3 ms·
It depends. I don't think anyone sees OCW as a substitute for going to school at MIT. That's the whole point. If it were successful, it would be (a substitute)
by netcan 18y ago
It depends. I don't think anyone sees OCW as a substitute for going to school at MIT.
That's the whole point. If it were successful, it would be (a substitute). What you are saying is that it isn't a problem, because it's' not too successful.
I'd also argue that universities serve other roles beyond education.
Education is what pins it all together. Imagine a future where degrees are not University centred, courses are available online & testing/evaluation is gets solved separately from the institutions. For one thing, filtering is not necessary. There's infinite room in every degree so if any filtering is done, it needs to be done as part of the testing/evaluation. Universities are a shell in this world. Parents are not likely to cough up the $$ they do currently, for students to make friends.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- aneesh 18y agoIf it were successful, it would be (a substitute). I disagree with that definition of success. OCW is very successful -- its goal is fundamentally different from the degree-granting part of MIT. Success for OCW means that everyone who wants to access university-level content can do it for free. If MIT wants to charge tuition for the "premium" version where you live on campus, can ask questions of the professors, get to know your classmates, get a degree, etc, then they certainly have the right to. That is a scarce resource, and can command a price like many other scarce resources people pay for.
- netcan 18y agoI disagree with that definition of success. Fair enough, but I hope it's not just a matter of semantics. My definition of the success for making educational materials available is making education available. The absolute goal would be 'the best education.' I admit, this is probably not the goal of this particular project. Universities have an inherent interest in maintaining a big enough gap between free & premium education. It seems to me that you're objections are base on an assumption that education cannot be acquired outside of institutions with an equivalent quality or ease. No chance. Universities don't have to worry about that, so no conflict.