3 ms·
I get the appeal of classic texts like the Dover math series -- I've got plenty of them on my own bookshelf. But the reality of most fields of study is that a 6
by pmags 5y ago
I get the appeal of classic texts like the Dover math series -- I've got plenty of them on my own bookshelf. But the reality of most fields of study is that a 60+ year old textbook just doesn't cut it in terms of topics covered, advances in the field, or modern pedagogical practice.
As a unversity professor myself, I am always seeking out open publishing or less expensive options for my students. The sad reality is that while there are some nice "open publishing" textbooks available, and I try and use these for my own classes whenever appropriate, very few such efforts can match the quality of a professionally edited textbook in terms of breadth of topics covered, quality of illustrations and figures, referencing to the recent literature, etc.
I wish it was otherwise, but that's currently the state of affairs in the sub-fields my work touches on (genetics, genomics, computational biology). For senior students and grad students I can usually draw on the primary literature rather than a textbook per se, but that's rough going for most students in their first few years of university.
- bell-cot 5y agoFor seniors & grad students, in a fair number of subjects, sadly yes. But for lower-level students, or in many other subjects - things like up-to-date references to the literature are not so important in (say) a senior-level abstract algebra text. Or they can go on a simple "Other Resources for this Course" web page that the Dept. maintains. (Point of amusement - one of my own grad school math texts, first published in 1966, is currently "List price: $175" on Amazon. Admittedly, I studied from a later edition of Rudin. But I suspect it didn't change all that much.)
- formerkrogeremp 5y agoI had a professor similar to you in college, and he was a real life saver for working with us on reducing textbook costs. I really appreciated his and your efforts to provide quality, affordable books and learning materials.