3 ms·
This is (hopefully) overly cynical, but having worked in and closely with politicians in the past, I highly doubt it. There are surely interest groups and thin
by freedomben 5y ago
This is (hopefully) overly cynical, but having worked in and closely with politicians in the past, I highly doubt it.
There are surely interest groups and think thanks that are working on the problem, and they will (if they don't already), have some legislation either ready to go or close to it.
The politicians won't even think about it until it becomes an actual problem that threatens votes, and when they do start caring they will just take whatever they can get from friendly/trusted think tanks and try to ram it through. The bills will be thousands of pages long and practically nobody will read them before voting for them.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoGood. Law should always lag social consensus. The power of the state should not be thrown around at the behest of unaccountable experts or a razor's edge majority. It should require the support and consent of the bulk of the people.
- HWR_14 5y ago> Law should always lag social consensus. Oh fuck no. Social consensus is too slow. Look at the social consensus that tracking was bad followed expert consensus by like a decade, and really only started appearing after EU regulation.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe "experts" also thought if Vietnam went communist the whole continent would. The "experts" gave us the war on drugs. The fatherless black household and the lazy black man weren't stereotypes until the "experts" tried to help minorities. How many lives are you willing to ruin and how much blood are you willing to spill getting things wrong? The power of the state shouldn't be thrown around on a whim or subject to subject specific industry fads and circle jerks.
- eptcyka 5y agoI don't believe that there's a right answer that will fit all cases here - for issues like same sex marriage, you can find all permutations of social acceptance and lawful acceptance all over earth, yet I think it's hard to justify any position besides lawful and social acceptance.
- jjoonathan 5y agoSo if you don't touch the lever on the trolley you aren't responsible for the millions of people it plows through on the default track? Uh-huh. Keep telling yourself that. Look, I invest in companies that stand to benefit in this transition and I want my stonks to go up -- but I'm horrified by the apathetic excuses people toss out to rationalize ignoring the externalities. Strengthening the safety net is the least we can do. "What if we get it wrong?" sounds an awful lot like "it's gonna cost money and I don't want to pay" to my ears.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoHistory is littered with the stories of people who thought the end justified the means. The 20th century eugenicists thought they were improving humanity. The people who tried to civilize the natives with Christianity thought they were saving them from eternal suffering. The "if the .gov doesn't get involved things will go to shit and you'll be sorry" stuff you are saying is basically what people who were ardent proponents of things like restrictive zoning were saying and we all know how well that worked. I'm not saying don't do anything. I'm saying it's more than ill-advised to get the vast resources of the modern state involved in things on the whims of "experts" because hubris abounds.
- freedomben 5y agoI think you and GP are both right. The Trolly Problem is legit and real. OTOH humans (especially those exercising any sort of power) are grossly incompetent, arrogant, and good at leaving trails of suffering behind them. I also think you're not really disagreeing. GP is talking about specific implementations while you are talking about high level philosophy.