5 ms·
Data centers are a hard sell in general because they don't really provide too much benefit to a community. They run on minimal labor, whether skilled or unskill
by paxys 5y ago
Data centers are a hard sell in general because they don't really provide too much benefit to a community. They run on minimal labor, whether skilled or unskilled, so the job creation argument doesn't work. They have huge energy requirements, which is a burden on the regional grid. And residents of an area won't really care that the Facebook latency of all of Western Europe could improve by a few milliseconds because of their sacrifice.
- fivea 5y ago> Data centers are a hard sell in general because they don't really provide too much benefit to a community. The Netherlands is already the home of some FANGs (AWS has a few edge locations in Amsterdam) and dominant hosting providers such as Cloudflare. I'm sure they'll be able to overcome the loss of Facebook.
- lucb1e 5y agoI agree (aside from that AWS might think twice about where to strategically expand further given how politics treated Facehook) but I don't get how this is related to what you quoted or any other part of GP's comment.
- smartbit 5y ago> given how politics treated Facehook According to today’s NRC coverstory it was the opposite: the project failed because of the aggressive lobbying demanding an exception. And Meta refusing to discuss their datacentre design. IOW it failed because of the way that Facebook treated politics. https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2022/03/30/agressieve-lobby-voor-datacentrum-in-zeewolde-nekte-facebook-a4105867 https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2022/03/30/agressieve-lobby-voor-d...
- fivea 5y ago> (...) but I don't get how this is related to what you quoted or any other part of GP's comment. If you read about the topic you'll soon discover that Meta/Facebook has been systematically imposing demands for preferential treatment, including demanding circumventing laws to allow agricultural land, some of which they don't even own, to instead be used to build high-density industrial buildings. This, in a country where Amazon and Microsoft already operate their own data centers. In fact, Facebook rejected the location already used by Amazon and Microsoft, and instead decided to force their way somewhere else. It's also worth mentioning some of the apparent corruption aspects of Facebook's deal, abusing preferential rights of the municipality to exclude competing bids.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mhb 5y agoDon't they pay for the energy they use? Isn't there a price for the energy that would make it appealing for the community to have them there?
- reaperducer 5y agoIf Facebook paid its electric bill to the neighbors, sure. But it doesn't. We live in an age of energy scarcity. So even if people think about the electricity it uses, people probably see a data center as slurping up energy, causing prices for regular people to rise.
- dspillett 5y agoIf the local grid can't provide that then upgrades are needed. They may pay enough for that but then the energy needs to be sourced, which may mean extra fossil fuels and potentially breaking promises made on move-in towards a higher % renewable use. It can be about more than the financial price. Even if it was about the cost of sourcing and provision, someone that big will bargain down close to the minimum. There will be little benefit to share around elsewhere, unless of course this is made specifically part of the bargain (they can build, in exchange _they_ improve local infrastructure to cope, as greenly as the locals desire, with stated benefits for the area with compensation clauses for if said benefits don't turn up).
- david38 5y agoEnergy is their #1 cost so they bargain heavily for large subsidies.
- lucb1e 5y agoSo the problem is whoever is in charge to say yes to discounts? Genuinely wondering because I keep not understanding this situation and I'm Dutch. Indeed, if people worry about that it'll use up all the green energy then let facebook pay for replacement renewable infrastructure that supplies MW equal to what they use, to be placed and functional anywhere in NL within X (1?) year(s) after the datacenter is turned on (we're not that big, we can swallow those transmission losses).
- ashtonkem 5y agoThey tend to go through a lot of water too, which is the big issue with the datacenter Meta wants to put in a town nearby to me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- darknavi 5y agoI'm out of the loop on data center design. How do they "go through" water? I'd imaging they pipe some in, use to cool, and then pipe it out.
- oh_sigh 5y agoSome percentage of it is lost to evaporation (fairly obvious if you see a big steam cloud coming out of a tower). How much that is...I have no idea. I don't think any place on earth forces big tech companies to report on the environmental impact and resource usage of their data centers. In fact, I think a lot of companies view these details as a competitive advantage and intentionally keep these facts secret even from non-datacenter folk in the same company.
- jreese 5y agoMany FB datacenters use evaporative cooling systems rather than traditional A/C, basically spraying water into the incoming air supply to cool it below outdoor ambient temperatures. The hotter it is outside, the more water is needed to cool the air, trading temperature for humidity. But this water can't easily be recaptured without using significantly more energy than normal A/C, so the evaporated water is exhausted as part of the hot air from the DC aisles.
- hetspookjee 5y agoDon’t forget the added coalents to the water that are dumped back! I’m still curiou to hear what the composition of these chemicals is but appearantly not s single data center is able to tell oddly enough.
- dominotw 5y ago> Data centers are a hard sell How did they convince existing locations if there is no upside for the community.
- TomVDB 5y agoProbably the same way sports teams convince communities to build subsidized stadiums: with unrealistic projections about jobs and trickle down benefits.
- jbverschoor 5y agoBribes. False promises about job creation. Politicians with wrong incentives, being starstruck, or who simply don’t understand what a datacenter is
- dominotw 5y agoi guess netherlands has more honest politicians.