3 ms·
Ah, but rationing based on mutable characteristics, like how much money and access to professional opportunities that your parents were born with, and whether o
by vkou 5y ago
Ah, but rationing based on mutable characteristics, like how much money and access to professional opportunities that your parents were born with, and whether or not you grew up in a broken home[1], or whether you grew up in a redlined apartment with lead dust peeling off the walls is fine?
[1] Because dad's in prison for a crime that the right kind of people get community service for. And he wasn't the right kind of person.
- FFRefresh 5y agoI'm sensing a theme here in creating strawmen. My advice to you would be attempt to steelman opposing views. Attempt to find synthesis between your initial notions and the best parts of the opposing views. To answer you question at a high-level: Rationing based on things people have ZERO control over seems worse to me than rationing based on things people have SOME (even if a little) control over. And there of course will be a litany of hypothetical/real scenarios that we could drum up for each rationing strategy that shows people losing out (it's rationing, no matter what some people will not end up with access!). And highlighting one side of the costs doesn't immediately mean that the other side isn't more ethical.