3 ms·
Is this really an AirPods problem or is it more of a Bluetooth problem? Might have Gustaf said AirPods because, let's be honest, the vast majority of people wi
by ravenstine 5y ago
Is this really an AirPods problem or is it more of a Bluetooth problem?
Might have Gustaf said AirPods because, let's be honest, the vast majority of people with wireless earbuds in our field are using Apple AirPods?
AirPods are by no means perfect, but they're the least problematic out of many Bluetooth earbuds I had tried in the past (granted, I've yet to try the brand that sponsor so many YouTube channels as of late). Bluetooth in general is very problematic and, if you've ever tried working with any version of the Bluetooth stack, you'd have immediately figured out why. Even BLE, which is supposed to be more restrictive, is still complex and hard to understand. And let's say you've got Bluetooth itself figured out, now you've got to make sure you've handled operating system quirks. And yes, there are quirks. If you were developing for Bluetooth on Windows or Linux and decide to do so on macOS, you'll be surprised to find that your code, even when directly translated to Swift or Objective-C, won't just work as-is because macOS has different restrictions for Bluetooth that are hardly documented anywhere. Today, macOS forces you to use a generated UUID to identify a hardware device instead of a MAC address, yet as far as I can tell it's documented nowhere as to how those UUIDs are generated.
But I digress.
Bluetooth just isn't a good tech stack for ultra-reliable audio, especially duplex audio. It's just going to have interruptions and random disconnections and reconnections. The mic quality will almost certainly stink unless the host has a better Bluetooth chipset and the peripheral does some neat tricks that likely result in lag as a tradeoff.
IMO, you don't use AirPods for any sort of audio production, except maybe if you are using them to receive cues. You use a "real" wireless lavalier mic such as the Rode Go Wireless II, which doesn't use Bluetooth at all, sounds great, handles distance and interference really well (important if you are walking around on a stage), and has a built-in audio backup in case there's interference or connection drops.
But no one actually wants to pay for real audio equipment for some reason.
I wish that companies, in particular remote ones, make quality mics and lavalier mics easily available to their employees. Only one company I've worked for provided good headphones, but never has a company provided a microphone.
- minimouse 5y agoFor anyone interested in the duplex/bidirectional audio side of Bluetooth, here's a good read: https://medium.marco.zone/apple-implemented-the-biggest-improvement-to-bluetooth-audio-since-2009-2079abc607af https://medium.marco.zone/apple-implemented-the-biggest-impr...
- artimaeis 5y agoIt's an AirPods problem in that it's a problem that the default mode where it uses automatic device switching is unreliable for some users. Unless you're positing that that unreliability is actually a side-effect of the bluetooth standard, which I don't really know enough about to comment on. Personally I haven't had issues with it despite hopping between iPhone, iPad, and MacBook Air regularly, but if I were taking meetings more regularly I might be tempted to disable the feature.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoIf you use them with Mac, then Apple controls both ends of the Bluetooth stack. Apple developers should be uniquely qualified to know macOS quirks, right?
- dolni 5y agoApple earns tens of billions of dollars per quarter. They don't seem to have any issue coming up with their own standard when it suits them. If Bluetooth is such an issue, there's nothing stopping them from implementing their own protocol for use with their own products. So I will say yes, this is definitely an AirPods problem.
- aeternum 5y agoA few releases ago, AirPods were significantly more reliable than other bluetooth headphones. Now I find that non-Apple bluetooth devices connect faster and stay connected much more reliably than Airpods. Definitely seems like a bug that Apple introduced somewhat recently.
- tshaddox 5y ago> Is this really an AirPods problem or is it more of a Bluetooth problem? I'm guessing it would be exceedingly rare for anyone to bring any non-AirPods Bluetooth headphones to YC demo day.