3 ms·
What really floors me is that people can compartmentalise so well that they'll read an article like this, nod, agree and then argue at a dinner party that we sh
by roenxi 5y ago
What really floors me is that people can compartmentalise so well that they'll read an article like this, nod, agree and then argue at a dinner party that we should keep centralising more power into government bodies. There is no workable scheme to mix large government and honest government - and no shining examples that I'm aware of where it has ever succeeded. People can look at the system which throws out (in quick succession) Obama, Trump, Biden and seriously claim it should be the major system that controls:
1. ...healthcare
2. ...who gets a bank account, what money gets spent on
3. ...which countries to invade
4. ...a lot of other stuff
I respect the position because I have no choice but how an entity that schizophrenic, over-stretched with responsibilities and mad with power is supposed to resist corruption I do not see. It is going to be a moral and administrative cesspit.
- yetihehe 5y agoTransparency+accountability seems to be best answer for corruption. If you can make deals for hidden reasons, you can hide from scrutiny. If you have transparency, you can start to apply accountability. Those making bad decisions should bear the consequences.
- civilized 5y agoTransparency and accountability are good but not quite what GP is talking about. The problem is that "we simply need to make the government good" is not realistic. That's the single biggest reason people want limited government.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI mean, there are other counties that do have large government that controls these things and also less corruption. There are also smaller governments with even more corruption, such as any small town with one racist or self-dealing sheriff. So idk, corruption and governing body size doesn’t seem correlated to me.
- civilized 5y agoI agree that it's not about small. I think it's about limited. There have to be limits on the government's power, whether they come from the constitution, the country's legal system, or the traditional culture and character of the people.
- amalcon 5y agoI don't think it's even possible to have a small government presiding over a large thing. That thing might be a region, an economy, or really anything -- as soon as the thing gets too many resources, the government either grows or is replaced. If you try to keep government small, you don't end up removing power and corruption. You just move them to other entities. Those other entities may not use the word government, but the word is obviously not the problem. It's easy enough to justify this by looking at the opposite end of the spectrum: are there any examples of small government that have succeeded other than by presiding over only very few resources? I'm having even more trouble thinking of any than thinking of examples of successful large government.
- ModernMech 5y ago> If you try to keep government small, you don't end up removing power and corruption. You just move them to other entities. This notion is not lost on those who are arguing the Federal government should be smaller.
- ip26 5y agoEssentially, the power vacuum theory.
- vintermann 5y agoCorruption is using public trust for private gain. It's quite independent of centralization, and it happens in all organizations, not only government ones. The countries seen as least corrupt by their citizens all have what you would call "large governments".
- roenxi 5y agoThose metrics probably tend to measure things like whether you have to pay unofficial bribes to officials as part of daily life. Picking on the US as an example of a low-corruption country, it is crystal clear that the major politicians are up to their neck in it. Bribery is all but the way politics works. And the Americans have very transparent politics compared to the EU. I expect the situation there is a lot more civilised in how much they advertise what is really going on. Nobody has come up with the philosophical tools that are needed for a public to assess how corrupt the government is and respond to it.
- vintermann 5y agoThe metric I referred to was perceptions of corruption. The US is 67th on that list. Americans have a really low impression of their representatives' fidelity, despite stuff like petty bribes being uncommon. https://www.transparency.org/en/cpi/2021 https://www.transparency.org/en/cpi/2021
- roenxi 5y agoReplying a bit quickly so you might want to edit it but, you say 67th and that is a misread. The US is actually 27th/28th on the list. It ranks pretty well. Particularly when the competition is somewhere like Denmark/Finland/New Zealand in slot one. I mean, sure. 6 million people is a mid-tier US state. There are probably some cracking good local councils out there too. The scale isn't impressive as far as 8 billion humans reckon it. If we want to break the world up into >1,000 countries with independent governments I'd consider that a step in the right direction for small government and cracking down on corruption.
- alexvoda 5y agoCorruption does not happen only at the governmental level. It happens in all hierarchies. The government is the one hierarchy so far that we have figured how to democratize. Corporations are also corrupt and are always autocratic.