3 ms·
I'm aware of Stallman's advocacy on free software issues, but (completely honest question), what else does the Free Software Foundation do ? Software is at a p
by josephg 15y ago
I'm aware of Stallman's advocacy on free software issues, but (completely honest question), what else does the Free Software Foundation do ?
Software is at a point where its basically impossible to make anything useful without opensource software. Proprietary code is a minority in my stack both as a developer and as a user. Proprietary software is often good before opensource software is good, but consistently opensource implementations eventually outpace their proprietary counterparts. We saw this trend first with UNIX -> Linux. Today, just reading this webpage I'm using Chrome (Chromium + WebKit) which communicates via POSIX to the BSD network stack in my kernel (Darwin). The browser has been compiled with either GCC or LLVM. Hackernews is probably hosted on nginx / apache behind varnish or something, running on linux.
In short, I feel like the opensource movement has already won. Aside from RMS's crusade against software patents, how is the FSF still relevant?
- tlrobinson 15y agoThey've won that battle, but not the war. Servers, databases, frameworks, languages, etc are often open source, but the majority of applications are not.
- drzaiusapelord 15y agoThat's the problem, you're the problem if you refuse to accept that the best solution is going to be the freedom for people to sell commercial closed software as well as use open software. The idea that this is a war is exactly why RMS is wrong. The idea that we must win it and we must make everyone use the new hot open license is wrong. The idea should be to encourage people to use open licenses, and to promote the good of open licenses, not declare war on everything and become some bitter asshole neckbeard when you see guys like Jobs doing well with a slightly different approach. The FSF doesn't do much. They're little more than negative campaigners "Windows 7 Sins" etc. I'm not sure what its purpose or real world effect is other than to scare middle management from FOSS as much as possible. Stick vs Carrot. FSF is all stick and people have noticed.
- Produce 15y ago>That's the problem, you're the problem if you refuse to accept that the best solution is going to be the freedom for people to sell commercial closed software as well as use open software. That's a debatable point since a sizable portion of the world's population does not think that capitalism is a good system. It's mind boggling that the task of convincing people to work together and share even exists, considering how social humans are. >They're little more than negative campaigners "Windows 7 Sins" etc. Here you have groups of people working towards the primary goal of taking money from you and the secondary goal of locking you into their brand so that you must continue to pay them and yet you vehemently defend them. These people are not your friends in a very active and direct way! Would we have solved other social issues such as equal rights without a stick or did they improve precisely because the powers that be begun to feel threatened? Are you aware of the fact that your local government is an organization which has a monopoly on sticks (which it is very ready to use against you)? Why do you not speak out about that if you are principally against sticks? Surely (I can't stop calling you that) those sticks hit a little closer to home? Incidentally, the very companies you are defending use their sticks the most. Besides, since when did it become so politically incorrect to point out unethical behavior?
- kragen 15y ago> the best solution is going to be the freedom for people to sell commercial closed software as well as use open software. The "freedom" you're describing involves government-granted monopolies enforced by pervasive surveillance, unannounced office raids to audit licenses, serial numbers to ensure trackability of all CD-R media, and prosecution of people for disabling malicious software running on their own computers. Certainly it's a kind of freedom; but can't we do better? Stallman had a slightly different viewpoint about that "freedom": The "freedom to choose a license" which denies others essential freedoms is not really a freedom. It is a form of power, of domination over others. Your description makes it sound like a matter of individual freedom by obscuring the presence of the others in the situation. The GPL is designed to protect the essential freedoms for everyone, by denying anyone the power to take them away. (He wrote that in 1999, but I imagine he still feels the same way.)
- whatusername 15y agoWin 2K8, Oracle, MS-SQL, DB2, .NET, WebLogic, WebSphere, C#, etc would all slightly disagree with you.
- derleth 15y ago> Aside from RMS's crusade against software patents, how is the FSF still relevant? "Well, we just beat the tuberculosis into remission, so now all we have to deal with is this metastasising cancer." Frankly, software patents have the potential to be a lot scarier than copyright ever could be. Anyone working to end them is doing good work.
- genieyclo 15y agortm would never run HN on Linux :-) If they haven't upgraded, FreeBSD 7.1 (not sure on the particulars of RELEASE version). news.arc does not need Apache or NGiNX, but I'm not sure whether HN uses varnish cache.
- kragen 15y ago> I feel like the opensource movement has already won. We have a really long way to go, still. The most popular computer platforms in the world are iOS and Android, and their users don't have the practical ability or, in some countries, the legal right to modify the software on them. Many people communicate with their friends and colleagues through Facebook and Gmail — proprietary software applications that send copies of their most private data to advertising-funded companies in foreign countries. (Unless they live in the US.) Their right to continue communicating with their friends through these media is subject to arbitrary revocation at any moment. Every day, I run into web sites that don't work unless I install Flash. And my friend David tells me his startup has just received a patent lawsuit from Lodsys. I understand that you're happy with this situation (except the patent part), but I'm not. I want to live in a world where people's communication with their friends, family, and colleagues, and the public, is subject to approval from nobody except the communicating parties. I want to live in a world where Apple can't surreptitiously log everywhere I go on my own phone, and where I'm not committing a crime if I reprogram the phone to stop anyone who is. I want to live in a world where I can buy any random piece of hardware at the computer store and plug it in with happy anticipation that it will work with Linux, not dread that I'll have to search all over the web for half-assed reverse-engineered drivers. I want to never read another fucking EULA, and to never again have to click through without reading it and wonder what rights I've just signed away. We've come a long way, but we still have a long way to go.
- cwp 15y agoBe careful about conflating the Free Software Foundation with the Open Source Initiative. Free software is about distributing source code for moral reasons, while open source is about distributing source code for utilitarian reasons. I think you're right; if open source hasn't won, it's doing pretty well. But as far as the FSF is concerned that's doing the right thing for the wrong reasons. The FSF isn't going to declare victory until they bring everybody around to their moral point of view.
- rimantas 15y ago> In short, I feel like the opensource movement has already > won. Aside from RMS's crusade against software patents, > how is the FSF still relevant? It's not. Many won't agree, but time will show (or have it already?). Stallman's ideas were born at the time when absolute majority of computer users were also IT guys — and in that context they do make sense. However nowadays computers are just mere tools/entertainment machines for the most of the users. The only concern they have is "does it work", not "can I modify the program". For some reason there are people who cannot accept this shift and get more and more out of touch with reality each day.
- DanBC 15y agoI think you're under-estimating RMS's extremism about 'freeness'. RMS would say that you booted your machine with an evil closed EFI / BIOS; that there's a bunch of evil non-free drivers; that there's a bunch of evil non-free gui stuff, etc etc. Chrome was not, to RMS, a valid solution. Note his approach to "browsing the www" - (http://lwn.net/Articles/262570/ http://lwn.net/Articles/262570/) >To look at page I send mail to a demon which runs wget and mails the page back to me. RMS would say that there is still plenty of work to do to work toward 'free' software. (Mobile phones is something he's keen to open up.)