4 ms·
I dunno, I've met a lot of profs who take the attitude "if you want your name on crap, be my guest" when it comes to reviewing papers. They might check for glar
by erdos4d 5y ago
I dunno, I've met a lot of profs who take the attitude "if you want your name on crap, be my guest" when it comes to reviewing papers. They might check for glaring errors, but rarely does anyone work through the results for correctness.
- bachmeier 5y agoI agree but that's a sign we need more peer review. IMO it's unethical to engage in fake peer review like that. I recently encountered the opposite - a reviewer that wrote a fake negative review of my paper without reading it. Killed the paper at a good journal by making claims that are easily verified to be false.
- nicce 5y agoSo we need a peer review for peer-reviewed reviews.