3 ms·
I've certainly found it useless, and when I need a decongestant I make certain I'm getting actual pseudoephedrine. The 12 and 24 hour slow-release versions are
by jfengel 5y ago
I've certainly found it useless, and when I need a decongestant I make certain I'm getting actual pseudoephedrine. The 12 and 24 hour slow-release versions are fantastic. I've never done a proper blind trial on myself, but I feel quite certain that I could tell the difference.
I suppose people must be buying it, and given how strong placebo effects are in general I guess it's doing something for them.
- nvahalik 5y agoSame here. Actual Sudafed works for me and anything else I think generally only tends to work with whatever NSAID they bundle with it.
- tcherasaro 5y agoSame, Sudafed is a silver bullet for me. The 12 hour release absolutely works to clear my sinuses and relieves the sinus pressure headache (almost completely when combined with ibuprofen). My wife insists Phenylephrine works for her and thats all she will take. She has offered it to me a couple times when we didn’t have any Sudafed and Phenylephrine had 0 noticeable effects for me. Edit: I forgot to add that Alavert-D 12 also has Pseudoephedrine and works for me too and is what I take when my congestion is allergy related.
- mh- 5y agoOne of many such studies: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19230461/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19230461/ Keep in mind this doesn't say that it's not effective. It's just not more so than the placebo effect, which is quite real even on physiological matters.
- thehappypm 5y agoThe article suggests the uptake is widely variable person to person so perhaps she’s just a lucky one.