4 ms·
Financing terrorists - and these "truckers" were nothing else, which led to the declaration of the emergency state, a legally defined mechanism! - will lead to
by mschuster91 5y ago
Financing terrorists - and these "truckers" were nothing else, which led to the declaration of the emergency state, a legally defined mechanism! - will lead to issues no matter if it's al-quaeda or y'all-quaeda.
The donors should be happy all they got was a temporary freeze on their bank accounts. Had it been Islamist terror they had donated to, the accounts would have been terminated and criminal charges levied.
- unmole 5y agoA few questions: 1. Is blocking roads and blowing horns is equivalent to crashing planes into buildings and setting off bombs? 2. Were the truckers designated a terrorist entity under the Anti-Terrorism Act? 3. Was there an actual legal prohibition against financially supporting them?
- hoseja 5y agoTerrorism is when you're inconvenient to a western government.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThis is whataboutery. At the very least the truckers were an extremely unpleasant and potentially dangerous nuisance for everyone in the vicinity. At worst were literally attempting regime change. They were also largely funded by the US far right, which has obvious links to Russia. In fact Russian propoganda was encouraging similar actions in the US and the EU. So of course they were defunded. It's always amusing to see libertarians complaining that a government shoots first - financially in this case, and only after a long delay - and asks questions later, when they're typically the people claiming loudly that far more extreme forms of violence are always legitimate in personal self-defence. Just as with Jan 6, most of these people should have been jailed and those from the US should have been banned from entering Canada again. Never mind the political angle, the nuisance and intimidation were more than enough to justify that.
- unmole 5y ago> This is whataboutery. It is not. The parent comment compared truckers to Al-Qaeda. I pointed out the ridiculouslness of it. > At worst were literally attempting regime change. Regime change? You seem to be using words that don't mean what you think they mean > They were also largely funded by the US far right And? > which has obvious links to Russia. Those links are not obvious to me at all. > It's always amusing to see libertarians Rule of law isn't something that only libertarians care about. It's the very basis of liberal democracy. I'm not going bother responding to the rest of your comment which quite frankly is unworthy of HN.
- josephg 5y agoI agree that the truckers were super disruptive. I’m glad some punitive action was taken. But freezing the bank accounts of people who donated to them without due process is beyond the pail. Given that cash is mostly dead as a result of covid, banking needs to be considered a basic right. It shouldn’t be able to be revoked simply because the government doesn’t like what you do with your money.
- halostatue 5y agoClaim made not in evidence. Legally frozen were the recipient accounts. Yes, contributors could have had their accounts frozen, but no evidence that the government ordered such an action on any donor.
- Bancakes 5y agoYou sound severely self-centric and antisocial. Protests are a movement, and the noise they make are the extended arm that you are to grab and hop onto.
- kurisufag 5y ago>It's always amusing to see libertarians complaining that a government shoots first - financially in this case, and only after a long delay - and asks questions later, when they're typically the people claiming loudly that far more extreme forms of violence are always legitimate in personal self-defence. do you regularly see libertarians advocating for shooting the friends & family of an attacker, in your own words, "after a long delay"? this is a very poor comparison.
- ctoth 5y agoI am curious if you generally feel comfortable with the government being able to retroactively define something as "terrorism" when it does not conform with your general political views. Personally I think this is a terrible idea whether or not I agree with the people being targeted.
- incomingpain 5y ago>I am curious if you generally feel comfortable with the government being able to retroactively define something as "terrorism" when it does not conform with your general political views. Personally I think this is a terrible idea whether or not I agree with the people being targeted. There's a hilarious video from our parliament. Andrew Scheer(former conservative leader, former opposition leader) was talking. Elizabeth May(former green party leader) got up and started accusing him of 'dogwhistles to nazis' blah blah. Andrew Scheer stands up with the biggest smile. He points out Elizabeth May has been arrested and convicted of an illegal blockade while being green party leader. That the precedent set will mean that the green party donaters will have their bank accounts seized as well as her own. The irony, it's only matter of time that conservatives take government back and very well can do this now. On twitter a ton of greenpeace and antifa people freaked out at this new precedent. "What if I donate to greenpeace. Some point later they have a protest that goes sideways. My bank account gets seized?" Yep.
- formerkrogeremp 5y agoIt sounds the argument being made here is that this was a dangerous precedent being made that can be abused by political parties against their political opponents. This seems to be presented by you with apparent glee as a conservative vs green party/greenpeace/"antifa" or liberal issue. What you'll actually find is that broader society is just intolerant of the economic duress and disruptions caused by such protests. Up to a quarter of Canadian-US trade was going through that area, and real people were suffering due to the trucker blockade. These economic disruptions had secondary effects that impact the lingering impacts of the pandemic and exacerbated supply chain issues. There is not a whit of moral equivalency between climate change protests and some truckers afraid of a needle.
- cscurmudgeon 5y agoThe double standard here is quite interesting. Trudeau backed the farmer's protest in India. Those protests were much more deadly. https://www.timesnownews.com/international/article/when-the-tables-turn-canadian-pm-justin-trudeau-who-backed-farmers-protests-in-india-asks-protesters-in-his-country-to-stop/856885 https://www.timesnownews.com/international/article/when-the-... Trudeau on protests in India: > “I would be remiss if I didn’t start by recognising the news coming from India about the protest by farmers. The situation is concerning. We are all very worried about family and friends. We know that’s a reality for many of you. Let me remind you, Canada will always be there to defend the rights of peaceful protesters. We believe in the process of dialogue. We’ve reached out through multiple means to the Indian authorities to highlight our concerns. This is a moment for all of us to pull together,” Trudeau had said in November 2021. Those were in fact not peaceful > 1 journalist killed. One person lynched for alleged desecration. Over 1,500 telecom tower sites damaged by protestors (as of 28 Dec). Government buses and 30 police vehicles damaged on Republic Day. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020–2021_Indian_farmers%27_protest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020–2021_Indian_farmers%27_pr...
- rosndo 5y agoIn the statement you quoted he seems to carefully avoid backing the protesting farmers, no? I really don’t see how you could reasonably read that as a statement of support.
- cscurmudgeon 5y agoHe backs peaceful protests. Why not condem the violent portions of the same protest? Why not similarly back the democratic legal processes? Or are Canada's laws more sacred than India's laws? Why not supoort peaceful protests in Canada?
- incomingpain 5y agoHere's the other reality. https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/to-tackle-vaccine-hesitancy-canada-can-t-ignore-race-racism-health-experts-1.5234212 https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/to-tackle-vaccine-... Race plays a role in vaccination. Black and Indigenous Canadians are only around 50% vaccinated. Indian/Punjabis are somewhere around 70%. An awful lot of truckers are Indian. Especially from Quebec. One of the original key issues that sparked this protest is the action by Trudeau to ban unvaccinated truckers and put them out of a job. This disproportionately harmed racial minorities including Indians. The comparison or hypocrisy is that he supported the indian farmers but called the punjabi truckers a bunch of racists. It blows my mind.