6 ms·
From the article: > Mobile phone SOCs integrate a substantial amount of function right onto the chip. Why hasn’t that been the case for the car? Because your
by bayindirh 5y ago
From the article:
> Mobile phone SOCs integrate a substantial amount of function right onto the chip. Why hasn’t that been the case for the car?
Because your mobile phone SoC is not certified for -20/+80 degrees Celsius, copious amount of vibration, error-free operation on many environments (incl. inputs with wrong voltages, shorts, etc.), and have a lifetime of 10+ years with the same performance characteristics.
Your car is running a real-time simulation of your engine to keep itself operational, and it's a much serious business than running Android or iOS.
More information: https://media.ccc.de/v/32c3-7331-the_exhaust_emissions_scandal_dieselgate https://media.ccc.de/v/32c3-7331-the_exhaust_emissions_scand...
- turbinerneiter 5y agoHow does functional integration interfere with robustness?
- JRKrause 5y agoOne method of making a chip 'tougher' is to physically increase the size of the semiconductor elements (e.g. transistors, FETs). This would seem incompatible with highly-integrated ICs.
- xyzzy21 5y agoThis is true. For radiation hardening for space, this is exactly what is required for anything more harsh than LEO. And as a consequence, the generation of processors and memory typically used are 10-20 years behind the current state of the art. That's simply the price of reliability in harsh environments!
- bayindirh 5y agoThe discrete components are designed, tested and verified after a long stint and their specs are frozen. It's a bit like space hardware. You verify an older CPU design can work reliably in space, and certify that processor. Then, you use the same foundation for a decade or so. It's same with automotive industry. You have a well defined and certified stack from Delco, Bosch, Delphi, etc. and you can trust that hardware. Integration makes you return back to square one. I remember Toyota tried unifying some control units into a single box, and 5-6 years considered realistic if not a little optimistic.
- pySSK 5y agoTo add to that, some of these features are extremely specialized, and for each feature, 1-2 of the big players might have a huge technical advantage and economies of scale in production and in supplying. This leads to higher barrier to entry and not enough margin for other players to replicate the feature.
- foobarian 5y agoFunny, this sounds exactly like why microservices have an advantage over monoliths in big organizations.
- Isinlor 5y agoSpaceX works around that by using consumer grade stuff and just replicating it 3 times. Tesla also managed to handle issues with supply shortages very well. The old practices are just not good enough.
- hulitu 5y agoTesla is not a car. It looks like one, it might behave a bit like one but i would not touch such a thing even with a 9 m pole. I heard too many horror stories about Tesla requirements.
- bayindirh 5y agoIf it looks like a duck (car), and moves like a duck (car), and quacks like a duck (car), then it's a duck (car) in my book. What other thing should it have? An ICE? Then Nissan Leaf, Ford F150 electric, and BMW i series are not cars either.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> SpaceX works around that by using consumer grade stuff and just replicating it 3 times Falcons get refurbished after short flights. That reduces the emphasis on durability. Redundancy defends against random errors, reducing the need for radiation hardening. It does less against wear and tear.
- pySSK 5y agoThey do however use SoCs for HMI/head-units/carputers now however. The bigger reason is just the nature of automotive development. Every part is developed by a specced or sourced by different teams and outsourced to a different Tier 1/2/3. Things are designed to be modular, so if you pick Option A for something, it might use ECU A, and if you pick Option B, they might pack a whole different ECU B. Also, every ECU is costed down to only support the intended application, so ECU A likely doesn't have the extra bandwidth to add on extra features for Option B. Also, none of this is decided or developed at the same time, so you have all the different features and ECUs developed throughout. Some things are changed mid program. Some things carry over from previous programs, so it's usually just easier to go your own way and not work with other teams on combining features. Every automotive OEM has a person who comes up with the brilliant and cost saving idea of combining ECUs. I know 4 such people from different OEMs but they have all failed for some of the reasons mentioned above.
- nudgeee 5y agoSoCs in head-units would still be automotive qualified variants (temperature grade, etc).
