13 ms·
I think a lot of ideas about academic legitimacy are neither based on a deep understanding of the replication crisis, nor are they emotional. The fact is, a lot
by mike_hearn 5y ago
I think a lot of ideas about academic legitimacy are neither based on a deep understanding of the replication crisis, nor are they emotional. The fact is, a lot of bad claims coming out of academia don't require any particular expertise to spot. Did you need to be an expert psychologist to realize that Power Posing probably wasn't right?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-41521671/100-women-amy-cuddy-on-how-posture-can-boost-your-confidence http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-41521671/100-women-amy-cu...
Very doubtful. You just need common sense. Like, if this actually worked then you'd be seeing it spread very fast everywhere, but in reality it apparently needs a constant flow of TED Talks to get people to take it seriously. Ditto for priming studies, etc.
More recently there's been COVID. The problems here aren't exactly the same as the replication crisis, partly because nobody seems to try and replicate anything in the first place. Really IMHO the problems are much worse. Nothing could possibly destroy confidence in academic and public sector expertise faster than being told masks don't work, followed by they work so well they're now mandatory, followed in turn by seeing case graphs where switching mandates on/off very clearly has no effect whatsoever.
The constant flow of bad models that were never acknowledged is particularly destructive. Most people can't articulate why the models always seemed to be wrong except through vague generalities like "bad assumptions", but it doesn't matter. Epidemiological modelling is toast in the public mind, along with the lockdowns they led to. The understanding that they're unreliable is fact based, not emotional, even if the details aren't there.
At any rate, having done deep dives into too many trash COVID papers in the past two years, I can't say knowing the exact details of why they're wrong makes much difference. The important thing is actually the social problems surrounding them, in particular the lack of any institutional acknowledgement or response that there's an issue. Observe how discussion of the replication crisis started with and still mostly comes from individual researchers, not institutional leaders. We can see there is no psychological acceptance of how badly they've been getting it wrong because, for example, Imperial College London (home of Prof Lockdown himself) just banned parents from attending their children's graduation ceremony due to COVID:
https://dailysceptic.org/2022/03/31/imperial-college-london-bans-parents-from-graduation-ceremonies-just-in-case/ https://dailysceptic.org/2022/03/31/imperial-college-london-...
This is at a time of record high cases and after the Queen got it at 95. Nobody cared, it was in the news for barely a day. ICL comes across as a delusional institution with this sort of act, and combined with all the stories of activist craziness on campus, it's getting widely noticed by the general public.