2 ms·
3He has almost exactly the availability of tritium, around here, because (almost) every last atom of tritium you manufacture will, in pretty short order, becom
by ncmncm 5y ago
3He has almost exactly the availability of tritium, around here, because (almost) every last atom of tritium you manufacture will, in pretty short order, become 3He, unless you go fusing it first.
It seems likely that the atmosphere of Neptune has a useful fraction of 3He. But you need to get there first, with apparatus to collect it. For that, you probably need a fusion rocket, and 3He to burn in it.
- adrian_b 5y ago3He can be produced, as you say, by storing the tritium and waiting for it to decay. Making the tritium requires another fusion or fission reactor, in which case there is no point in trying to develop a 3He fusion reactor, because it will be advantageous only if it can replace the fission reactors and the "dirty" fusion reactors. If those are still needed to produce the nuclear fuel, nothing is gained by using 3He. If there would have existed a natural source of sufficient 3He, then things would have been very different and the deuterium-3He fusion would have been the top priority in fusion research. A much more likely use of 3He is inside the so-called tritium-suppressed deuterium-deuterium fusion reactors. The deuterium-deuterium reactions produce both tritium and 3He. If the tritium is removed continuously from the fusion reactor, then it is stored for a long enough time until it decays into 3He, and then it is fed back into the fusion reactor, that fusion reactor would use only deuterium as primary input fuel and because it will fuse internally larger quantities of 3He than of tritium, it will produce a flux of neutrons significantly lower than a standard deuterium-deuterium fusion reactor, even if not so low as a reactor that could use 3He as a primary input fuel. This idea is promising, but the conditions for deuterium-deuterium fusion are more difficult to attain than for deuterium-tritium fusion. Moreover, all the papers that I have seen about this concentrated on the great advantages that would happen if one would remove the tritium from the reactor as soon as it is produced, but none of them mentioned the practical means to do this. Removing promptly the tritium from the plasma of a fusion reactor is something much easier said than done.
- ncmncm 5y agoThere are circumstances where fusing 3He is useful even where you have to make it yourself, first. Use as spacecraft fuel is just such a circumstance. It is yet to be seen whether remote laser or local fusion will be more useful for powering outer-solar-system spacecraft. If you only need neutrons to make 3H, they don't need to be hot, and are more useful cold.