- sandworm101 5y ago>> SoC is not certified for -20/+80 degrees Celsius That is basically the operating range of the average graphics card these days. Not many people go sub-ambient with their cooling but no graphics card would complain if they did. The actual silicon is perfectly fine with such temperatures. The only real issue is the external cooling rig, a classic engineering problem that any car company shouldn't have a problem solving. A water cooler tied to the vehicle's coolant loop would easily cap the upper temperature range at water boiling points. A car engine has plenty of power available for fans or even air conditioning if necessary. Hide the controller chips somewhere in the passenger compartment and the humans will die of heat before the silicon.
- bayindirh 5y agoI’m not talking about processor temperatures. The temperatures I’m talking about are ambient/enclosure temperatures. So, the board, and all integrated components will be at least that ambient temperature, and they’ll work without any transient errors. Also this means, no solder joints or any other component won’t act funky. A transient error in your GPU is a one pixel blip. In an ECU, that’s a power loss event in best case.
- ptsneves 5y agoIn low temperatures you start having issues with moisture saturating the air. Things get wet out of nowhere. There are also electrolytic capacitors which are water based so these need to be ruled out as well. Given air has at any given time a lot of water and water goes through a phase change at sub zero i find the comparison quite invalid.
- sandworm101 5y agoThat's a difference with automotive/aviation products. They will all be in sealed containers and then the actual circuitry will all be covered in plastic. There shouldn't be any exposed metal that could possibly short, even if immersed in water. Pouring buckets of water on a running engine (ie a gap in the hood closure on a rainy day) or even into the passenger compartment (ie sunroof left open) shouldn't do much of anything to a car's electrical systems. (This is also done for fire safety reasons. Any metal that could possibly short if wet could also ignite a fire during/after a crash.)
- hulitu 5y ago-20 ° C - + 80 °C is for keyfobs. For ECUs in the passenger compartment is -40°C - 85 °C and for ECUs in the engine compartment is -40 °C - 105 °C.
- shadowpho 5y agoAlso... mobile phone SoC are made in much higher quantities then car chips: there are much more phones shipped then cars. Therefore R&D costs per unit are significantly lower with phone chips and you can spend more.
- ryanobjc 5y agoWhen you buy semiconductors on digikey or whatever, there are several different 'classes' of performance. Everyone imagines milspec being the top one, and it's true, but for most people the ideal class is 'automotive'... Because precisely of what the parent said: tolerances of temperatures to 140F or more. Think of a car sitting in a baking parking lot in Phoenix, no shade. You don't build semiconductors for that purpose by using 10nm process then adding a lot more redundancies when all you need is a simple opamp. You instead build the thing beefy and resistant to the environment. And all the excitement over new chip plants by TSMC etc, won't do a thing for these automotive applications.
- xyzzy21 5y agoThere are classes ABOVE mil-spec. These are several "Space grade" classes above mil-spec which have far wider temperature and radiation ranges.
- rasz 5y ago>Your car is running a real-time simulation of your engine to keep itself operational, and it's a much serious business than running Android or iOS. Lets not exaggerate :) ECU reads a bunch of sensors, does some mild compute, uses that to do a table lookup, interpolates and slaps the result into actuators. 8bit 10MHz is enough to accomplish this task.
- bayindirh 5y agoThese are not my words. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30875680 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30875680
- calvinmorrison 5y ago> Your car is running a real-time simulation of your engine to keep itself operational, and it's a much serious business than running Android or iOS. Well, it takes some parameters, goes into a lookup table and decides how much timing to retard, or fuel to give, and probably has a o2 sensor, checks knocking, etc. All done on pretty barebones 80's tech.
- bayindirh 5y agoYou're right on the tables part, but these are the words of the guy who worked on BMW for 14 years, who's on the video. And, as a person who's doing simulation coding, I tend to behave to him about that. The relevant part starts here: https://media.ccc.de/v/32c3-7331-the_exhaust_emissions_scandal_dieselgate#t=2231 https://media.ccc.de/v/32c3-7331-the_exhaust_emissions_scand...