I didn't say the original app had all the "EXACT" same functionality as what is in the iPhone 4S. It has a lot of the same basic functionality that I have used

I didn't say the original app had all the "EXACT" same functionality as what is in the iPhone 4S. It has a lot of the same basic functionality that I have used and would continue to use on my 3GS, except that I can't because Apple turning it off on all iPhone models except for the new 4S. (It already appears to be offline for me.) I don't disagree that the new implementation looks to be far more polished, tightly integrated, and probably just plain better than what I had. What I object to, is them taking it away and forcing an upgrade of hardware if I still want to use the same features I already have been. The "SAME," "EXACT" semantics are yours, not mine. I don't think I implied that either. They took an existing app away and the features are now only available on brand new hardware. That is a business and marketing decision, not a limitation of existing hardware.