge project is famous for its safety record and care given to the safety of its crews during construction. It was one of the first bridges ever built with safety nets during construction. > If there’s one construction job that set the modern standards for work site safety precautions, it is the construction of the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco. When construction on this bridge began in 1933, it was the first suspension bridge supported by a tower in the ocean and surrounded by harsh weather and water conditions. > Before this project bridge construction workers, or “bridgemen,” had been considered reckless daredevils who worked without any safety precautions. They had to be fearless to climb the high steel and deal with the rugged weather and risky footing. The Golden Gate Bridge was built during the Great Depression – when 1 in 4 Americans was unemployed – and despite the risks, workers applied in droves. > /../ > Even with these precautions, 11 men died during construction – including 10 who lost their lives when a section of scaffold fell through the safety net. However, there were 28 worker fatalities during the construction of the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge. Strauss’ safety regulations can be reasonably credited with saving many lives and setting a new worksite safety standard. He proved to the world that safety gear saves lives. https://www.fixfastusa.com/news-blog/golden-gate-bridge-changed-safety-standards/ https://www.fixfastusa.com/news-blog/golden-gate-bridge-chan...
- greggman3 5y agoI'm pretty confident Japan gets shit done 5-10x faster than SF/LA/USA and people don't die building it.
- ynniv 5y agoThings get done quickly when people care about getting them done quickly. As far as I can tell, it's as simple as that.
- strikelaserclaw 5y agowonder how much the land itself costs in that 100k per meter estimation.
- xixixao 5y agoIt’s an “upgrade” of an existing street, don’t think any land had to be purchased.
- Enginerrrd 5y agoOnly if there's space within the existing easement. Without knowing the specifics, it could go either way. It might involve an additional lane for the bus lane and thus involve a widening.
- gcheong 5y agoGetting the bridge built was also a highly visible and thus naturally a higher priority project for the implementers than either a new bus lane or suicide nets. Probably a better comparison would be the building of the signature span of the Bay Bridge.
- brenns10 5y agoRegarding the Van Ness "bus lane"... the site's blurb fails to mention that the project also replaced infrastructure like plumbing which was around hundred years old, requiring digging up a lot of the street and contributing a ton to the cost and time. I'm pretty confident that still doesn't justify all the delays or huge cost overruns. SF is not well known for completing anything in time or on budget. But it's frustrating and inaccurate to see "San Francisco's expensive bus lane" becoming a talking point while omitting the costly and necessary infrastructure upgrades included in that cost. The omission feels designed to malign projects that improve public transit. (And probably also to fit into talking points about "liberal San Francisco"). [Edit: I mean in general, not necessarily assuming ill will on the part of this particular site/author.]
- xixixao 5y agoThe Central Subway is 2.5km long tram line that SF has been building for 12 years now, at a cost of $1.6B. Prague built 35km of tram lines in 14 years after 1893 and another 45km during the next 20 years. (Different era and tech, but still it was building tram lines through existing streets)