8 ms·
Maybe I'm showing my old age, but I never thought of Wi-Fi networking or mobile voice as anything other than "toy" technologies, unsuitable for SeriousBusiness™
by ryandrake 5y ago
Maybe I'm showing my old age, but I never thought of Wi-Fi networking or mobile voice as anything other than "toy" technologies, unsuitable for SeriousBusiness™. Wi-Fi is what you use very temporarily at a coffee shop or something when you simply have to log in to deal with an emergency while on the go. But, for serious daily driver usage, it's wired all the way. First thing I did when I moved into my home was crawl under the crawlspace and run two CAT 6 drops to each room.
If I were to be hired by a company and went into their office the first day, and they said, "so the corporate Wi-Fi SSID is..." well, I'd kind of not take them really seriously as a business. I realize with today's much better Wi-Fi and cellular technologies, that this is an emotional response and there's no rational facts behind the way I feel. Just an artifact of growing up with "wired = reliable".
- carlio 5y agoI'm not sure "I refuse to adapt or change" is a desirable trait in a new employee anyway so probably the relationship would be mutually suspicious.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoTo me "I refuse to adapt or change" is one of the most undesirable traits for an employer when some type of innovation needs to be accomplished then deployed.
- turtlebits 5y agoCompanies with a large enough IT deparment will have enterprise APs all over the office with certificate authentication. IME, ever since 802.11ac (~2014), wifi has been fast enough to not need to be wired in.
- dijit 5y agoHonestly this reads as painfully naive. Maybe you’ve never worked with radio communications before in which case I definitely give you the benefit of the doubt for not knowing this: But wifi (just like other radio tech like 4G) has limited capacity, and that capacity is shared across all radio systems- this sounds obvious but when you realise how few devices can be talking simultaneously you will understand what an absolute pain this is. Most of the huge gains in wifi technology (and 3g-4g) is not just making assumptions about what a signal is based on the leading and trailing edge of the wave of the transmission: mostly it’s about collision detection algorithms. Collision detection, by necessity, adds undeterminable latency to your connection, it’s literally how it works. So taking calls over wifi in a room full of people using wifi: you’re going to have a bad time. Worse: that room full of people is not _just_ that room full of people. Wifi works in 3 dimensions, you’ll be competing with your upstairs and downstairs neighbours too.
- wildrhythms 5y agoAnd yet countless massive office buildings across NYC and every city seem to allow dozens of people to work from a conference room without issue simultaneously over the air every day... must be magic.
- serf 5y ago>without issue >...must be magic. i'd believe the second line if the first one were true, but fact is that although your experience may be very good, people have issues with WiFi constantly -- and more importantly; a lot of people are having issues without even realizing it. An AP that hits 40% of it's projected performance metrics isn't down, but to say it is issue-free is malarkey. Air-congestion is very real, and it affects all of us. Average latency is more chaotic now than it ever has been -- even if the low numbers are very low. Is WiFi effective? Absolutely. I have no illusions that an office worker filling out spread-sheets is going to be totally hindered by a bit less predictable latency numbers -- I just think that it paints an incomplete picture by not realizing that we ARE losing something for the convenience of network-over-the-air. And just to throw an anecdote out there , i'm often one of those conference room workers in one of the massive office buildings when contracted , and with a brand new XPS I still see all the same old issues with congested WiFi nearly everywhere I go. "Convention Wifi" is such a meme that most people expect it to fail 1st or 2nd day of any specific Con. It's not all that uncommon for me to encounter corporate groups that have specific APs for video conference that aren't allowed for general-employee use; the fact that this trend sprung up in the first place presumably indicates that not everyone is getting the performance they need from the arrangement.
- emteycz 5y agoI worked in a purely wifi-based office of hundreds of people. Seamless roaming, speeds in hundreds of Mb/s, low ping - while everyone restored their NPM deps, Docker image layers and had video conferences all the time. Don't know what you're talking about. IME wifi problems are purely administrator capability issue. And I've never seen anyone have a problem with mobile network due to wifi...
- 5y ago
- titzer 5y agoMy workstation doesn't have a WiFi adapter, and I'm glad. It's gigabit ethernet plugged straight into the cable modem. I'm happy to keep tinkering away, even watching videos and such on my laptop, but a big black tower with a keyboard is a holy thing that needs a big pipe jacked into the wall, and you can't convince me otherwise :)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- trebligdivad 5y agoYes; you can get it right; lots of places don't, but you can. And it's very good for people constantly shuffling between meeting rooms. That's a real use
- TacticalCoder 5y ago> Companies with a large enough IT deparment will have enterprise APs all over the office with certificate authentication. OK but companies with a large enough IT department shall also have shitloads of employees / contractors using desktops plugged into ethernet all over the place. They're not mutually exclusive.
- acranox 5y agoThe bandwidth is good enough, but it’s the latency that gets me.
