2 ms·
People get very emotional about this. So, maybe instead of it being “signal” it was instead: “closed chat app”. I have an issue with closed chat app. My issue
by dijit 5y ago
People get very emotional about this. So, maybe instead of it being “signal” it was instead: “closed chat app”.
I have an issue with closed chat app. My issue is that it’s closed, but often pretends to be secure.
I can’t be sure it is secure, because they pay lip service to open source, they also integrate another Foreign (to me) companies binary SDK which is also not open source.
They’re also a closed system, meaning that they have direct network effects and have been hostile to third party implementations of clients.
The protocol is documented (somewhat homegrown, more like an evolution of something existing), and the server is “open”, but it’s not possible to actually use these things.
The politics of the founder are sometimes in question. They’re also foreign to me and have had brushes with their nations law enforcement. Whether I can trust them shouldn’t be my concern- if the service were open it would not be.
So, I personally don’t believe in it.
I would _rather_ have a small collection of TLS irc servers or zulip servers, because lots of small targets is better than a big centralised one; Better than that is matrix which is properly federated.
Tell me though, was I talking about signal, whatsapp or telegram?
They all suffer the same problems and people like to bicker about their personal favourite; forgetting that you shouldn’t be throwing in to this kind closed ecosystem with its stupid network effects.