3 ms·
We're about to find out! The scientific community has done itself a huge disservice in recent years in two ways: 1) Refusing to police non-rigorous fields invo
by rayiner 5y ago
We're about to find out! The scientific community has done itself a huge disservice in recent years in two ways:
1) Refusing to police non-rigorous fields invoking scientific authority. As the article notes, even rigorous fields are full of results that cannot be reproduced. The situation is even worse in non-rigorous fields. In his famous essay on cargo-cult science, Richard Feynman specifically called out "educational and psychological studies" as "examples of what I would like to call Cargo Cult Science." https://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm https://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm. Yet today, there is a movement to accord any PhD the respect of the title "doctor," as if an EdD was an authority similar to a PhD in physics. People do this to be polite but it has grave consequences.
The respect people accord "science" is, at the end of the day, built on results. We trust doctors because they delivered concrete results that medicine men could not. In the long run, people will notice that EdD is often wrong, because it's not a rigorous field, and that will tarnish the credibility of everyone with a PhD, because the lay public quite reasonably doesn't understand these distinctions in rigor.
2) Allowing scientific authority to be invoked for political purposes. There is a difference between scientific results, and the value systems of individual scientists. Science can, for example, create a vaccine. It cannot address the political question of whether anyone should get the vaccine--that question relies on cost/benefit analysis that, in turn, depends on individual value systems. Or in another example, science can tell you the probability of spreading a disease in a grocery store versus a church, but cannot tell you whether grocery stores or churches are more important. Moreover, most people intuitively understand this distinction. There are, of course, some people who will ignore scientific facts that are as plain as day. But there are a lot more people who will chafe at feeling like they are being told "I'm smarter than you, so you have to accept my values." That, in the long run, will undermine their trust in scientific results.
And if we, as highly educated people who understand "science" are honest with ourselves, that skepticism may not be unwarranted. We know that biases exist in the system. For example, it is well known that publication bias exists: studies reporting positive results get published, while studies reporting negative results don't get published: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3341407/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3341407/. As science becomes more politicized, it's inevitable that other kinds of publication bias will affect not only the reported results, but even the kinds of questions that are studied.
- tptacek 5y agoYet today, there is a movement to accord any PhD the respect of the title "doctor," as if an EdD was an authority similar to a PhD in physics. People do this to be polite but it has grave consequences. No. We shouldn't be putting so much weight on the title of "doctor" for physics PhD's either; several physics PhD's I know personally are absolutely barking mad, and there's a long history of physics PhD's getting over their skis on other fields like medicine. Meanwhile, the usage of "doctor" that you're decrying here is the more historically well-established one.