- lizknope 5y agoThe last 3 companies I have worked at over the last 10 years all have wired connections in every office / cubicle as well as 3 separate WiFi networks. Wifi 1 is for if you disconnect your laptop from ethernet then it automatically connects to the internal corporate WiFi network. This is great if you go to a conference room and need to access to your remote desktop session in the compute cluster. Wifi 2 is for employees personal devices like mobile phones and is outside of the corporate network with no access to confidential data Wifi 3 is for guests and vendors who need network access for a demonstration etc.
- joshgachnang 5y agoWhat's the difference between 2 and 3?
- tomrod 5y ago3 typically requires no password, in the setups like this I've seen. So, bring the VPN. I have no proof, but given the actions of one employer I believe 2 was for indirectly monitoring what people were doing on their personal devices.
- ip26 5y agoOr 2 could be a "carrot" to prevent people from connecting their personal devices to 1.
- cricalix 5y agoIf you implement client machine certs, then only corporate imaged machines can connect to 1 in the first place - wired or wireless. 2 and 3 are a bit same-y from my perspective, but the selling point might be “you get a bigger share of the office pipe than the totally open guest network, and fewer restrictions” for 2.
- lizknope 5y agoWifi 1 is only allowed for corporate issued laptops. We don't even know what the password is. Wifi 2 for employee personal devices has the password on an internal website and it changes once a month Wifi 3 changes passwords every 24 hours. It is only for vendors who need internet access to do a demo of their product. When we meet the vendor in a conference room we have to get the password off another web site and then they also get a wifi login screen where they have to list their company name and reason for visit etc.
- cryptoz 5y agoWhat a take. So from your perspective, the developing world that has largely skipped wired connections for their connectivity is all doing 'toy' stuff, not real work? There are literally billions of people with Wifi/Cell but no wired connection, you're just going to write them off as never having what it takes to do SeriousBusiness (tm)? That you're privileged enough to consider, even emotionally, the majority of the world's connections as 'toys' is something you should recognize. Way more SeriousBusiness happens on Wifi/Cell than I think you expect, and writing off that large (and growing) group is honestly ridiculous. On the other end of the spectrum, Steve Jobs, and Elon Musk, etc, did/do so much of their work on Wifi/Cell only that it seems insane to think that they are just doing 'toy' stuff as well. I was on a plane about 10 years ago working on a global network of barometers for weather forecasting research using phones as sensors, and the flight attendant told me rudely to 'put away my toys now'. I've been upset at this ever since, so I'm sorry if this comes off as rude too, but honestly, wtf. I'm working on real stuff, nothing to do with 'toys', as are so many people. Belittling the Wifi/Cell revolution is a mistake IMO.
- kevinventullo 5y agoEmployees at Facebook and Google use Wi-Fi for their daily work. Maybe there’s a way to run an Ethernet cable to one’s desk, but e.g. my MacBook doesn’t even have an Ethernet port. Say what you will about ad tech, I think there’s no denying these are “serious” tech companies.
- travisjungroth 5y agoI’ll let my employer know they’re not a serious business. -written from my wifi connected laptop at Netflix
- catmanjan 5y agoI think a lot of people don't consider FAANG serious business, profitable yes, but you aren't putting food on tables (other than the shareholders)
- after_care 5y agoI don't know anyone that isn't taking Amazon or Apple seriously now. Lots of people don't take Meta or Alphabet seriously, but still buy or click online advertisements.
- catmanjan 5y agoI'd say Amazon is the most "serious" of them, but only the import/export side of the business. Apple basically just sells boutique whitegoods. If any of these companies ceased to exist, it wouldn't inconvenience anyone other the shareholders.
- rayiner 5y agoI have a friend who is an experienced senior paralegal. (Experienced paralegals are sought after because the best ones often leave the job quickly to go to law school.) She started work at a new boutique law firm founded by prominent litigators. She was to head up the paralegal department within the firm. She quit days later. Key to her decision, she told me, was the fact that their IT plan apparently involved using the building WiFi instead of setting up an internal wired network. She figured that this was such a red flag regarding the firm’s administrative competency that she was going to have a rough time.
- gerdesj 5y agoThere's nothing wrong with wifi per se. It is simply another type of medium - instead of a wire, you use electromagnetic waves to transmit the signal. That's how your mobile phone works and so does your radio and TV (if you have them and don't just use Netflix - you know what I mean here). There are long established standards such as 802.1X which involves mutual TLS encryption for wifi. This is generally called "Enterprise WPA" or something like that. This means that all wifi traffic is encrypted to what I would call: a decent standard. I hope your friend did a proper analysis of the wifi offering and didn't simply discount it out of hand because it is wifi. There are a lot of issues here and the wifi vs wired thing is bloody complicated but make sure you understand all of the issues before pontificating about one vs the other ... 8) (edit: 51 year old commentard here)
- tedunangst 5y agoNothing wrong with two cans and a line of string, either.
- ryandrake 5y agoI think the person in GP's story objected to the fact that the network connection she was told to use was not even limited internally to that law firm, but was astonishingly just whatever semi-private "building wifi" network happened to exist in the (presumably shared) building. If I were a lawyer and cared about client confidentiality, that would at least give me pause, regardless of whether the physical network was wired or wireless.
