4 ms·
I expected some crazy new attack vector that was so sophisticated it could fool this Scam Prevention Expert, but this post is laughable. They fell for textbook
by paxys 5y ago
I expected some crazy new attack vector that was so sophisticated it could fool this Scam Prevention Expert, but this post is laughable. They fell for textbook "scamming 101" that my grandma knows to avoid.
Here's one tip for this expert – if you get a 2FA code over text or email that clearly has the line "we will never contact you for this code over phone or text" right under it, DON'T give it to a "support agent" over the phone.
> this is clearly a two-factor authentication code, meant to be entered directly into an authentication page. Which is normally not something that would be relayed over a phone call to a customer service rep. A concern that I raised to Daniel. However, he said that it was part of Apple's system, which they only had limited access to. An explanation that, as someone who works with computers, data security, and API integration professionally, I completely bought
And after reading multiple paragraphs of this person describing money literally taken out of their account in front of their eyes, you get to this line:
> Putting all of this together, the scales started to tip toward this potentially being a scam call, but I still wasn't certain
I really hope they don't have a lot of clients
- feoren 5y agoI agree. I nodded along to the part about not assuming it's the victim's fault, and then this "expert" falls for an extremely basic, obvious attack. "Wells Fargo will not contact you by phone or text to request this code." -- maybe that should have been bigger and bolder, but it was there. This guy should not be allowed to call himself a "scam prevention expert" anymore.
- mort96 5y agoThere's a lot of text in that e-mail. The text you're referring to is perfectly positioned to be almost invisible -- it's in the last paragraph intermingled with the standard "if you have any questions, call us on blah blah blah" text. My brain skipped the rest of that paragraph the first 5 times I skimmed the e-mail.
- mdavis6890 5y agoDoes a "scam prevention expert" really need to read that fine print to know not to provide a one-time code to an inbound caller?
- woojoo666 5y agoThe author mentioned that (1) they have had many poor experiences with Wells Fargo and (2) they don't have much experience with Apple but the experiences they have had weren't positive. I personally have had to deal with my fair share of janky and badly designed support systems (especially in health and banking), sometimes they are worse than startups. So it's not outside the realm of possibility that giving the support rep the auth code was simply the best solution they could find given whatever poor and legacy systems they had in their backend.
- mort96 5y agoListen, I responded to a particular part of my parent comment. Whether the author's given explanation for why she in the moment read the code over the phone is reasonable or if it proves that she's a fundamentally terrible scam prevention expert is a much bigger topic which my comment didn't touch on.
- gridspy 5y agoAnyone can fall for these attacks in the moment, even experts. That was the point of the article. What makes us vulnerable is that we are human: we get tired, caught up in the urgency of the call and our logical thinking stops working. The actual story of the article is that we need to design systems that are robust even when people are getting scammed. Able to identify and reverse scamming soon after it happens with easy ways to report it.
- unixbane 5y agoThere are no experts in information security. It's just random people with in depth knowledge of some tiny subsystem they happened to feel like studying. They are literally all LARPers who will fall for every single thing aside from whatever class of vulns they specialized in. There is no way to use modern systems securely. Absolutely none. Even with 20 years of study you will still find new ways they are broken and where security forgot to be implemented. All of this is a consequence of the industry being controlled by what is essentially a 5 year old: monetary incentives. > Able to identify and reverse scamming soon after it happens with easy ways to report it. Just make a site with a username / password where the user gets locked out forever if he forgets it. Do banking transactions by singing them with your public key, via a phone app. This is what I was complaining about not being able to do before smart phones became a thing. This is literally better than the tripe the 'experts' come up with. All these roundabout shit ways of authenticating people just add new ways of getting phished, exploited, etc.
- fallingknife 5y agoAmazing that a security "professional" would wait until he is 100% sure it's a scam and not hang up when he isn't 100% sure it's legit.
- solidasparagus 5y agoThis feels like an unreasonably nasty and condescending response to an article about how anyone can make mistakes in the moment. I thought it was a pretty good article about how easy it is to sit at your computer and look down at people who fall for scams, but that scams are effective precisely because they take advantage of mistakes and the fallibility of people - even knowledgable ones. I feel like this comment misses the core thesis of the article - that condescension and expectations of human perfection are not effective ways to prevent social engineering attacks and that building systems that anticipate human error is a better approach.
- oehpr 5y agoeven worse is spreading this attitude is something that only aids a scammer. Fear and shame at reputational harm prevent victims from alerting authorities, about alerting their friends. About getting help. Worse than being wrong. Worse than just being a jerk. This poster is being actively harmful.
- xeromal 5y agoYeah, I felt like I was taking crazy pills seeing comments agreeing with this nasty comment. Thanks for counteracting it.
- hedora 5y ago> if you get a 2FA code over text or email that clearly has the line "we will never contact you for this code over phone or text" I needed a cashier's check recently at $GIANT_US_BANK. The teller initiated a 2FA handshake. The text said something like "never give this number to anyone, none of our representatives will ever ask you for it". I figured scammers probably hadn't set up an entire bogus branch with yelp reviews going back years. I handed it over. The check they issued cleared, from what I can tell. If you think that's bad, try applying for a mortgage. It's 100% remote these days, with a mix of multiple communication channels, all bootstrapped with incoming phone calls, emails (and, if you're me, phone numbers from government licensing databases, followed by awkward call backs)