4 ms·
First, for reasons I don’t understand very well yet, transmitting is very different than receiving. People are not transmitting AM signals from portable radios.
by CamperBob2 5y ago
First, for reasons I don’t understand very well yet, transmitting is very different than receiving. People are not transmitting AM signals from portable radios.
Not actually correct at a conceptual level. Antenna reciprocity is as close to an immutable law of physics as we tend to get.
However, numerous practical concerns will interfere if you try to use a small ferrite loopstick antenna in a high power AM broadcast transmitter. In principle, a transmitter could match the E field of a small metal terminal to much longer wavelength using series inductance (more or less amounting to a Tesla coil), or it could match a ferrite inductor to the H field with parallel capacitance, as an old-school pocket transistor radio does. But the field components near the antenna would be insanely high, causing dielectric losses, corona discharge, or induction heating of everything in the vicinity.
So there's often no practical way to take advantage of the theoretical equivalence of transmission and reception. At low power levels it will work as expected, but things fall apart in a hurry as the power goes up.
(And yes, a portable AM radio like the one in the article does transmit. Get two of them, tune in a weak station on one, then tune the other one 455 kHz below the first, and you'll hear a beat note. This will be noticeable with the radios positioned several meters away from each other.)