- gerdesj 5y agoI think you are both right and wrong! You are old enough (I assume) to remember really dodgy wifi but it has moved on and APs from nearly all vendors are really rather good. ISPs in the UK (I can't comment elsewhere obviously) have generally woken up to delivering really quite decent "hubs" instead of a shonky Thompson Rainbow type device. That said, even those have some mileage with a firmware change. It's all about tools for the job. You know as well as I do what drywall/plasterboard does to wifi or what a skin of bricks does to wifi propagation, compared to generally wooden construction. Yes, running a CATn cable will nearly always trump a wifi connection but it's fixed. I personally stick to CAT5e at home instead of 6 but I won't rule it out in future. 5e -> 1Gb/s over 100m. 6 ... which one? 6 is nominally 10Gb/s and 6A is 40 I think. 6A needs the shielding to be earthed properly. I run most things over wifi if I can. My servers have fixed ethernet and things like my doorbell obviously get a PoE CAT5e connection. ... ... ... obviously!
- Dyac 5y ago"drywall/plasterboard", "skin of bricks"... I wish! Here I am with 12" thick stone walls and wifi can barely make it from the next room. I'm so glad the previous owner ran a little bit of ethernet cable!
- R0b0t1 5y agoA real enterprise WiFi rollout might provision 1 access point for 1-4 people to keep access speeds high, depending on cube or office layout. WiFi shouldn't be expected to penetrate walls well. If you take normal WiFi hardware and try to go with normal household usage patterns it doesn't work great.
- paxys 5y agoI'd wager employees at the majority of tech companies today (including those at the scale of Google and Facebook) use Wi-Fi by default for all day-to-day operations. Whether they are "serious" businesses or not is for you to decide.
- peckrob 5y agoI'm kinda with you, though I am more willing to use wifi as an alternative when wiring is impossible or impractical. The line I use in the house is, "if it's staying in one place and can be wired, it should be." My iMac is wired, all the AppleTVs are (now) wired, Linux servers are wired, etc. Weirdly, until the 4K launched, on the AppleTV 4's was actually faster to use wifi (they only had a 10/100 Ethernet port, but support 802.11ac.) To be fair, Wifi has gotten a lot better than the bad ol' 802.11b and WEP days. My Unifi access points are fairly solid (even if the company behind them is acting less so recently) and I very rarely have any wifi problems that aren't specific to a device. Like printers. I constantly fight with printers falling off the wifi. But I just prefer to be wired if possible.
- k33l0r 5y agoI was pretty surprised to learn that my 2021 OLED TV only has a 10/100 ethernet port. Apparently previous models had USB 3.0 ports so you could workaround it by adding a USB gigabit ethernet adapter but in newer models they've reverted back to USB 2.0 ports, for whatever reason.
- mjevans 5y agoThe same reason they didn't shove in a 1000mbit Ethernet port; it saved them 2 cents a TV across 10 million TVs.
- ridgered4 5y agoIt really bothers me my Brother laser printer only has wifi as a network connection.
- fuzzfactor 5y agoMost likely there is an almost identical model having an RJ-45 along with wifi or in place of it, in addition to USB.
- jacobsenscott 5y agoI crawled around my attic and basement and ran cat 6 to a few rooms. I never use it. I've been working from home for years, all on wifi. Never had an issue with it. Wires are just ugly dust collectors and things to trip over.
- ghaff 5y agoBecause of various renovations in my house, I always had Cat 5 (and speaker wire) run when walls were open. I do used wired connections when convenient but I don’t generally see any difference.
- icedchai 5y agoLike most things, it depends... and you get what you pay for. If you have an enterprise grade or "prosumer" level access point (Ubiquiti, for example), wifi is solid. If you're using a garbage router/wifi combo, like the ones provided by most ISPs, you're definitely going to have issues.
- eek2121 5y agoYou need to get out more. :) Early on in my career, I made a living designing network solutions for companies. Warehouses and retail stores in particular needed large, highly available Wi-Fi networks. Some providers tried to build proprietary protocols/networks, but ultimately, they failed. These days, I'd question working for, or doing work for a company WITHOUT Wi-Fi. I am probably your age or older. I've interfaced with COBOL systems, for example...
- BeefWellington 5y agoHaving Wi-Fi and making it the primary method of accessing a network from your cubicle are two different things.
- bschwindHN 5y agoIf I want to go "really fast" I use ethernet, but otherwise wi-fi has been more than enough for me in the places I use here. Here's a speed test I just ran, on my home wi-fi: https://imgur.com/orc2hkD.png https://imgur.com/orc2hkD.png Ethernet adds on a few hundred extra Mbps but I usually don't need that unless I'm downloading something huge.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI don't think my feelings about it are as extreme as yours, but I agree otherwise. Using WiFi as a primary connection is just asking for a lot of extra crap to troubleshoot for no good reason at best, and giving people unreliable and slow connections at worst. WiFi in your business is for smart phones/tablets and guests.