3 ms·
Anything that changed radically since 2021? "Waymo and Cruise self-driving cars took over San Francisco streets at record levels in 2021 — so did collisions wi
by belter 5y ago
Anything that changed radically since 2021?
"Waymo and Cruise self-driving cars took over San Francisco streets at record levels in 2021 — so did collisions with other cars, scooters, and bikes" [1]
"...Many of the accidents, which the companies are required to report to the California Department of Motor Vehicles, occurred while the vehicles were operating in manual mode, with a safety driver in control.
...But according to an analysis by Insider, a majority of the 98 reported accidents in 2021 occurred while the vehicles were in autonomous mode, or within seconds after the autonomous mode technology had been switched off..."
[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/self-driving-car-accidents-waymo-cruise-tesla-zoox-san-francisco-2022-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/self-driving-car-accidents-w...
- mdorazio 5y agoYou really need to look at which vehicles were at fault in these accidents. In the vast majority of cases, it's not the autonomous vehicle.
- wolverine876 5y agoWhere is this data?
- belter 5y ago"...Waymo sued the California DMV this week to prevent it from revealing certain information about its cars' performance, including Waymo's internal analyses of collisions. Waymo argued that the information, including any "potential technological remediations," represents a trade secret that would have "a chilling effect across the industry" if released, and would dissuade potential market participants from investing time and resources into developing self-driving cars..." Now the question is, did the government officials who approved this, been given access to this data? And if not, why not?
- grandmczeb 5y agoWhat government officials are you referring to? These are disclosures made to the DMV, so obviously they have access. Maybe you mean the court? But they have access too as part of the lawsuit... so I'm not sure what you're talking about.
- belter 5y agoSo do you mean a private company just decided to move to driverless rides with no required approval from any supervising government official? Is this like Boeing self-certification or even worst because they need no approvals at all?
- grandmczeb 5y agoNo? What about my response indicated that? They got a whole slew of approvals from the CPUC and DMV.
- grandmczeb 5y agoI don't know if there's anywhere that goes through and categorizes who's at fault, but you can look at the collision reports from the CA DMV. E.g. the report from March 9th: > The Waymo AV was stopped in traffic, eastbound on Irving Street in autonomous mode. A parked car to the right of the Waymo AV began reversing into the street and made contact with the rear right side of the Waymo AV. https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/vehicle-industry-services/autonomous-vehicles/autonomous-vehicle-collision-reports/ https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/vehicle-industry-services/auto...
- grandmczeb 5y agoCan't read the article because of the paywall, but just because an accident "occurred while the vehicles were in autonomous mode, or within seconds after the autonomous mode technology had been switched off" doesn't mean the collision was the car's fault. The real question is how many of those accidents would have been prevented if a human was driving.
- shkkmo 5y agoI'm not sure what you are getting at? As that article notes, in 2021 accidents only doubled while the autonomously driven miles more than tripled? Waymo has been scaling their level of testing with their level of safety. What has changed is that Waymo think they are safe enough to start doing more widespread testing in SF without a safety driver. This seems to be a strong counter to all those who were claiming that level 4 self-driving cars would be limited to flat, dry climates for the forseable future.